Skip to content

Why are there conspiracy theories?

What is the psychology of fake news?

Stolen elections. Phony pandemics. Faked moon landings. Lizard people. It’s not just Americans who love a good conspiracy theory; it seems to be a trait shared by humans everywhere. It is a curious paradox that in the Age of Information — when all of our acquired knowledge is available at the click of a button or the tap of a screen — that we should choose to believe lies and fiction rather than truth and facts. Why? The answer involves a combination of psychology, widespread distrust, and malevolent actors. Propaganda has existed since humans were able to speak and write, but now, those lies can circle the globe within seconds. Here, we tackle one of the hardest problems facing the world today: how to inform a public that prefers to be misinformed.


Viewpoints
Well, first of all I think there’s a gene.
I think there’s a gene for superstition, a gene for hearsay, a gene for magic, a gene for magical thinking. And I think that when we were in the forest that gene actually helped us because nine times out of ten that gene was wrong. Superstition didn’t work. But one time out of ten it saved your butt. That’s why the gene is still here. The gene for superstition and magic. Now there’s no gene for science. Science is based on things that are reproducible, testable. It’s a long process the scientific method. It’s not part of our natural thinking.
Michio Kaku
Professor of Theoretical Physics, CUNY
…I’ve been messing around with this idea of cognitive dissonance.
This is to say you have a world view. You’re presented with evidence that conflicts with the world view so you either have to change your world view, which is hard because you’ve lived your whole life with it, or you just dismiss the evidence and dismiss the authorities that may have provided the evidence. The authority could be a person or it could be a book or, excuse me, an article on the electric internet computer machine. So you dismiss the evidence so that you don’t have this discomfort, this conflict in your mind, this dissonance.
Bill Nye, The Science Guy
The Science Guy
Thinking about reptoids controlling our government.
There have always been people who believed these sort of strange things but what social media and the internet in general has allowed to happen is for people with these beliefs to find each other and then when they’re hearing back those same sorts of facts, those same sorts of theories then their beliefs strengthen.
Sarah Rose Cavanagh
Psychologist
What the skeptical movement has developed is a set of tools like the baloney detection kit.
A set of tools to deal with particular claims that are on the margins of science like creationism, intelligent design theory, the anti-vaccinations, the holocaust revisionists. All these conspiracy theories and so on and all these alternative medicines. There’s hundreds and hundreds of these claims that are all connected to different sciences. But the scientists in those particular fields are too busy working in their research to bother with what these claims are because the claims really aren’t about those fields. They’re just hooked to them. They’re about something else.
Michael Shermer
Founding Publisher, Skeptic Magazine
The way we get the information 24 hour bombardment…
…makes people feel afraid and you’ve got a lot of people who feel like dangerous shut-ins who are railing against how said things are or dropping out because they’re overwhelmed. And because of that dropout and that polarization you get a regime like Trump. You get a fertile ground for fascism which is about blaming someone irrationally for other problems in your life. It’s an old game that has been played for millennia. That immigrant, that transgender person, that person who is of a different race their very existence threatens you because they’re getting attention, money. They’re stealing something from you and that certainly found its way into a World War II, but also the fragile state of truth right now which also comes out of digital addiction is that all conspiracy theories are true. All news is suspect. Facts are fungible. And in a world like that, that’s the biggest danger.
John Cameron Mitchell
Filmmaker, Actor & Writer

Psychology of conspiracy theories

“A lot of blame gets laid at the feet of smartphones,…”

“…at the feet of technology for driving us apart that we’re holding these screens between us and it’s disconnecting us. I think there are unhealthy ways to use smartphones and social media and that we should focus on ways to use those technologies more helpfully. But I think that a lot of our current woes may not be sourced in this technology. It may be sourced in how our society is structured. The level of inequality that we currently have that is growing by the day. The level at which our communities are not connected. That we enshrine ambition over altruism and which we are expected, the whole phenomenon of burnout has gotten a lot of attention recently because we are expected to just achieve and achieve and achieve. I think that our basic happiness lies in each other and then lies in those connections and that we in some ways can use these technologies to shore up those connections rather than to isolate ourselves.”


the wildest conspiracy theories

4. Aliens regularly come to Earth

Among the surveyed, 45% are pretty sure of the existence of aliens. Of those people, 27% think they are just hiding from people on Earth while 18% are confident that the authorities know all about that and are just keeping the regular citizens in the dark.


Fake news

What I’d like to see is a whole bunch of news outlets first commit to being trustworthy.

And they do that by signing up for the Trust Project principles. Then I’d like to see them now and then have someone serve as a watchdog, maybe via the International Fact-Checkers Network, which is basically a network of networks. I would like to see fact checkers – in the network or out – submit results that they find to the emerging database done at Tech & Check where a claim, which is fact-checked, could be registered in that manner using a standard database layout. I’d like to see nutrition labels generated by the folks there. 


“And so it’s that process of triangulation,…”

“…where you’re looking for other experts who will validate that this source or this idea is credible, is really, like, the critical component of figuring out what to believe. And people think, we all think — and this is true with human beings and it’s true with news or online sources — we all think we’re very good judges of who’s lying and who’s telling the truth. But we’re very susceptible to, you know, is it a beautiful serif font that it’s presented in or is it something that looks lower grade; is the person charismatic or are they stuttering. These cues turn out not to have very much to do with whats credible or not. But we’re very susceptible to them, and so that’s why sort of looking at who else believes that this is credible is a really important part of the process.”