David Goggins
Former Navy Seal
Career Development
Bryan Cranston
Critical Thinking
Liv Boeree
International Poker Champion
Emotional Intelligence
Amaryllis Fox
Former CIA Clandestine Operative
Chris Hadfield
Retired Canadian Astronaut & Author
from the world's big
Start Learning

Depressed Fish May Seem Like a Joke to You, But It’s Serious to Them

Scientists realize that fish are sentient and intelligent, though unfortunately, they also get depressed.


Dog and cat owners and animal lovers believe that animals carry some sort of human-like thought. Some may say it’s just anthropomorphizing, but we’re pretty convinced that our pets are "happy" or "sad" or whatever we want to project on them. Obviously we can’t just ask them — at least for now — but as scientists learn more and more about animal intelligence, it’s safe to say that fewer people see our companions as acting purely from instinct. Nonetheless, even some animal lovers have trouble believing that fish are self-aware and have feelings — after all, they’re as expressionless as… (most) cats. To some scientists, though, it’s become clear that fish not only have emotions, but that they’re subject to depression.

One such scientist is Julian Pittman, who is using them to develop treatments for human depression, especially since there’s some physiological overlap with us. “The neurochemistry is so similar that it’s scary,” he recently told New York Times. Pittman considers fish — he works with zebrafish — useful for testing the efficacy of antidepressants because it’s so easy to read their emotional state.

Pittman’s lab uses something called the “novel tank test.” When fish are introduced to a new environment such an unfamiliar tank, they’ll normally explore its upper reaches. If they’re depressed, however, they stay in the lower reaches of the new space.

Normal exploratory behavior (TROY UNIVERSITY)

Depressed behavior (TROY UNIVERSITY)

To depress fish for testing purposes, Pittman’s team gets them drunk on ethanol for two weeks before abruptly forcing them into stressful withdrawal. (It’s worth considering the ethical implications: If an animal can be depressed, many would find it morally questionable to deliberately induce a state of suffering you acknowledge is real.)

Is depression even the right word? It’s hard to say. While we can’t know for certain what this emotional state feels like to a fish — we barely know what other people really feel like — we can be reasonably sure that the behavior researchers are seeing signifies a dispiritedness, de-motivation, or at the very least, a state of demobilizing anxiety.

It’s clear that fish are far more intellectually capable than previously assumed. Conventional wisdom holds that they barely have any memory, but studies have shown this to be untrue. In experiments conducted by researchers from University of Oxford and the University of Queensland, four archerfish, a creature that shoots water to take down insect prey, were trained to expect a reward when they shot water at the picture of one of two faces. While one archerfish got it after about 30 trials; the others took longer. What’s remarkable is that when they were shown 44 images images of faces they hadn’t previous seen, they spat at the right person with up to 89% accuracy.

An archerfish (JOSH MORE)

One research group that’s been concentrating on the the capabilities of fish is the Fish Lab, led by Culum Brown, and part of the Department of Biological Sciences at Macquarie University in Sydney, Australia. The often-cited Brown has studied fish sentience and intelligence extensively, and his Fish Cognition and Behavior is now in its second printing. Research shows, he says, that, “fish perception and cognitive abilities often match or exceed other vertebrates,” adding, “fish have a high degree of behavioral plasticity and compare favorably to humans and other terrestrial vertebrates across a range of intelligence tests.”

Brown tells The Dodo, “The big issue here is that people don't treat fish the same way as they do other animals. It's complicated, but it boils down to the fact that most people just don't understand them and can't relate to them. If you don't have that connection, you are less likely to feel any empathy.”

Even so, he lists some of the things scientists now understand about fish:

  • They can perform multiple complex tasks simultaneously due to cerebral lateralization, a trait that was until recently thought to be uniquely human.
  • They can recall the location of objects using feature cues, a capacity developed by humans at approximately the age of six.
  • Fish have excellent long-term memories.
  • They cooperate with one another and show signs of Machiavellian intelligence such as cooperation and reconciliation
  • Fish can use tools, another "in a long list of skills that was supposed to be unique to humans."
  • In this case, the tool is a rock against which the fish smashes clams (LABORATORY EQUIPMENT)

    “Each animal is unique, has an identity and a personality. Each is special,” concludes Culum in his talk with The Dodo, so, “animals should be treated with respect, and we have a duty of care towards them that demands that we reduce pain and suffering wherever possible.”

    The fish most of us have in our lives are goldfish, and New York Times asked Penn State University’s Victoria Braithwaite what to do for if yours seems to have become lethargic and withdrawn. “One of the things we’re finding is that fish are naturally curious and seek novel things out,” and so she suggests giving your fish something new to do, maybe by moving things around in the tank or adding new objects. Brown’s research shows that fish respond well to complex tank environments, with edible plants and things to swim through. He says that such amusements decrease stress and even promote brain growth.

    Tippi’s happy. Edible plants coming soon. (ROBBY BERMAN)

    LIVE ON MONDAY | "Lights, camera, activism!" with Judith Light

    Join multiple Tony and Emmy Award-winning actress Judith Light live on Big Think at 2 pm ET on Monday.

    Big Think LIVE

    Add event to calendar

    AppleGoogleOffice 365OutlookOutlook.comYahoo

    Keep reading Show less

    8 logical fallacies that are hard to spot

    From "if-by-whiskey" to the McNamara fallacy, being able to spot logical missteps is an invaluable skill.

    Photo: Shutterstock
    Mind & Brain
    • A fallacy is the use of invalid or faulty reasoning in an argument.
    • There are two broad types of logical fallacies: formal and informal.
    • A formal fallacy describes a flaw in the construction of a deductive argument, while an informal fallacy describes an error in reasoning.
    Keep reading Show less

    Space travel could create language unintelligible to people on Earth

    A new study looks at what would happen to human language on a long journey to other star systems.

    Cylindrical space colony.

    Credit: NASA Ames Research Center.
    Surprising Science
    • A new study proposes that language could change dramatically on long space voyages.
    • Spacefaring people might lose the ability to understand the people of Earth.
    • This scenario is of particular concern for potential "generation ships".
    Keep reading Show less

    Your emotions are the new hot commodity — and there’s an app for that

    Many of the most popular apps are about self-improvement.

    Drew Angerer/Getty Images
    Personal Growth

    Emotions are the newest hot commodity, and we can't get enough.

    Keep reading Show less
    Scroll down to load more…