Unbounded Rationality & Its Consequences

We should know that we can't know it all. Yet the results of using the opposite idea, of "unbounded rationality,” are widely influential (usually farcically mixed with asymmetrically applied “unintended consequences”). Here's why neither sports nor markets need "less regulation":

It should not be news that we can’t know it all (ignorance is unavoidable). But the results of using the opposite notion, of “unbounded rationality,” remain influential, often bizarrely mixed with asymmetrically applied ideas about “unintended consequences.”

1. “Unbounded rationality” is built into many economic models (which are deemed to confer near “sacredness” on free market results). For example decisions are assumed to meet demanding standards of “completeness.” Sadly models incorporating “bounded rationality” (our cognitive and data limits) are harder and hence used limitedly).

2. Hayek said "all political theories assume...that most individuals are very ignorant," adding that everyone inevitably suffers some ignorance (information incompleteness). Hayek reasoned that although we each can only have limited data, that collectively is more information than any central planning could have, so “spontaneous order” is better.

3. Markets = data processing systems: But Hayek’s spontaneous order ignores cases needing nondispersible data (see 9 below). Free markets only process one kind of data in one way (hardwired reflex responses to prices varying one-dimensionally, up or down). That’s like having no central nervous system, or calculating with only one kind of data and no CPU.

4. “Unintended consequences” = unavoidable: Hayek cautioned “we ought not to increase...unpredictability.” Yet many now aggressively promote unregulated innovation (=lower predictability).

5. Regulation “risks all sorts of unintended consequences.” True, but in nonstatic conditions, so does inaction. And free market “invisible handers” depend on its unintended effects (typically miscast as always benign).

6. “Permissionless innovation” promoters risk structural non-science-ness. Its “free-market think tank” developer has openly declared biases in its assumptions and goals (pre-assuming freer markets are better). Physical (reality refereed) sciences aren’t precommitted to particular assumptions or results, only to rigorous bias balancing processes.

7. Seeking less regulation is often just make-my-life-easier whining. All businesses should want good regulation, and dislike bad regulation. That distinction matters. Rules and referees are required to ensure fairness and safety in sports—and markets.

8. Can we trust the mindless coordination of markets to handle the future’s "voyage into the unknown”? What if some element of central steering, or guidance, or intelligent nonlocal adjustment, is needed? Perhaps that’s why central nervous systems evolved. They can beat distributed reflex-only systems.  

9. Markets solve many problems well. But not all (e.g., Darwin’s Wedges, or where externalities lower costs for all transactors). Without guidance/regulation markets do only one kind of coordination: “deciding” via incomplete prices and often imprudentcustomer choices (like a mass tug-of-war with millions of players pulling on separate ropes).

Central guidance/steering isn’t “central planning” (both Hayek and Adam Smith saw this). It’s more like steering a ship and regularly adjusting to changing conditions and observed effects). We must use what is foreseeable to prepare prudently for what isn’t.

Illustration by Julia Suits, The New Yorker cartoonist & author of The Extraordinary Catalog of Peculiar Inventions



Big Think Edge
  • The meaning of the word 'confidence' seems obvious. But it's not the same as self-esteem.
  • Confidence isn't just a feeling on your inside. It comes from taking action in the world.
  • Join Big Think Edge today and learn how to achieve more confidence when and where it really matters.
  • Prejudice is typically perpetrated against 'the other', i.e. a group outside our own.
  • But ageism is prejudice against ourselves — at least, the people we will (hopefully!) become.
  • Different generations needs to cooperate now more than ever to solve global problems.

Active ingredient in Roundup found in 95% of studied beers and wines

The controversial herbicide is everywhere, apparently.

Surprising Science
  • U.S. PIRG tested 20 beers and wines, including organics, and found Roundup's active ingredient in almost all of them.
  • A jury on August 2018 awarded a non-Hodgkin's lymphoma victim $289 million in Roundup damages.
  • Bayer/Monsanto says Roundup is totally safe. Others disagree.
Keep reading Show less

Scientists see 'rarest event ever recorded' in search for dark matter

The team caught a glimpse of a process that takes 18,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 years.

Image source: Pixabay
Surprising Science
  • In Italy, a team of scientists is using a highly sophisticated detector to hunt for dark matter.
  • The team observed an ultra-rare particle interaction that reveals the half-life of a xenon-124 atom to be 18 sextillion years.
  • The half-life of a process is how long it takes for half of the radioactive nuclei present in a sample to decay.
Keep reading Show less