Paradox-free time travel is 'logically' possible, say physicists

Grandfathers, take heart. You'll survive the paradox that's been gunning for you since the 1930s.

Paradox-free time travel is 'logically' possible, say physicists
Credit: Warner Bros
  • For a century, the specter of paradoxes has loomed over physics theories and science fiction scripts.
  • A University of Queensland undergraduate and his supervisor ran the numbers and found paradox-free time travel to be mathematically consistent.
  • But the practical hurdles to time travel vastly out distance the mathematical ones.

    • Science fiction requires its fans to suspend their disbelief, and there's no greater ask in that department than when trying to enjoy a time travel story. Writers twist their plots into Gordian knots to explain how time travel could logically work in their futuristic worlds. When the simplest explanation is, it probably doesn't.

      Many physicists have agreed with that assessment. Einstein wondered whether time travel—more specifically ramifications of Gödel's universe—could be "excluded on physical grounds." In a 1992 paper, Stephen Hawking coined the "chronology-protection conjecture." That's basically a temporal accord baked into the laws of the universe to render time travel impossible and, in Hawking's words, "make the universe safe for historians." And Russian physicists Igor Dmitriyevich Novikov formulated a similar idea with his "self-consistency conjecture."

      But physics can't preclude the possibility of time travel entirely. Both general and special relativity shows time to be relative, and general relativity is open to the possibility of temporal shenanigans. But if you could hop into a time machine and jet back in time, would you need to worry about generating history-altering paradoxes? Not according to a new study published in the peer-reviewed Classical and Quantum Gravity. The math shows the universe will sort things out.

      A paradox primer

      According to the study, the universe would have worked things out whether Marty stole credit for "Johnny B. Goode" or not.

      (Photo: Universal Studios)

      The classic temporal thought experiment is known as the grandfather paradox. It goes like this: Imagine you decide to go back in time to kill your grandfather. Yes, his election-year posts have been that embarrassing. You travel back and kill him before he conceives one-half of your parents. But then, how is it you can exist to go back and kill him? But if you don't exist, then who killed your grandfather? Paradox. The timeline is no longer self-consistent. (Maybe.)

      You can play this game with most time traveling tales. In "Back to the Future," Marty travels back in time and interferes with his parents' dalliance, preventing himself from being born. But if Marty is never born, how does he interfere with his parents' dalliance? But if he can't interfere, what's preventing him from being born? And round we go.

      One would think such worries limited to high-minded philosophy debates or low-brow movie riffs. But some solutions to Einstein's field equations allow time travel through closed timelike curves. These theoretical paths would allow someone to be present at an initial event, travel through space and time, and return to that event again. Think a spacetime loop-the-loop. Importantly, the return point is not a repeat of the initial event. It is the initial event.

      The implications of closed timelike curves lead to all sorts of wild time travel scenarios. According to physicist Michio Kaku, these have included traveling through a wormhole, through a spinning black hole, around an infinitely-long spinning cylinder, and around two colliding cosmic strings.

      The universe is a self-regulating Time Lord

      Dr. Fabio Costa (left) and Germain Tobar (right) discuss their findings. Behind them, a process function (w) interacts with localized spacetime regions with closed timelike curves.

      Credit: University of Queensland

      With time travel on the theoretical table, Tobar Germain, a University of Queensland undergraduate, wanted to test its consistency. Is paradox-free time travel mathematically possible? To answer that question, he teamed up with Dr. Fabio Costa, a University of Queensland physicist, to crunch the numbers.

      "Some physicists say it is possible, but logically, it's hard to accept because that would affect our freedom to make any arbitrary action," Tobar said in a release. "It would mean you can time travel, but you cannot do anything that would cause a paradox to occur."

      According to their research, time travel can be consistent and free of logical paradoxes. However, that requires the outputs of all but two space-time regions to be fixed. In that case, despite the presence of closed timelike loops, entities can maintain their freedom of choice without resulting in a paradox.

      "The maths checks out, and the results are the stuff of science fiction," Costa said in the same release.

      To illustrate their findings, Tobar and Costa offer a thought experiment straight out of science fiction. Imagine you travel through time to stop the COVID-19 pandemic. You locate and quarantine patient zero. Mission (and paradox) accomplished, right? Not according to their research. The math suggests that temporal events would adjust to being logically consistent with any action you made. For example, you may catch the virus, become patient zero, and spread the pandemic anyway.

      Therefore, future, erm, past you still has the stimulus that sent you back in time initially.

      "No matter what you did, the salient events would just recalibrate around you," Tobar said. "That would mean that—no matter your actions—the pandemic would occur, giving your younger self the motivation to go back and stop it.

      "The range of mathematical processes we discovered show that time travel with free will is logically possible in our universe without any paradox."

      Riding the timelike curve?

      Of course, sayings paradox-free time travel is mathematically consistent is a wildly different statement than saying it is practically possible. Even if you could take the plunge into a wormhole, there's a good chance you'd be crushed out of existence before reaching the other end. Souped-up DeLorean or no.

      It all depends on how the laws of quantum gravity shake out, and physicists are still exploring that very open question. What about those other scenarios Kaku pointed out? In a follow-up article, he points out that none can be realized using known physical mechanisms.

      So, while we may be the time lords of the whiteboard, the universe will be a one-way street for the foreseeable future.

      CT scans of shark intestines find Nikola Tesla’s one-way valve

      Evolution proves to be just about as ingenious as Nikola Tesla

      Credit: Gerald Schömbs / Unsplash
      Surprising Science
      • For the first time, scientists developed 3D scans of shark intestines to learn how they digest what they eat.
      • The scans reveal an intestinal structure that looks awfully familiar — it looks like a Tesla valve.
      • The structure may allow sharks to better survive long breaks between feasts.
      Keep reading Show less

      American imperialism: fat-shaming Uncle Sam

      Opponents of 19th-century American imperialism were not above body-shaming the personification of the U.S. government.

      Uncle Sam's growth from toddler to giant of the world stage.

      Credit: Bill of Rights Institute / Public domain
      Strange Maps
      • In the years before 1900, the United States was experiencing a spectacular spurt of growth.
      • Not everyone approved: many feared continued expansionism would lead to American imperialism.
      • To illustrate the threat, Uncle Sam was depicted as dangerously or comically fat.
      Keep reading Show less

      Why information is central to physics and the universe itself

      Information may not seem like something physical, yet it has become a central concern for physicists. A wonderful new book explores the importance of the "dataome" for the physical, biological, and human worlds.

      Credit: agsandrew via Adobe Stock
      • The most important current topic in physics relates to a subject that hardly seems physical at all — information, which is central to thermodynamics and perhaps the universe itself.
      • The "dataome" is the way human beings have been externalizing information about ourselves and the world since we first began making paintings on cave walls.
      • The dataome is vast and growing everyday, sucking up an ever increasing share of the energy humans produce.
      Keep reading Show less
      Surprising Science

      Dogs know when people are lying

      A new study tested to what extent dogs can sense human deception.