How Some Myths about the Brain Just Don't Go Away

A new study examines reasons behind the persistence of neuromyths.


Some commonly held ideas about what we know about the brain are nothing more than myth, and a new study recently published in Frontiers of Psychology has set out to disprove these falsehoods despite their prevalence in culture.

Our infant daughter spent years with her face pressed up against our TV screen supposedly having her learning capacity expanded through classical music and “stimulating images" delivered to her by a then-popular video series, Baby Einstein. At the time, everyone seemed to believe that exposure to classical music had a beneficial effect on young minds. By now, a majority of people who know about neuroscience don't believe this to be the case, even if a majority of the public still does. Unfortunately, a majority of educators also do. This so-called “Mozart effect" is just one of a handful of popular neuromyths about how the brain and learning work that continue to misdirect parents, students, and most disturbingly, their teachers.

Dispelling the Myth: Training in Education or Neuroscience Decreases but Does Not Eliminate Beliefs in Neuromyths, recently published in Frontiers in Psychology, reveals how hard it is to stamp out these popular untruths. Its authors, led by Kelly Macdonald of the University of Houston, handed out true/false questionnaires to 3,000 members of the general public, 600 educators, and 234 people who had taken a substantial number of higher-education courses on the brain or neuroscience. Participants didn't do as well as one might hope, especially the more “expert" among them. Every group had people who believed falsehoods about neuroscience, in about the ratios you'd expect.

Some of the most common neuromyths that just won't let go are these, along with the percentage of people who get them wrong, broken down into the general public, educators, and people knowledgeable in neuroscience:

(derived from MACDONALD, ET AL)

Of special concern are the educators, for two reasons. The survey involved a mix of them:

  • General education, 31%
  • Early childhood (nursery, pre-K, kindergarten), 28%
  • Higher education (college/university), 27%
  • Special education, 22%
  • Administrator (superintendent, dean, principal, director of program), 11%
  • Enrolled in teacher preparation program, 6%
  • Gifted/talented, 4%
  • Other (e.g., counselor, speech pathologist, tutor), 8%
  • First off, educators are responsible for disseminating presumably correct information to their students, thus magnifying many times over the negative impact of any neuromyths they believe.

    Second, among the neuromyths are misconceptions about the efficacy of different teaching methods, and so we can surmise that many educators are being less effective as teachers than they could be. Among the education-related myths in the study are these:

  • Individuals learn better when they receive information in their preferred reading style.
  • Children have learning styles that are dominated by particular senses.
  • A common sign of dyslexia is seeing letters backwards.
  • Learning problems associated with developmental differences can't be improved by education.
  • Exercises that rehearse coordination of motor-perception skills can improve literacy skills.
  • Here are the rest of the neuromyths in the study and the percentages of wrong answers the researchers received:

    (derived from MACDONALD, ET AL)

    The study did confirm that a greater exposure to neuroscience helped dispel a tendency toward belief in neuromyths, but it doesn't completely banish them, since “both educators and individuals with high neuroscience exposure continue to endorse about half or more of the 'classic' neuromyths, despite their training."

    Maybe the most interesting finding is that certain core neuromyths cluster together statistically, so if you believe one of them, you're more likely to believe them all. Among these are:

  • items about learning styles
  • dyslexia
  • the Mozart effect
  • the impact of sugar on attention
  • the role of the right and left hemispheres in learning
  • using 10% of the brain
  • Given their differing subject matter, this may indicate something more about the psychology of the believer than about his or her education level. Still, as the study notes, “Alternatively, it is possible that these neuromyths are taught explicitly and simultaneously in some professional contexts." This leads to the authors' somewhat surprising, though perfectly sensible, recommendation for how to effectively combat neuromythology, “Regardless of the source, our data pointing to the clustering of neuromyths suggests that curricula must address multiple misunderstandings simultaneously, perhaps pointing out the connections between myths, in order to effectively address their persistence among educators."

    Ethnic chauvinism: Why the whole world shouldn’t look like America

    We are constantly trying to force the world to look like us — we need to move on.

    Videos
    • When the Berlin Wall fell in 1989, many Americans jumped for joy. At the time, some believed there weren't going to be any more political disagreements anywhere in the world. They thought American democracy had won the "war of ideas."
    • American exceptionalism has sought to create a world order that's really a mirror image of ourselves — a liberal world order founded on the DNA of American thinking. To many abroad this looks like ethnic chauvinism.
    • We need to move on from this way of thinking, and consider that sometimes "problem-solving," in global affairs, means the world makes us look like how it wants to be.
    Keep reading Show less

    Physicists find new state of matter that can supercharge technology

    Scientists make an important discovery for the future of computing.

    Pixabay
    Surprising Science
    • Researchers find a new state of matter called "topological superconductivity".
    • The state can lead to important advancements in quantum computing.
    • Utilizing special particles that emerge during this state can lead to error-free data storage and blazing calculation speed.
    Keep reading Show less

    First solar roadway in France turned out to be a 'total disaster'

    French newspapers report that the trial hasn't lived up to expectations.

    Image source: Charly Triballeau / AFP / Getty Images
    Technology & Innovation
    • The French government initially invested in a rural solar roadway in 2016.
    • French newspapers report that the trial hasn't lived up to expectations.
    • Solar panel "paved" roadways are proving to be inefficient and too expensive.
    Keep reading Show less