Is There Really Such a Thing As Clean Coal?

An explanation of why clean coal is just fiction, or at best a climate-change denier’s fantasy.

The phrase “clean coal” snuck into our national climate conversation quite a while ago. Presidents Bush and Obama have both championed it, and in the second 2016 Presidential debate, Donald Trump claimed it could help address the climate change he doesn’t believe exists. That’s okay, because, neither does clean coal.


Coal is the most carbon-rich fuel we have, and when it comes to the amount of climate-killing carbon dioxide it puts into the atmosphere, it’s filthy. Here’s how many pounds of CO2 our various fuels generate per million Btu units of energy produced, from greatest to least.

  • Coal (anthracite) — 228.6
  • Coal (bituminous) — 205.7
  • Coal (lignite) — 215.4
  • Coal (subbituminous) — 214.3
  • Diesel fuel and heating oil — 161.3
  • Gasoline — 157.2
  • Propane — 139.0
  • Natural gas — 117.0
  • (Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration)

    Coal is important to the U.S. since it’s the source of about half our electricity, and thus it produces 40% of all the United States’ carbon emissions. This may be why the last two Administrations have wanted to believe in clean coal.

    President Obama’s administration invested $3.4 billion in it, claiming shortly after taking office,” “This is America. We figured out how to put a man on the moon in 10 years. You can’t tell me we can’t figure out how to burn coal that we mine right here in the United States of America and make it work.” Obama promised during his campaign to implement a “cap and trade” system in which operators of current “dirty” coal plants would have to pay for each ton of CO2 they released.

    SRP Springerville (BRIAN SAMSON)

    The dream of clean coal is about capturing carbon dioxide before it escapes into the air. “Carbon capture and storage” (CSS) systems would use “scrubbers” to clean the emissions before release. There are roughly a dozen CSS systems being tested around the world, and the technology is still in its infancy — most of coal’s carbon dioxide still makes it into the atmosphere. And many of those plants may not be so climate-benign anyway, since they play a game of put-and-take with carbon: They remove CO from coal emissions and force it underground to push upward fossil fuels they can sell to offset CSS costs. It’s really just a carbon detour since it still ends up in the atmosphere, but from gasoline instead of coal.

    Out goes the CO, up comes the oil. (BBC NEWS)

    In any event, carbon dioxide’s not the only problematic substance produced in the burning of coal. There’s also:

  • Sulfur dioxide that causes acid rain.
  • Nitrogen oxide that creates smog, and can burn lung tissue, make asthma worse, and leave people more susceptible to chronic respiratory diseases.
  • Particulates, or haze-producing soot or fly ash, that are a source of chronic bronchitis, make asthma worse, and which can even result in premature death. 
  • Mercury, a heavy metal that causes brain damage and heart problems. Half the man-mad mercury in the U.S. comes from coal.
  • So. “Clean coal?” Nope, at least not in 2016 — it would require technology that doesn’t exist as of yet. And it may never, considering the range of bad things that burning coal produces. (We haven’t even mentioned the danger involved in mining coal.) It would be far more sensible to invest in solar energy, wind power, and other truly clean methods of providing power to our world. And let’s just put this oxymoron to rest.

    ​There are two kinds of failure – but only one is honorable

    Malcolm Gladwell teaches "Get over yourself and get to work" for Big Think Edge.

    Big Think Edge
    • Learn to recognize failure and know the big difference between panicking and choking.
    • At Big Think Edge, Malcolm Gladwell teaches how to check your inner critic and get clear on what failure is.
    • Subscribe to Big Think Edge before we launch on March 30 to get 20% off monthly and annual memberships.
    Keep reading Show less

    This is the best (and simplest) world map of religions

    Both panoramic and detailed, this infographic manages to show both the size and distribution of world religions.

    (c) CLO / Carrie Osgood
    Strange Maps
    • At a glance, this map shows both the size and distribution of world religions.
    • See how religions mix at both national and regional level.
    • There's one country in the Americas without a Christian majority – which?
    Keep reading Show less

    The world's watersheds, mapped in gorgeous detail

    Hungarian cartographer travels the world while mapping its treasures.

    Strange Maps
    • Simple idea, stunning result: the world's watersheds in glorious colors.
    • The maps are the work of Hungarian cartographer Robert Szucs.
    • His job: to travel and map the world, one good cause at a time.
    Keep reading Show less
    Image source: Topical Press Agency / Getty Images
    Politics & Current Affairs
    • Though we know today that his policies eventually ended the Great Depression, FDR's election was seen as disastrous by some.
    • A group of wealthy bankers decided to take things into their own hands; they plotted a coup against FDR, hoping to install a fascist dictator in its stead.
    • Ultimately, the coup was brought to light by General Smedley Butler and squashed before it could get off the ground.
    Keep reading Show less