Tuberculosis and the Immigration Question

Question: Should we screen immigrants for tuberculosis?


Neil Schluger: Well, more than half of all people with active tuberculosis in the United States were born outside the U.S. Now very few of those people come in to the United States with active tuberculosis. Most of those persons come in with a latent form of tuberculosis that’s not contagious. They’re not sick. We can identify those people and we can treat them. So it’s a very treatable condition in my view. In no measure is it a reason to keep people from immigrating to the United States. Persons who are coming here should be screened for TB and treated if they have it and then it won’t be much of a problem so I don’t think it’s a reason to keep people out. It’s a very easy mallet to beat people over the head with to try to prevent immigration. Immigrants are bad people who bring diseases. We have seen that before in the United States and certainly in the current climate there is the potential for that again, but most persons who come in to the U.S. just have latent TB infection, as I said not contagious. We can identify them, we can treat them, and they’ll never get TB so from my point of view it would be really a tragedy if that were used to drum up prejudice and discrimination against people coming in for perfectly legitimate reasons, and we’ve always depended on these people in the United States.

Question: What about actively contagious immigrants?

Neil Schluger: Right. So people coming to the United States with active TB, as I said it’s relatively uncommon. Most of those persons don’t come legally. If you try to legally immigrate to the United States for example you actually have to be screened for tuberculosis in your home country so if you’re coming here on a residence Visa or something like that you have to have an x-ray in your home country and it’s got to show that you don’t have contagious TB before you can come in. Now some people are exempt from that. Tourists for example don’t get that kind of screening and students often don’t get that kind of screening but people who are coming here to live at least do, and we don’t think there’s too many people who actually come in to the United States with active TB. Now in some parts of the United States that is more of an issue and that’s particularly out west, California and the Southwest, where people go back and forth across the border all the time. And that’s not really the case in New York because we’re separated by an ocean from most other borders but California, Arizona, places like that, it’s more of a problem there because people go back and forth all the time. And there I think the solution is in sort of cross- border cross government cooperation for TB treatment.

Recorded on: 04/25/2008



Tuberculosis should not be a reason to keep people from immigrating to the United States, Schluger says.

The 4 types of thinking talents: Analytic, procedural, relational and innovative

Understanding thinking talents in yourself and others can build strong teams and help avoid burnout.

Big Think Edge
  • Learn to collaborate within a team and identify "thinking talent" surpluses – and shortages.
  • Angie McArthur teaches intelligent collaboration for Big Think Edge.
  • Subscribe to Big Think Edge before we launch on March 30 to get 20% off monthly and annual memberships.
Keep reading Show less

Brazilian scientists produce mini-brains with eyes

Using a new process, a mini-brain develops retinal cells.

Surprising Science
  • Mini-brains, or "neural organoids," are at the cutting edge of medical research.
  • This is the first one that's started developing eyes.
  • Stem cells are key to the growing of organoids of various body parts.
Keep reading Show less

Do you have a self-actualized personality? Maslow revisited

Rediscovering the principles of self-actualisation might be just the tonic that the modern world is crying out for.

Personal Growth

Abraham Maslow was the 20th-century American psychologist best-known for explaining motivation through his hierarchy of needs, which he represented in a pyramid. At the base, our physiological needs include food, water, warmth and rest.

Keep reading Show less