The keto diet helps men – not women – lose weight, new research suggests
One group of women still seem to benefit from the popular diet.
- Medical professionals and dieters have long noticed differences in the efficacy of the keto diet between the sexes.
- A new study suggests that estrogen plays a role in preventing women from losing weight on the keto diet.
- More research is needed before scientists know exactly how the keto diet's effects vary between the sexes.
It's long been observed that men seem to have an easier time than women in terms of losing weight on the keto diet. The results of a new study on the keto diet's effects on mice support that anecdotal claim, suggesting that sexual hormones might prevent the high-fat diet from helping females lose weight.
At the annual meeting of the Endocrine Society on Sunday, researchers from the University of Iowa discussed a soon-to-be-published study showing how female mice on the keto diet were less likely than males to lose weight, and more likely to experienced impaired blood sugar control.
In the experiments, researchers put a group of mice on the keto diet or a regular diet, which served as the control.
- Keto diet: 75 percent fat, 3 percent carbs, 8 percent protein
- Regular diet: 7 percent fat, 47 percent carbs, 19 percent protein
After 15 weeks on the keto diet, the male mice experienced losses of body weight and body fat, while the female group actually gained weight. The researchers speculated that estrogen might be interfering with the weight-loss process, so they removed ovaries from some of the mice. This caused females to start experiencing the same weight-loss effects observed in the male group.
"Our studies suggest that sex hormones might modulate the way that male versus female mice respond to ketogenic diets," lead investigator Jesse Cochran, a research assistant at the University of Iowa, told Inverse.
The male mice experienced another, less desirable change: Their livers showed stronger signs of fibrosis — the thickening and scarring of connective tissue — and fatty storage than the female mice. The males had higher levels of a hormone called FG21, which previous studies have shown is released in response to liver damage.
Is the keto diet bad for the liver?
The intuitive answer might be yes, considering the keto diet calls for eating lots of fats, and having too much fat (particularly triglycerides) in your liver can lead to inflammation and cell death. However, some research suggests that a responsibly implemented keto diet can actually improve liver health.
For example, a 2018 study tracked the effects of the keto diet on 10 mildly obese people with fatty livers. Ann Fernholm, science journalist and founder of the not-for-profit Dietary Science Foundation, said the study offered an "extremely detailed map showing what happens when a person cuts down on sugar and starch in their diet.
"The liver metabolism changed almost immediately," she wrote for Diet Doctor. "Instead of creating fat, it started burning it and already in the first day you could see a significant reduction in liver fat. As a great side effect, the participants also improved their cholesterol profiles. The microbiome also changed. A surprising discovery was that it started producing more folic acid, a vitamin which is important in the liver's metabolism. Low levels of folic acid has earlier been associated with an increased risk of fatty liver."
Still, more research is needed
Despite its popularity, there's still much scientists don't know about the keto diet, and most medical professionals stop short of recommending the diet unless it's prescribed to epileptics.
"The keto diet is primarily used to help reduce the frequency of epileptic seizures in children," said registered dietitian Kathy McManus, director of the Department of Nutrition at Harvard-affiliated Brigham and Women's Hospital. "While it also has been tried for weight loss, only short-term results have been studied, and the results have been mixed. We don't know if it works in the long term, nor whether it's safe."
The mixed results on keto diet studies could be explained, in part, by discrepancies in efficacy between the sexes, and a lack of solid research on how females respond to the diet.
"Most studies of the ketogenic diet for weight loss have taken place in small numbers of patients or in only male mice, so sex-based differences in response to this diet are unclear," said senior investigator E. Dale Abel, M.D., Ph.D., chair of the University of Iowa Department of Internal Medicine and president-elect of the Endocrine Society.
Regarding the recent research, it remains unclear whether similar studies conducted with human participants would yield the same results.
Can the keto diet work for some women?
Interestingly, the recent study suggests it can.
"[The finding that ovariectomized mice experienced weight loss] suggests that postmenopausal women could potentially experience better weight loss outcomes with the ketogenic diet compared to younger women," Cochran said.
This seems to match the observations of some medical professionals prior to the recent research.
"My anecdotal observation in my medical office and working with people online is that men perform better in nutritional ketosis compared with women, particularly women aged 40 and older," wrote Sara Gottfried, a board-certified gynecologist, on her website. "My female patients, myself included, have more problems on keto with their stress hormones (i.e. producing too much cortisol), thyroid function, and may develop menstrual irregularities. At the root of these problems is dysfunction of the control system for hormones, the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal-thyroid-gonadal (HPATG) axis."
Since the initial use of ketogenic diets (KD) as adjunctive treatment for epilepsy, these diets are being increasingly used to promote weight loss and to reduce the risk of metabolic sequelae of severe obesity. Typical KD are very low in carbohydrate and high in fat, promoting hepatic production of ketone bodies. Most animal studies tend to be performed in male mice, and few studies have evaluated gender differences in response to KD. To explore sex differences in response to KD, female and male wild-type mice on the C57BL/6J background were fed either a control diet (CD- 7% fat, 47% carb., 19% protein) or KD (75% fat, 3% carb., 8% protein), following weaning. Females on the CD manifested higher levels of circulating β-hydroxybutyrate (β-HB) than males (2.86-fold, p<0.05). Circulating β-HB concentrations increased with KD in males and females (1.30-fold & 5.05-fold, p<10-4& p<0.01 respectively) with higher concentrations in females. After 15 weeks of feeding, females on KD displayed an increase in body weight (1.07-fold KD vs. CD, p<0.05) while body weight declined in males (0.88-fold, p<0.05). Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis revealed elevated lean mass in 18-week old females (1.07-fold, p<0.05), but a significant reduction in fat mass in males (0.49-fold, p<0.05) relative to sex-matched mice on CD. The female mice on KD developed impaired glucose tolerance with a 1.35-fold increase in glucose tolerance test area under the curve (GTT AUC) (p<0.001) relative to CD females. In contrast, fasting glucose levels were lower in males on KD (131.8 ± 12.5 mg/ dl vs. 169.2 ± 6.3 mg/dl, p<0.05). Despite no significant change in GTT AUC, the male mice on KD displayed elevated blood glucose concentrations 30 minutes after injection relative to males on CD (344.9 ± 18.7 mg/ dl vs. 272.0 ± 10.31 mg/dl, p<0.05). However, after 120 minutes, blood glucose levels returned to initial levels. To further investigate the role of estrogen in this sexual dimorphism, female mice were ovariectomized (OVX) and randomized to receive either a CD or KD after weaning. At 15 weeks old, OVX mice on KD displayed decreased body weight (0.84-fold, p<0.0001) and fat mass (0.65-fold, p<0.001) relative to CD-fed mice. Despite changes in body composition, OVX mice on KD still exhibited impaired glucose tolerance with a 1.4-fold increase in GTT AUC comparable to OVX mice on CD (p<0.05). In conclusion, significant sex differences exist in terms of body composition and metabolism in response to ketogenic diet, which may partially be attributed to estrogen.
"Body, breath, awareness…that's your life. Every problem you ever have, every joy you ever have, depends on that." In this week's episode of Think Again, host Jason Gots talks with acclaimed poet and zen teacher Norman Fischer about the imagination as a tool for living a good life.