Want to Teach the Difference Between Correlation and Causality? Use Heavy Metal.

All teachers should strive to instill in their students the ability to think rationally and clearly communicate their conclusions. One educator has recommended using heavy metal as a focal topic in teaching sound thinking. 

Want to Teach the Difference Between Correlation and Causality? Use Heavy Metal.

Any topic can be used to teach rational thinking, even something as loud and bombastic as heavy metal music.


Rodney M. Schmaltz, a psychologist at Edmonton's MacEwan University, writes in the journal Frontiers in Psychology "there are many useful resources from this area of popular culture that can help promote scientific thinking in the classroom." As an example, Schmaltz points to controversies surrounding bands such as Slayer, Judas Priest and Mayhem, each having been accused over the past 30 years of instigating violence through their music. Teachers can design a lesson around an investigation of these claims and, by proxy, instill in students an awareness of correlation versus causality. 

To make something like heavy metal a teaching tool, Schmaltz cites the methods of Robert Cialdini, an expert on influence and persuasion who champions the use of mystery to goad students into thinking like scientists. "Cialadini argued that instructors should frame a lecture in the same way a mystery writer frames a novel," writes Schmaltz, "by posing a puzzle and providing the information for the reader—or in this case, the student—to solve it."

The lesson is a detective story with a class full of Sherlocks tasked with reasoning a solution to the mystery: “Can music lead people to commit harmful acts?” Schmaltz provides a bevy of new stories and scientific sources to serve as clues for the student investigators. He encourages teachers to divvy out useful information piece by piece. Students will gradually learn to understand the concepts and thought processes necessary to reach the accepted scientific conclusion: Heavy metal and violent behavior have a correlational relationship, not causal. Arguments that run counter to this conclusion tend to rely on fallacious reasoning.


All teachers should strive to instill in their students the ability to incorporate reason into their daily thinking, as well as to clearly communicate their conclusions. The trick is to frame the lesson around an intriguing and/or unexpected topic. This communicates that rational thought has as much a home in cultural criticism as it does in the science classroom.

Too often, the lessons learned in a lab remain in the lab because students have no context for transferring the skills into real life. That's why Schmaltz' idea about teaching heavy metal mysteries could be so effective. You can substitute punk rock or hip hop just as easily and achieve the same results: a real-world application of smart classroom thinking.

Source: Metal Injection

Photo: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images

**

Robert Montenegro is a writer and dramaturg who regularly contributes to Big Think and Crooked Scoreboard. He lives in Washington DC and is a graduate of Loyola Marymount University in Los Angeles.

Twitter: @Monteneggroll. Website: robertmontenegro.com.

Iron Age discoveries uncovered outside London, including a ‘murder’ victim

A man's skeleton, found facedown with his hands bound, was unearthed near an ancient ceremonial circle during a high speed rail excavation project.

Photo Credit: HS2
Culture & Religion
  • A skeleton representing a man who was tossed face down into a ditch nearly 2,500 years ago with his hands bound in front of his hips was dug up during an excavation outside of London.
  • The discovery was made during a high speed rail project that has been a bonanza for archaeology, as the area is home to more than 60 ancient sites along the planned route.
  • An ornate grave of a high status individual from the Roman period and an ancient ceremonial circle were also discovered during the excavations.
Keep reading Show less

Are lab–grown embryos and human hybrids ethical?

This spring, a U.S. and Chinese team announced that it had successfully grown, for the first time, embryos that included both human and monkey cells.

Getty Images
Surprising Science
In Aldous Huxley's 1932 novel “Brave New World," people aren't born from a mother's womb. Instead, embryos are grown in artificial wombs until they are brought into the world, a process called ectogenesis.
Keep reading Show less

A big lesson from the ‘Oumuamua alienware controversy

Scientists should be cautious when expressing an opinion based on little more than speculation.

Artist's impression of ʻOumuamua

Credit: European Southern Observatory/M. Kornmesser
13-8
  • In October 2017, a strange celestial object was detected, soon to be declared our first recognized interstellar visitor.
  • The press exploded when a leading Harvard astronomer suggested the object to have been engineered by an alien civilization.
  • This is an extraordinary conclusion that was based on a faulty line of scientific reasoning. Ruling out competing hypotheses doesn't make your hypothesis right.
Keep reading Show less
Surprising Science

Asteroid impact: NASA simulation shows we are sitting ducks

Even with six months' notice, we can't stop an incoming asteroid.

Quantcast