It Was the Dress in 2015. In 2017 It's the Silent Gif People Can Hear.

A silent gif is sweeping the web because many people think they can hear it.

You certainly remember The Dress from 2015 and the viral internet debate regarding what color it really was. This year it’s a silent animated gif showing three electrical pylons playing jump rope — the odd thing is that many people can hear it.


The gif was actually created by Twitter user I Am Happy Toast back in 2008 as part of a Photoshop challenge, and it appeared in British parallel-universe comedy show The Wrong Door. What set off the current uproar was a December 4 tweet by Scottish scientist Lisa DeBruine.

Does anyone in visual perception know why you can hear this gif?

— Lisa DeBruine (@lisadebruine) December 2, 2017


She asked her followers what, if anything, they hear when the watch the gif. 315,483 people have responded to her poll as of this writing. But that’s just the tip of the iceberg, since the whole thing has gone viral. One of the things that intrigued DeBruine was why some hear the sound and others don’t, as reflected in her tweet’s survey.

Her basic question has yet to be definitively answered, though, but there are certainly some interesting theories. The early favorite on her feed was that the pylon in the middle is jumping at a tempo very similar to the human heartbeat, and so it’s their own hearts that people are hearing. This theory actually makes sense only if your heartbeat happens to be in sync with the pylon, which is vanishingly unlikely. Anyone who’s ever tried to get two pieces of music at the same tempo to play back in time can attest to this — it only happens when they line up exactly. DeBruine quickly put the kibosh on this one On the other hand, as long as we’re talking viral videos, why does this eventually happen to unsynchronized metronomes? (It does take significantly longer to achieve its effect than the gif.)

It didn’t take long, however, for the discussion to center on the camera shake that occurs when the jumper lands. I Am Happy Toast himself got into the conversation, showing how the effect still happens when the towers are cropped out, leaving just the shake.

The thump is almost entirely in the shake, if you crop out the pylons themselves you can still hear it. They just give it height.

— HappyToast (@IamHappyToast) December 4, 2017


He also notes that in The Wrong Door, there's no shake, and no boom.

I've tracked down a copy of the pylons as they appeared in The Wrong Door - No ground shake and therefore no perceived noise! @lisadebruine

— HappyToast (@IamHappyToast) December 7, 2017


A couple of other examples with a camera shake back up his point. This one’s from My Neighbor Totoro, and it, too, booms.


This seesaw go doesn’t boom, it snaps. Still…


Tweeter Aaron Carlson noted a phenomenon that may begin to get at what’s going on for those who hear the gif.

The gif shake seems to cause me to have an extremely minute muscle tensing around my ears (bracing for impact?). I think this is where the sound is coming from for me at least.

— Aaron Carlson (@crazycarl864) December 4, 2017


Jonathan Toolan tweeted his young son’s reaction to the gif: “7 year old son’s report on skipping pylon: 'I can’t hear it, but my body can feel it.'”

Avowed technoanarchist Andrew Kemendo puts this in a more sciency, sensible way:

Look into Correlated neuronal activity. The brain is "expecting/predicting" what is coming visually and then fires a version of what it expects across the relevant senses. Also explains why some might "feel" a physical shake

— Andrew Kemendo (@AndrewKemendo) December 3, 2017


Another, not completely unrelated theory comes from Christopher Fassnidge, a University of London scientist, who spoke to the BBC. He suggests a kind of movement-to-sound synesthesia. Fassnidge is studying what he calls "vEAR" — for “Visually-Evoked Auditory Response” — which he says is a phenomenon experienced in daily life by around 20% of us, much higher than the generally reported incidence of synesthesia.

“We are constantly surrounded by movements that make a sound, whether they are footsteps as people walk, lip movements while they talk, a ball bouncing in the playground, or the crash as we drop a glass. There is some evidence to suggest that synaesthetic pairings are, to some extent, learnt during infancy.”

Fassnidge offers this example: “I might assume I am hearing the footsteps of a person walking on the other side of the street, when really the sound exists only in my mind.”

There hasn’t yet been a lot of research into vEAR, but Fassnidge is conducting a survey, if you're interested.

The truth may be one of these theories or something not yet posited — what do you think? Is it something else entirely? 


How to make a black hole

Here's the science of black holes, from supermassive monsters to ones the size of ping-pong balls.

  • There's more than one way to make a black hole, says NASA's Michelle Thaller. They're not always formed from dead stars. For example, there are teeny tiny black holes all around us, the result of high-energy cosmic rays slamming into our atmosphere with enough force to cram matter together so densely that no light can escape.
  • CERN is trying to create artificial black holes right now, but don't worry, it's not dangerous. Scientists there are attempting to smash two particles together with such intensity that it creates a black hole that would live for just a millionth of a second.
  • Thaller uses a brilliant analogy involving a rubber sheet, a marble, and an elephant to explain why different black holes have varying densities. Watch and learn!
  • Bonus fact: If the Earth became a black hole, it would be crushed to the size of a ping-pong ball.

10 paradoxes that will stretch your mind

From time-traveling billiard balls to information-destroying black holes, the world's got plenty of puzzles that are hard to wrap your head around.

Big Think
Surprising Science
  • While it's one of the best on Earth, the human brain has a lot of trouble accounting for certain problems.
  • We've evolved to think of reality in a very specific way, but there are plenty of paradoxes out there to suggest that reality doesn't work quite the way we think it does.
  • Considering these paradoxes is a great way to come to grips with how incomplete our understanding of the universe really is.
Keep reading Show less

China’s artificial sun reaches fusion temperature: 100 million degrees

In a breakthrough for nuclear fusion research, scientists at China's Experimental Advanced Superconducting Tokamak (EAST) reactor have produced temperatures necessary for nuclear fusion on Earth.

Credit: EAST Team
Surprising Science
  • The EAST reactor was able to heat hydrogen to temperatures exceeding 100 million degrees Celsius.
  • Nuclear fusion could someday provide the planet with a virtually limitless supply of clean energy.
  • Still, scientists have many other obstacles to pass before fusion technology becomes a viable energy source.
Keep reading Show less