Why Can't Reason and Imagination Just Be Friends?

Surely the greatest scientific discoveries are the product of imaginative energy and curiosity no less intense or pure than that which animates Hamlet or King Lear. Still, the petty squabble between Reason and Imagination that began in the 17th century persists . . .

Back in high school, my imagination was overtaken for a year or two by the poems and engravings of William Blake (1757-1827). In particular, and only semi-consciously, I absorbed some of Blake’s wild mythology about the relationship between Urizen, a deity representing Reason and Law, and Los – the opposing force of Imagination. 


Along with Blake, I came to view math and science (which, not coincidentally, were my worst subjects) as aligned with conformity and lack of spirit, soul-crushing pursuits presided over by frowning Urizen and his carpenter’s square. It didn’t help that the head of our math department was a dour, sadistic creature who delighted in nothing more than assigning students to afterschool blackboard duty for failing to bring the right type of pencil to class. Art and literature, on the other hand, were the highest products of the human spirit, limitless sources of light, energy, and hope.  

Although I never made my peace with high school math and science, I have long since seen the folly of this rigid distinction between reason and imagination. Surely the greatest scientific discoveries are the product of imaginative energy and curiosity no less intense or pure than that which animates Hamlet or King Lear. Still, this marital squabble between Urizen and Los, which began perhaps in the 17th century, as rational philosophers attempted to define their methods and cast off the superstitious trappings of earlier ages, persists in various forms down to our present day. A few examples: 

  • The battle between Bones (Los) and Spock (Urizen) on Star Trek 
  • The battle between the “new atheism” (Urizen) on the one hand and religion, agnosticism, and various forms of spirituality (Los) on the other. 
  • The endless pedagogical battle between proponents of humanities education (Los) and proponents of “STEM” (science, technology, engineering,* mathematics – i.e. Urizen). 
  • The battle between big corporations (Urizen) and those who hate them (Los) – with the vaccination debate being a particularly illustrative example.. 
  • Psychologist Daniel Kahneman’s recent book Thinking, Fast and Slow, contrasting the two human systems of thought: Intuitive (Los) and Deliberative (Urizen). For most types of decision making, Kahneman says Los is the better bet.  
  • The various permutations of this debate sometimes serve to illustrate just how convoluted and absurd the attempt to split the human mind into two opposing forces – and to determine once and for all which one is better – can become. 

    C’est la politique, but for the sake of future sensitive, poetic high schoolers everywhere I’d like to see fewer irritating ad hominem public slugfests, and more brilliant, playful, experimental attempts to heal this centuries-old rift. Jad Abumrad’s public radio show Radiolab, which uses sound and narrative to delve deep into mathematical and scientific concepts, comes to mind. So does the painter Chuck Close, whose enormous portraits are composed of tiny, meticulously painted squares on a grid. Also, the Dalai Lama’s (admittedly controversial) efforts to encourage research efforts on the neuroscience of meditation. There have been some promising developments in the corporate world, as (some) businesses have come to understand the human ecosystems on which their success depends. I’m thinking, too, of the late, great David Foster Wallace, whose monumental work Infinite Jest is at once an imaginative tour-de-force on the order of, say, Alice in Wonderland – and a meticulous, Talmudic discourse (with 200+ pages of microscopic footnotes) on the human psyche. 

    In other words, Los and Urizen, can’t we just be friends?  

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    *thanks to reader Reynir Orn, who pointed out my omission of engineering here, providing further evidence of my Los-ian biases...

     

    Follow Jason Gots (@jgots) on Twitter

    'Upstreamism': Your zip code affects your health as much as genetics

    Upstreamism advocate Rishi Manchanda calls us to understand health not as a "personal responsibility" but a "common good."

    Sponsored by Northwell Health
    • Upstreamism tasks health care professionals to combat unhealthy social and cultural influences that exist outside — or upstream — of medical facilities.
    • Patients from low-income neighborhoods are most at risk of negative health impacts.
    • Thankfully, health care professionals are not alone. Upstreamism is increasingly part of our cultural consciousness.
    Keep reading Show less
    Videos
    • Climate change is no longer a financial problem, just a political one.
    • Mitigating climate change by decarbonizing our economy would add trillions of dollars in new investments.
    • Public attitudes toward climate change have shifted steadily in favor of action. Now it's up to elected leaders.


    Following sex, some men have unexpected feelings – study

    A new study shows that some men's reaction to sex is not what you'd expect, resulting in a condition previously observed in women.

    Credit: Pixabay
    Sex & Relationships
    • A new study shows men's feelings after sex can be complex.
    • Some men reportedly get sad and upset.
    • The condition affected 41% of men in the study
    Keep reading Show less

    Elizabeth Warren's plan to forgive student loan debt could lead to an economic boom

    A plan to forgive almost a trillion dollars in debt would solve the student loan debt crisis, but can it work?

    Photo credit: Drew Angerer / Getty Images
    Politics & Current Affairs
    • Sen. Elizabeth Warren has just proposed a bold education reform plan that would forgive billions in student debt.
    • The plan would forgive the debt held by more than 30 million Americans.
    • The debt forgiveness program is one part of a larger program to make higher education more accessible.
    Keep reading Show less