Yearly Health Exams Cost Billions, Don't Improve Health

Annual checkups cost the nation billions while yielding virtually no health benefits, argues Ezekiel J. Emanuel.

The tradition of the yearly physical examinations is antiquated. Annual checkups cost the nation billions while yielding virtually no health benefits, argues Ezekiel J. Emanuel, oncologist and vice provost at the University of Pennsylvania.

In a study conducted by the Cochran Collaboration, an international group of medical researchers, over 182,000 people were followed for nine years to better understand the benefits of an annual medical exam, i.e. visits to the doctor not prompted by any health complaint. 

Annual checkups failed to extend life expectancy of patients or reduce instances of specific causes of death such as heart disease and cancer.

And while the United States Preventative Services Task Force does not have a recommendation with respect to annual visits to the doctor, Canada's equivalent body has advised against the routine sine 1979.

Because the exams are not prompted by any health complaint, they amount to health screenings for healthy people, which is not a convincing way to improve people's health. Nor do the exams help reduce death and injury caused by acute problems such as unintentional injury, suicide, or chronic conditions like Alzheimer's. 

The exams may even be cruel in some cases. When a physical exam discovers esophageal or pancreatic cancer, for example, patients will not likely live longer as a result, but will spend more time knowing they have cancer.

In his Big Think interview, Ezekiel J. Emanuel discusses how the media can incorrectly shape health policy through lack of nuance and short attention spans: 

Read more at the New York Times

Photo credit: Shutterstock

Related Articles
Keep reading Show less

Five foods that increase your psychological well-being

These five main food groups are important for your brain's health and likely to boost the production of feel-good chemicals.

Mind & Brain

We all know eating “healthy” food is good for our physical health and can decrease our risk of developing diabetes, cancer, obesity and heart disease. What is not as well known is that eating healthy food is also good for our mental health and can decrease our risk of depression and anxiety.

Keep reading Show less

For the 99%, the lines are getting blurry

Infographics show the classes and anxieties in the supposedly classless U.S. economy.

What is the middle class now, anyway? (JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images)
Politics & Current Affairs

For those of us who follow politics, we’re used to commentators referring to the President’s low approval rating as a surprise given the U.S.'s “booming” economy. This seeming disconnect, however, should really prompt us to reconsider the measurements by which we assess the health of an economy. With a robust U.S. stock market and GDP and low unemployment figures, it’s easy to see why some think all is well. But looking at real U.S. wages, which have remained stagnant—and have, thus, in effect gone down given rising costs from inflation—a very different picture emerges. For the 1%, the economy is booming. For the rest of us, it’s hard to even know where we stand. A recent study by Porch (a home-improvement company) of blue-collar vs. white-collar workers shows how traditional categories are becoming less distinct—the study references "new-collar" workers, who require technical certifications but not college degrees. And a set of recent infographics from CreditLoan capturing the thoughts of America’s middle class as defined by the Pew Research Center shows how confused we are.

Keep reading Show less