Skip to content

Almost 300,000 guns sold without background checks as pandemic overwhelmed system

The ‘Charleston Loophole’ has likely allowed thousands of guns to end up in the hands of people who would have failed a federal background check.

Credit: Scott Olson / Getty

Guns built by DSA Inc and other manufacturers are displayed inside the DSA Inc. store on June 17, 2016 in Lake Barrington, Illinois. Earlier in the day the facility was the target of an anti gun protest. DSA Inc. manufactures FAL, AR-15 and RPD rifles.
Key Takeaways
  • In 2020, both gun sales and gun violence have increased on a year-over-year basis.
  • Amid surging demand for guns, a recent report from the nonprofit Everytown for Gun Safety suggests that the nation’s background-check system has been overwhelmed.
  • One likely consequence: nearly 300,000 people were able to buy guns without passing a background check.

As U.S. gun sales continue to surge amid the pandemic, how is the nation’s background-check system keeping up?

Not so well, suggests a recent report from Everytown for Gun Safety, a nonprofit gun-control advocacy group.

The report, which was based on FOIA-retrieved F.B.I data, stated that the “National Instant Criminal Background Check system (NICS) is falling behind due to surging gun sales during the pandemic,” and that there’s been “a 54% increase in the number of background checks that were delayed past three days in the March through July period, as compared with the same time last year.”

Why is the three-day mark important? Federal law currently requires people to pass a background check when buying a gun from a licensed dealer. Most background checks go through in minutes. But some take longer, and the F.B.I. has a total of three business days to pass or deny the check. However, if the bureau gives no answer after three days, the person can buy the gun legally.

Coronavirus Pandemic Causes Climate Of Anxiety And Changing Routines In AmericaCredit: Mario Tama / Getty

This is often called the “Charleston Loophole,” named after the infamous South Carolina shooting where 21-year-old Dylan Roof killed nine people with a gun he bought after the F.B.I. took longer than three days to clear his background check. The shooter, who had admitted to drug possession, would’ve failed the background check without the loophole.

Typically, the F.B.I. only takes extra processing time on about 11 percent of background checks, while about 3 percent of checks take longer than three days. However, from March to July, more than 5 percent of all background checks took longer than three days.

Immigration And Border Security Issues Loom Heavy In Upcoming U.S. ElectionsJohn Moore/Getty Images

Considering there were 5.86 million background checks during that period, that means some 294,683 people may have bought a gun without passing a background check. The actual number is probably lower, given that 19 states and the District of Columbia allow authorities more than three days to process background checks, or outright prohibit gun sales if a background check is incomplete.

Is the U.S. already suffering consequences from surging gun sales? It’s hard to say. Crime, in general, has mostly fallen across the nation during the pandemic. Gun violence in many major American cities has spiked. A recent Wall Street Journal report found that, among the nation’s 50 largest cities, reported homicides were up 24 percent, on a year-over-year basis.

Some researchers have linked the uptick in violence to more guns in the hands of Americans. On the other hand, the increase could stem not only from more guns, but also from fewer gun arrests.

For example, an analysis recently published by The New York Times found that the increase in shootings in New York City is likely linked to the fact that police have been arresting far fewer people for firearms violations, potentially because they’re deterred or distracted by the protests and pandemic.

Still, the exact causal factors remain unclear, given the strange confluence of stressors present in 2020: pandemic anxiety, political turmoil, national protests over the killing of George Floyd. In any case, it seems safe to expect the national background-check system, as is, to become dangerously overwhelmed when the demand for guns skyrockets.

“Surges in gun buying, coupled with dangerous loopholes that put guns in the hands of those who shouldn’t have them, create a perfect storm to worsen our already dire public health crisis,” reads a recent Everytown report.


Up Next