Why Rachel Held Evans Won't Change Christianity

Why Rachel Held Evans Won't Change Christianity

Some progressive Christian bloggers I respect have been writing enthusiastically about a new book, Rachel Held Evans' A Year of Biblical Womanhood, which they say proves that the Bible has been misused to justify patriarchy and demands for female submission. When the book became a bestseller despite evangelical denunciation, they've seen it as proof that a cultural shift is underway among Christians.


I haven't read the book myself, but I'm not so optimistic. I'd be happy if they were right, but I think patriarchal ideas are much more entrenched in Christianity than they realize, and it's going to take much, much more than one book to undo them. I say so because of another story this month, the Anglican church's shock defeat of a proposal for female bishops:

Those against felt the concept of female bishops could not be reconciled with scripture, and felt that compromise, for that reason, was not a Christian value.

The proposal needed a two-thirds majority in all three houses of the church's General Synod to pass. It met that mark in two houses, but narrowly fell short in the third, the House of Laity. It had been widely expected to pass, and its defeat was described as "disastrous", a "bewildering catastrophe" and a "humiliation" for the outgoing archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams. One commenter said, "I think I have just watched the Church of England commit suicide."

The stunning defeat of female bishops, even in a supposedly liberal mainstream church, shows how deeply rooted within Christianity are ideas of female leadership and female subservience. I think this is something that progressive believers underestimate. It's not just a matter of the "clobber verses" that command women to be silent, but of the fundamental worldview that's woven into the Bible from start to finish.

Consider that, in Christian teaching, God is explicitly male. In fact, he's male twice over - the Father and the Son. Whether you read the book of Genesis metaphorically or literally, either way it says that God created man first and woman to serve him. The Old Testament recounts a continuous lineage of male Israelite kings, except for one queen, Athaliah, who came to power in a bloody coup and reigned only a few years. All the major prophets of the Old Testament were men. Jesus was a man, and he chose twelve men to be his apostles. And all the authors of the Bible's individual books are identified as men.

This kind of sexism is baked into Christianity's origin, which makes it almost impossible to eradicate. If the Bible were a constitution, where you could add amendments, that would be one thing - but it isn't, and you can't. The best you can do is emphasize or reinterpret old stories to give them more woman-friendly messages, but at best this is tinkering around the margins.

None of this can erase the fundamental truth of a biblical worldview where the unquestioned assumption is that men are the prime movers, the leaders, the holders of agency and the makers of decisions, whereas the primary role of women is to gracefully submit, to be obedient and invisible. You can tell the story of Deborah as many times as you want, but this message still comes through loud and clear.

When progressive Christians try to put an egalitarian spin on the Bible, it's the same unconvincing argument made by corporations that claim to not be sexist because their board of directors has nineteen white men and one woman. You can praise that one woman for her leadership skills or recount her brilliant business decisions, but there's still an unmistakable message being sent. And how much more powerful is that message when it's not a corporate board, but the chosen followers of God himself?

Image via The Oncoming Hope

Daylight Atheism: The Book is now available! Click here for reviews and ordering information.

Every 27.5 million years, the Earth’s heart beats catastrophically

Geologists discover a rhythm to major geologic events.

Credit: desertsolitaire/Adobe Stock
Surprising Science
  • It appears that Earth has a geologic "pulse," with clusters of major events occurring every 27.5 million years.
  • Working with the most accurate dating methods available, the authors of the study constructed a new history of the last 260 million years.
  • Exactly why these cycles occur remains unknown, but there are some interesting theories.
Keep reading Show less

Babble hypothesis shows key factor to becoming a leader

Research shows that those who spend more time speaking tend to emerge as the leaders of groups, regardless of their intelligence.

Man speaking in front of a group.

Credit: Adobe Stock / saksit.
Surprising Science
  • A new study proposes the "babble hypothesis" of becoming a group leader.
  • Researchers show that intelligence is not the most important factor in leadership.
  • Those who talk the most tend to emerge as group leaders.
  • Keep reading Show less

    The first three minutes: going backward to the beginning of time with Steven Weinberg (Part 1)

    The great theoretical physicist Steven Weinberg passed away on July 23. This is our tribute.

    Credit: Billy Huynh via Unsplash
    13-8
    • The recent passing of the great theoretical physicist Steven Weinberg brought back memories of how his book got me into the study of cosmology.
    • Going back in time, toward the cosmic infancy, is a spectacular effort that combines experimental and theoretical ingenuity. Modern cosmology is an experimental science.
    • The cosmic story is, ultimately, our own. Our roots reach down to the earliest moments after creation.
    Keep reading Show less
    Surprising Science

    Ancient Greek military ship found in legendary, submerged Egyptian city

    Long before Alexandria became the center of Egyptian trade, there was Thônis-Heracleion. But then it sank.

    Quantcast