E-cigs shown to be healthier than cigarettes—but still not healthy

A new meta-analysis of over 800 studies shows that e-cigs are healthier than cigarettes. But the authors don't give them a clean bill of health. 

Everything in moderation, so the sentiment goes. Alcohol, for example, may bestow health benefits in small doses—a glass of wine does not make an alcoholic. The same idea is often touted with cigarettes. While there are no health benefits, a cigarette here and there can’t be all that bad, can it? 

Not so fast, says a research team led by Allan Hackshaw, professor of epidemiology and medical statistics at University College London. Conducing a meta-analysis of 141 cohort studies, the team found that even one cigarette a day equated to a 48 percent increased risk of coronary heart disease. For women, that number jumped to 57 percent.

As the team noted in the study, published in the journal, BMJ:

“Smoking only about one cigarette per day carries a risk of developing coronary heart disease and stroke much greater than expected: around half that for people who smoke 20 per day.”

They also note that this research does not imply people shouldn’t cut down if quitting isn't in the cards at the moment. But this eye-raising research is certain to make smokers question their efforts if even one daily smoke has such profound negative effects. It also brings into question today's most popular alternative: e-cigs.

There, smokers can take some solace, at least according to a new congressionally mandated meta-analysis of over 800 peer-reviewed studies. Conducted by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM), the study set out to learn if e-cigarettes could help smokers quit traditional cigs and what health impact that would have.

The good news:

“There is conclusive evidence that completely substituting e-cigarettes for combustible tobacco cigarettes reduces users’ exposure to numerous toxicants and carcinogens present in combustible tobacco cigarettes.”

As Vox notes, England is leading the charge in promoting e-cigs as a safer alternative to cigarettes, something American agencies have been reluctant to do. The FDA’s tobacco czar, Mitch Zeller, has said that he believes e-cigs should not be marketed to children and teenagers—and indeed, that is a major problem cited by NASEM in its study.

Promoters smoking electronic cigarettes during the Vape Fair in Kuala Lumpur. Vaping is soaring in popularity in Malaysia, the largest e-cigarette market in the Asia-Pacific region. Photo: Mohd Rasfan/AFP/Getty Images) 

One key finding is that vaping increases the likelihood teens and children will smoke real cigarettes in the future. This news arrives even as the study states e-cigs are both less harmful than conventional tobacco products and that they may help adults quit smoking cigarettes.

Oncologist Maiciej Goniewicz, who was on the NASEM committee, says, “Children using e-cigarettes are at an increased risk of using tobacco cigarettes in the future.” Her statement comes after covering ten clinical studies on the topic.

While the study says e-cigs are healthier than cigarettes, this does not give vaping a clean bill of health. The authors of the report give a thumbs up to e-cigs in the short term, yet as they conclude:

“In the long term (for instance, 50 years out), the public health benefit is substantially less and is even negative under some scenarios. If the products do not increase combustible tobacco cessation in adults, then with the range of assumptions the committee used, the model projects that there would be net public health harm in the short and long term.”

One thing is certain: vaping keeps the toxic stench of cigarettes out of the public, which is a bonus. Yet the aromatic flavors are also in part what hook young people on vaping in the first place, which could lead to more toxic stench (and cancers, and so on). This catch-22 makes regulating e-cigs challenging. A short-term public health gain is not so appealing if the long-term effects are negative.

Then again, given all we know about the dangers of tobacco products in the first place, that anyone smokes today is evidence that we’re not really good about thinking in decades. That’s the insidious nature of addiction: immediate pleasure trumps the long arc of a healthy life every time.


Derek Beres is the author of Whole Motion: Training Your Brain and Body For Optimal Health. Based in Los Angeles, he is working on a new book about spiritual consumerism. Stay in touch on Facebook and Twitter.

3D printing might save your life one day. It's transforming medicine and health care.

What can 3D printing do for medicine? The "sky is the limit," says Northwell Health researcher Dr. Todd Goldstein.

Northwell Health
Sponsored by Northwell Health
  • Medical professionals are currently using 3D printers to create prosthetics and patient-specific organ models that doctors can use to prepare for surgery.
  • Eventually, scientists hope to print patient-specific organs that can be transplanted safely into the human body.
  • Northwell Health, New York State's largest health care provider, is pioneering 3D printing in medicine in three key ways.
Keep reading Show less

The information arms race can’t be won, but we have to keep fighting

The tactics that work now won't work for long.

Politics & Current Affairs

Arms races happen when two sides of a conflict escalate in a series of ever-changing moves intended to outwit the opponent.

Keep reading Show less

10 excerpts from Marcus Aurelius' 'Meditations' to unlock your inner Stoic

Great ideas in philosophy often come in dense packages. Then there is where the work of Marcus Aurelius.

(Getty Images)
Personal Growth
  • Meditations is a collection of the philosophical ideas of the Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius.
  • Written as a series of notes to himself, the book is much more readable than the dry philosophy most people are used to.
  • The advice he gave to himself 2,000 years ago is increasingly applicable in our hectic, stressed-out lives.
Keep reading Show less

What if all humanity had to do to save itself was listen?

By working together, and learning from one another, we can build better systems.

  • Many of the things that we experience, are our imagination manifesting into this physical realm, avers artist Dustin Yellin.
  • People need to completely rethink the way they work together, and learn from one another, that they they can build better systems. If not, things may get "really dark" soon.
  • The first step to enabling cooperation is figuring out where the common ground is. Through this method, despite contrary beliefs, we may be able to find some degree of peace.