The Value of Our Online Participation

Question: How do we measure the value of cognitive surplus?
 \r\n
Clay Shirky:  The most immediate value from the \r\ncognitive surplus comes from satisfying the intrinsic desires.  Right?  \r\nThe kind of things that we’re motivated to do that are different from, \r\n“My boss told me so,” or “This is what I’m paid to do.”  And they’re \r\nboth personal and social motivations.  Intrinsic motivations have both \r\npersonal and social components.  Personal motivations tend to be \r\nautonomy and competence.  Right?   The idea that I am the author of my \r\nown actions, or that I’m good at something.  Social motivations tend to \r\nbe membership and generosity.  I am part of a like-minded group that \r\nrecognizes me and accepts me as a member, or my activities are creating \r\nbenefits for other people who are grateful for the work that I’ve done. \r\n
 
So, the primary value driving all of this stuff is really \r\nsome positive sense of self that comes from participation and public \r\naction, whether it’s personal or social. As long as enough people want \r\nto get some of that value out of uploading photos to Flicker, you know, \r\nuploading videos to YouTube, uploading pictures of cats to \r\nICanHasCheezburger, those aggregations... those aggregations will do \r\nwell.  Downstream from that, there’s a whole range of questions about \r\nvalue.  Right? 
 
So, the value of ICanHasCheezburger.com was \r\nthe purveyor of LOLCats, of the pictures of cute cats with cute \r\ncaptions, completely slight, right?  Not world-changing, not really \r\ndoing much other than giving people something to laugh at a coffee \r\nbreak. 
 
The value of Wikipedia?  You know, in less than 10 \r\nyears has become the most important reference work in the English \r\nlanguage.  So, on that range—the range of kind of socio-utility \r\ndownstream of the participants—you’ve got everything from really nothing\r\n more than a bit of fun on a work day to reshaped people’s sense of \r\nwhat’s possible.

Recorded on May 26, 2010
Interviewed by Victoria Brown

The primary value of participation is the positive sense of self that comes from personal and public action.

'Ghost forests' visible from space spread along the coast as sea levels rise

Seawater is raising salt levels in coastal woodlands along the entire Atlantic Coastal Plain, from Maine to Florida.

Photo by Anqi Lu on Unsplash
Surprising Science
Trekking out to my research sites near North Carolina's Alligator River National Wildlife Refuge, I slog through knee-deep water on a section of trail that is completely submerged.
Keep reading Show less

Why professional soccer players choke during penalty kicks

A new study used functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) to measure brain activity as inexperienced and experienced soccer players took penalty kicks.

Abbie Parr via Getty Images
Mind & Brain
  • The new study is the first to use in-the-field imaging technology to measure brain activity as people delivered penalty kicks.
  • Participants were asked to kick a total of 15 penalty shots under three different scenarios, each designed to be increasingly stressful.
  • Kickers who missed shots showed higher activity in brain areas that were irrelevant to kicking a soccer ball, suggesting they were overthinking.
Keep reading Show less

A historian identifies the worst year in human history

A Harvard professor's study discovers the worst year to be alive.

Credit: Pieter Bruegel the Elder. (Museo del Prado).
Politics & Current Affairs
  • Harvard professor Michael McCormick argues the worst year to be alive was 536 AD.
  • The year was terrible due to cataclysmic eruptions that blocked out the sun and the spread of the plague.
  • 536 ushered in the coldest decade in thousands of years and started a century of economic devastation.
Keep reading Show less

Changing a brain to save a life: how far should rehabilitation go?

What's the difference between brainwashing and rehabilitation?

Credit: Roy Rochlin via Getty Images
Mind & Brain
  • The book and movie, A Clockwork Orange, powerfully asks us to consider the murky lines between rehabilitation, brainwashing, and dehumanization.
  • There are a variety of ways, from hormonal treatment to surgical lobotomies, to force a person to be more law abiding, calm, or moral.
  • Is a world with less free will but also with less suffering one in which we would want to live?
Keep reading Show less
Quantcast