Pakistan: An Unforeseen Problem for the U.S.

Question: What big trends have you missed during your 18-year \r\ntenure at Foreign Affairs?
\r\n
\r\nJim Hoge:
I had a number of people in Washington and the State \r\nDepartment and elsewhere telling me very early on, all the way back 18 \r\nyears ago, "Put the focus on Pakistan.  Pakistan is going to be the most\r\n dangerous state for all of us."  And that was the head of policy \r\nplanning at the time, a man named Sam Lewis who said that to me and I \r\nsaid, “Well is that the number one item for policy planning, long term \r\nplanning for the century?”  He said, “You bet it is.”  Well it still is \r\nand it’s more urgent now than it was then.  We did pay attention to \r\nthem.  We’ve done a number of pieces on not just Pakistan, but the \r\ndynamics of that region and how easily they come unraveled, but this was\r\n long before 9/11 and long before Afghanistan was viewed as anything but\r\n a backwater after the Soviet invasion was over, so I still remember \r\nthat neither the State Department nor Foreign Affairs really grasped at \r\nthat time just what a problem Pakistan could end up to be. 
\r\n
\r\nNow why do I call it a big problem now?  Pakistan is a major state.  \r\nIt’s not like Afghanistan, a backwater state.  It has a big population, a\r\n lot of big military, nuclear weapons and one of the great nation to \r\nnation conflicts that still goes on.  If there is going to be another \r\nbig nation to nation war it’s more likely to be between India and \r\nPakistan than almost anybody else.  We have been completely \r\nunsuccessful, not that we haven’t tried, when I say we I mean the United\r\n States, in getting Pakistan and India to finally resolve the problems \r\nover Kashmir and get back into more normal state to state relationship \r\nputting the emphasis on their economic developments.  In that period of \r\ntime, those 18 years or so since that first warning Pakistan has gone \r\nthrough a great discombobulation, civil governments that didn’t work, \r\nmilitary coups that didn’t work, the rise in fundamentalism there.  \r\nMeanwhile, across the border India has gone from being a relatively huge,\r\n poverty-ridden country with very few prospects for economic development\r\n into this raging new first rate power, which is where they’re headed, \r\nwith a very dynamic economy and so you have this contest between a \r\nfading Pakistan if you will and a rising India and that of course is the\r\n grounds for even more tensions and possible miscalculations.
\r\n
\r\nQuestion:
How would such a war affect the U.S.?
\r\n

\r\nJim Hoge: Well one has to assume that if there really was another\r\n all out Indian/Pakistani war that nuclear weapons would be used and \r\nwhat the specific ramifications would be it’s hard to say, but a nuclear\r\n war, there has only been one use of nuclear weapons ever, is an \r\nincalculable risk with unintended consequences.  We are both an ally of \r\nPakistan and we are an ally of India.  What would we do if the two of \r\nthem ended up in a war?  What would we do if one started using nuclear \r\nweapons?  I don’t know, but it is a cataclysm to be avoided at all \r\ncosts.

Recorded May 28, 2010
Interviewed by Jessica Liebman

The Asian nation—with its big military, nuclear weapons, and ongoing conflict with India—has been a "dangerous state" for the U.S. for some time. We're only now starting to realize how urgent its situation is.

Afghanistan is the most depressed country on earth

No, depression is not just a type of 'affluenza' – poor people in conflict zones are more likely candidates

Image: Our World in Data / CC BY
Strange Maps
  • Often seen as typical of rich societies, depression is actually more prevalent in poor, conflict-ridden countries
  • More than one in five Afghans is clinically depressed – a sad world record
  • But are North Koreans really the world's 'fourth least depressed' people?
Keep reading Show less

Banned books: 10 of the most-challenged books in America

America isn't immune to attempts to remove books from libraries and schools, here are ten frequent targets and why you ought to go check them out.

Nazis burn books on a huge bonfire of 'anti-German' literature in the Opernplatz, Berlin. (Photo by Keystone/Getty Images)
Culture & Religion
  • Even in America, books are frequently challenged and removed from schools and public libraries.
  • Every year, the American Library Association puts on Banned Books Week to draw attention to this fact.
  • Some of the books they include on their list of most frequently challenged are some of the greatest, most beloved, and entertaining books there are.
Keep reading Show less
Videos
  • Oumuamua, a quarter-mile long asteroid tumbling through space, is Hawaiian for "scout", or "the first of many".
  • It was given this name because it came from another solar system.
  • Some claimed 'Oumuamua was an alien technology, but there's no actual evidence for that.