How to Make Dozens of Musicians Play as One

What are you listening for when you're conducting?

\r\nAlan Gilbert:  Well, both.  I mean, I try to hear everything \r\nthat's happening, and that can be very, very difficult, and someone that\r\n tells you, “Oh, I hear everything that's happening onstage” is lying \r\nbecause there's almost no way, I think, to really do that.  But as an \r\nexercise, I do try to identify, okay, What is that musician, the third \r\nflute, playing?  And I try to make sure I can hear that.  You have to \r\nhear what's going on because if you're... there's a way... I've used the\r\n analogy...  It's like a ball, a very big ball.  You can affect the way \r\nthe ball rolls, and you can change the direction that the ball is \r\nrolling if it's already in motion, but you can't suddenly have it turn \r\nan abrupt angle.  There's a natural way that the ball can be guided, so \r\neven though you're steering the ball there's a natural momentum the ball\r\n has that you can't interfere with. 

If the orchestra has a \r\ncertain flow, you can affect the flow, but there's a natural way to do \r\nthat, and there's a way that actually would interrupt the natural flow. \r\n So it's not that you can just do whatever you want.  You have to take \r\ninto account what is happening and what is being offered from the \r\nplayers.  So that means really being in touch with they're doing and \r\nhearing them as well as you can.  It's surprisingly difficult to really \r\nidentify, not even with two, or three, or four lines, but even just one \r\nline, to really hear what the will and the sense that the players are \r\ngiving to one line, to really listen to that and to actually be able to \r\nreact to it in a meaningful way is surprisingly difficult.

When you hear an instrument that is out of sync, how do you steer it back without throwing everyone else?

Alan Gilbert: Well, that's difficult, and what happens is\r\n if there's more than one current, if there are conflicting currents \r\nonstage, then you have to make a choice.  You have to either give in or \r\ninsist.  For the other musicians onstage, if they sense two currents, if\r\n they say... for example, if I show one thing and they hear a response \r\nto that that is not in sync, then they have a dilemma; they have to \r\nchoose, “Do I go with what I see from the conductor or do I go with what\r\n I hear?”

So I very often tell orchestras, even the New York \r\nPhilharmonic,  say, “You know, I really want you to play with my lead.  \r\nIt's not that I care about your following me that precisely, it's just \r\nthat I want to take the element of choice out of the question” so that \r\npeople are not forced to decide Do I follow him or do I not follow him? \r\n There has to be just one current.  Of course, mistakes happen.  \r\nAccidents happen.  If something goes wrong, then you just have to use \r\nyour sense and that's based on experience.  Either you give in - \r\nsometimes it's better to give in and allow it to sort of right itself \r\nover time.  Other times you sort of dig your heels in and say “No.  This\r\n is where it is.”  And it creates a discomfort and uncomfortable moment,\r\n but you try to use your best sense, and I couldn't say it's always one \r\nway or it's always another way.  You just have to figure out what's the \r\nbest way to get out of those situations, and hopefully they're not too \r\nfrequent.

Recorded on June 18, 2010
Interviewed by David Hirschman

An orchestra has a momentum as it plays. Its flow can be affected and redirected, but the conductor must do it in an natural way to avoid jarring turns.

  • Beethovan and Picasso are the perfect examples for mastering the creative process.
  • Behind each of their works are countless studies and sketches.
  • The lesson? Never erase anything, keep iterating, and find new paths to familiar destinations.

New study finds the egg may actually 'choose' the Sperm

Here's the first evidence to challenge the "fastest sperm" narrative.

Keep reading Show less
Big Think
Sponsored by Lumina Foundation

Upvote/downvote each of the videos below!

As you vote, keep in mind that we are looking for a winner with the most engaging social venture pitch - an idea you would want to invest in.

Lumina Foundation and Big Think have partnered to bring this entrepreneurial competition to life, and we hope you'll participate! We have narrowed down the competition to four finalists and will be announcing an audience's choice award and a judges' choice award in May.

The creator of the winning video — chosen by Big Think's audience, the Lumina Foundation, and an independent panel of experts (bios below) — will be flown to New York for a taping in the Big Think studio as a way to further promote their vision for a new, disruptive idea in post-secondary education.

Thank you to all of the contestants who spent time submitting applications, and best of luck to our final four competitors.

Finalist: Greater Commons - Todd McLeod

Greater Commons, founded by Todd McLeod and Andrew Cull, is an organization that helps people live happier, more successful and fulfilling lives through agile learning. The current education system is inefficient and exclusionary, in which many students who end up earning a degree, if at all, enter a career not related to their field of study. Greater Commons solves this problem and gap in post-high school secondary education in a variety of ways. Passionately and diligently, Great Commons helps others obtain skills, knowledge, wisdom, motivation, and inspiration so that they may live better lives.

Finalist: PeerFoward - Keith Frome

PeerForward is an organization dedicated to increasing the education and career success rates of students in low-income schools and communities by mobilizing the power of positive peer influence. PeerForward works with partner schools to select influential students as a part of a team, systemizing the "peer effect." Research in the fields of sociology of schools, social-emotional learning, adult-youth partnerships, and civic education demonstrates that students can have a positive effect on the academic outcomes of their peers. PeerForward is unique through its systemic solutions to post-secondary education.

Finalist: Cogniss - Leon Young

Cogniss combines technology and best practice knowledge to enable anyone to innovate and share solutions that advance lifelong learning. Cogniss is the only platform to integrate neuroscience, through which it solves the problem of access by providing a low-code platform that enables both developers and non-developers to build sophisticated education apps fast, and at a much lower cost. It addresses the uneven quality of edtech solutions by embedding research-based learning design into its software. App creators can choose from a rich set of artificial intelligence, game, social and data analytics, and gamification to build their perfect customized solution.

Finalist: Practera - Nikki James

Practera's mission is to create a world where everyone can learn through experience. Today's workplaces are increasingly dynamic and diverse, however, costly and time-consuming experiential learning is not always able to offer the right opportunities at scale. Many students graduate without developing the essential skills for their chosen career. Practera's team of educators and technologists see this problem as an opportunity to transform the educational experience landscape, through a CPL pedagogical framework and opportunities to apply students' strengths through active feedback.

Thank you to our judges!

Our expert judges are Lorna Davis, Dan Rosensweig, and Stuart Yasgur.

Lorna Davis is the Senior Advisor to Danone CEO and is a Global Ambassador for the B Corp movement. Lorna has now joined B-Lab, the non-for-profit that supports the B Corporation movement on an assignment to support the journey of large multi nationals on the path to using business as a force of good.

Dan Rosensweig joined Chegg in 2010 with a vision for transforming the popular textbook rental service into a leading provider of digital learning services for high school and college students. As Chairman and CEO of Chegg, Dan commits the company to fulfilling its mission of putting students first and helping them save time, save money and get smarter.

Stuart Yasgur leads Ashoka's Social Financial Services globally. At Ashoka, Stuart works with others to initiate efforts that have mobilized more than $500 million in funding for social entrepreneurs, engaged the G20 through the Toronto, Seoul and Los Cabos summits and helped form partnerships with leading financial institutions and corporations.

Again, thank you to our incredible expert judges.