Fending Off Angry Readers

Question: What’s the most\r\nvehement reader reaction you’ve ever gotten?


Louis Menand: One\r\nof the oddities about responses that you get to what you write, if you \r\nget a\r\nfair number of them, is that people have very different ideas of what \r\nyou\r\nsaid.  People tend to read with a\r\npreconceived idea of what the piece is about.  If \r\nthere are nuances in the argument, they won’t pick them\r\nup.  Sometimes people won’t even\r\nfinish a piece that you wrote, because they’ve already decided what it \r\nis that\r\nyou want to say, and generally I, whatever I say in the first half of \r\nthe\r\npiece, you should not assume I'm going to end up with, but they don’t \r\nfinish reading\r\nthem.   So, and people read\r\nfast and stuff.  So you do get odd\r\nresponses, but a lot of that is just that, you know, that people are, \r\njust\r\naren’t reading it quite the way that you wrote it.


I think the, I guess the oddest response recently \r\nthat I got\r\nwas I wrote an editorial about Fox News, a comment, as the sort of \r\neditorial,\r\nfirst piece in the magazine.  And\r\nthis was a response to some statement from the Obama administration that\r\n they\r\nwere going to not treat Fox News reporters as real reporters.  So I wrote a comment about it, and I\r\nthink Fox News is fairly ridiculous—and certainly the opinionaters on \r\nFox are\r\nridiculous—and I’ve made some fun of them at the beginning of the piece,\r\n but I,\r\nat the end of the piece, which was only about 1,000 words, I said that I\r\nthought it was a bad idea for the state or the White House, whatever, to\r\n single\r\nout one news organization and say you’re not a real news organization.  I just think that’s a very chilling\r\nthing and the First Amendment is all about letting people, even people \r\nwhose\r\nviews your despise, have their say, because then at the end of the day, \r\nyou can\r\nsay, "You had your say and you lost." \r\nIf you silence them, you don’t get to say that.  So\r\n I said this in the piece.


So I got a very angry email from somebody who was a\r\n Fox News\r\njunkie, who said, “You Harvard professors are all the same, Fox News is \r\ngreat,\r\nyou know, you’re full of it,” and so I wrote back and I said, “Did you \r\nfinish\r\nreading the piece?”  And he said,\r\n“No, I didn’t bother, it was such drivel.”  So I \r\nwas like, “But you bothered to write an email about it,\r\nisn’t that kind of weird?”  I mean,\r\nso you do get that.


Question: After you\r\ncriticized the “Eats, Shoots & Leaves” author, did people start \r\ncritiquing\r\nyour grammar?


Louis Menand: If\r\n you write for the New\r\nYorker, you always get people critiquing your grammar, you can count on\r\nit.  So, because a lot of New\r\nYorker readers are kind of, you know, amateur grammarians and so you do \r\nget a\r\nlot of that.  So that, I’m used to\r\nthat.


But I think, yeah, with that piece, so this was \r\nthis book by\r\nLynne Truss and it was a big, big bestseller in the US, and there were a\r\n lot of\r\nbad things about it.  One was that\r\nthe style of punctuation that she was explaining in the book is British \r\nstyle\r\nof punctuation, which doesn’t work in the United States, I mean, they \r\nhave\r\ndifferent rules, so it didn’t make sense that people buy this book in \r\nthe US\r\nand think they were going to learn how to punctuate from it.


And then the book itself was full of real, I mean, \r\nlike\r\nhowlers, I mean, really bad punctuation mistakes and some grammatical\r\nerrors.  So I had to say this, I\r\nmean, you know, I just thought the world should, at least somebody \r\nshould say\r\nthat she doesn’t know how to punctuate.


So the great thing was that there was a fuss in \r\nEngland\r\nabout it, apparently, and her editor was interviewed and he was asked \r\nabout my\r\nreview, and he called me a "wanker"—which I thought was, you know, not \r\nvery\r\nclassy, but all right—and then it\r\nturned out that the next book Lynne Truss was going to write was \r\ncivility, how\r\nthere’s no civility any more.  She\r\nshould start with her editor.

Louis Menand recalls the most vehement reactions his essays have ever gotten—including one from a reader who didn’t realize Menand agreed with him.

‘Designer baby’ book trilogy explores the moral dilemmas humans may soon create

How would the ability to genetically customize children change society? Sci-fi author Eugene Clark explores the future on our horizon in Volume I of the "Genetic Pressure" series.

Surprising Science
  • A new sci-fi book series called "Genetic Pressure" explores the scientific and moral implications of a world with a burgeoning designer baby industry.
  • It's currently illegal to implant genetically edited human embryos in most nations, but designer babies may someday become widespread.
  • While gene-editing technology could help humans eliminate genetic diseases, some in the scientific community fear it may also usher in a new era of eugenics.
Keep reading Show less

What is the ‘self’? The 3 layers of your identity.

Answering the question of who you are is not an easy task. Let's unpack what culture, philosophy, and neuroscience have to say.

  • Who am I? It's a question that humans have grappled with since the dawn of time, and most of us are no closer to an answer.
  • Trying to pin down what makes you you depends on which school of thought you prescribe to. Some argue that the self is an illusion, while others believe that finding one's "true self" is about sincerity and authenticity.
  • In this video, author Gish Jen, Harvard professor Michael Puett, psychotherapist Mark Epstein, and neuroscientist Sam Harris discuss three layers of the self, looking through the lens of culture, philosophy, and neuroscience.
Keep reading Show less

Discovery of two giant radio galaxies hints at more to come

The newly discovered galaxies are 62x bigger than the Milky Way.

I. Heywood, University of Oxford / Rhodes University / South African Radio Astronomy Observatory / CC BY 4.0.
Surprising Science
  • Two recently discovered radio galaxies are among the largest objects in the cosmos.
  • The discovery implies that radio galaxies are more common than previously thought.
  • The discovery was made while creating a radio map of the sky with a small part of a new radio array.
Keep reading Show less

Massive 'Darth Vader' isopod found lurking in the Indian Ocean

The father of all giant sea bugs was recently discovered off the coast of Java.

SJADE 2018
Surprising Science
  • A new species of isopod with a resemblance to a certain Sith lord was just discovered.
  • It is the first known giant isopod from the Indian Ocean.
  • The finding extends the list of giant isopods even further.
Keep reading Show less

The secret life of maladaptive daydreaming

Daydreaming can be a pleasant pastime, but people who suffer from maladaptive daydreamers are trapped by their fantasies.

(Photo: Wikimedia Commons)
Mind & Brain
  • Maladaptive daydreamers can experience intricate, vivid daydreams for hours a day.
  • This addiction can result in disassociation from vital life tasks and relationships.
  • Psychologists, online communities, and social pipelines are spreading awareness and hope for many.
  • Keep reading Show less