The End of a Bold Experiment: Big Think and Satoshi Kanazawa

Thinking big involves taking risks, and taking risks requires a certain openness to failure. I believe it is an imperative to take such risks today because our personal welfare is directly tied to our ability to get smarter. The Information Industrial Complex (media and education), I believe, is increasingly missing the opportunity to save itself and better serve all of us. And so it is in the spirit of risk-taking that Big Think is always on the lookout for bold and clear voices, people who see the world through the lens of big ideas and who are able to express those ideas in a provocative, counterintuitive and poetic voice.


To that end, we have invited dozens of highly original bloggers to contribute to this site, and we continue to fill our studio with a steady stream of experts to share their wisdom in the form of video lessons.

It was in our studio, in fact, that I first became acquainted with Satoshi Kanazawa in 2010. Among the many key insights he delivered in his interview, Kanazawa introduced us to a proven mathematical theorem that explained why dating and finding a job in a large urban area is difficult and frustrating.

I thought this type of original, inspiring thinking would broadly resonate with our viewers and advance our core mission, and so I reached out to Kanazawa this past September to invite him to join Big Think as a blogger. At that time I anticipated that a range of criticism would likely emanate from the Big Think community, and emanate it did. After all, Kanazawa was a controversial choice, and his reputation certainly preceded his appearance on Big Think.

Kanazawa, an evolutionary psychologist at the London School of Economics, had recently parted ways with Psychology Today after there was widespread backlash against a post he had written that argued black women are physically less attractive than other women. Big Think’s editorial team was aware of these remarks, and we found them to be highly ill-advised. However, after a vigorous internal debate we concluded it was worth the risk to give Kanazawa a second chance and a second home to deliver the best of his work in the service of our cause.

Over the past few months, across various social media platforms, and also from the mouths of some of our own bloggers, I have listened to a sustained critique of Kanazawa’s presence on Big Think. Indeed I think it a testament to our commitment to intellectual openness that we allowed the discussion to play out on Big Think’s pages, in the form of blog posts, and on our social media platforms.

The most compelling arguments have cited numerous examples of faulty science in Kanazawa’s body of work, and the growing consensus in the evolutionary psychology community that his research is a poor representation of the field. This is particularly concerning given the fact that the core message of Kanazawa’s blog is that his work represents empirically correct science, and that his claims are unassailable on that basis.

After reviewing all the available evidence, and upon careful deliberation with the Big Think editorial team, I have decided that it would be best to discontinue our relationship with Kanazawa at this time.

What I hope results from this experience is what educators call a ‘teachable moment.’ We certainly believe in the value of free speech at Big Think, and give voice to controversial thinkers whose opinions tend to span the political spectrum and often challenge the sacred cows of their respective fields. Some of these thinkers, such as the Chinese contemporary artist and political dissident Ai Weiwei, express themselves at grave risk to their personal well-being. However, in providing a platform for dangerous ideas, we also run the risk of overreaching and losing the goodwill of our most dedicated readers. Our commitment is first, and always, to you, and to maintaining your trust and the level of intellectual integrity you expect from us, even while we push the boundaries.

In closing, I would like to highlight the fact that the way this dialogue has taken place -- with readers and bloggers weighing in, the Big Think staff debating internally and then deciding on a prudent course of action -- is a process that has been transparent, and is one that I am proud of. I would like to thank my colleagues and members of this community for their input. It was invaluable in guiding this decision.

NASA spots perfectly rectangular icebergs in Antarctica

Geometric or tabular icebergs are a thing, and they're kinda beautiful.

This photo, taken during an Operation IceBridge flight over the northern Antarctic Peninsula on Oct. 16, 2018, shows another relatively rectangular iceberg near the famous sharp-cornered berg, which is visible behind the plane's outboard engine. The huge, tabular iceberg A68 is visible in the distance. Photo: Jeremy Harbeck/NASA.
Surprising Science
  • Rectangular icebergs have been spotted just off the Larsen Ice Shelf in Antarctica.
  • They're called tabular icebergs, and are totally natural, though they don't look like it.
  • The "alien" idea is tantalizing, but simply not real.
Keep reading Show less
Sex & Relationships

The evening represents many things to different people. It's a time to unwind, a time to catch up on sleep, and for many couples, it's the most opportune time to connect with one another. And since we know that there's an inextricable link between sleep and the success of a relationship (yes, there are even sleep habits that can mess with a relationship!), it's important to implement practices that help you and your partner thrive before bedtime.

Here are the sleep and bedtime habits that characterize successful relationships.

Keep reading Show less

10 of Europe's weirdest laws

Amongst other things, you can't get away with handling a salmon suspiciously in Scotland.

Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty Images
Politics & Current Affairs
  • While a few of the laws on this list are holdovers from long ago, some laws are as recent as 2011.
  • While marrying a dead person or handling salmon suspiciously might sound morbid or hilarious, these laws have historical context.
  • Some of today's laws might seem as antiquated as these in 100 years, too.
Keep reading Show less

Taking care of your hearing and vision slows cognitive decline by 50-75%

A joint study from US and UK universities shows promising results in reducing the rate of cognitive decline.

Pexels/Big Think
Mind & Brain
  • Decline in hearing and vision can add to overall mental decline.
  • Hearing aids can slow cognitive decline by 75%.
  • Similarly, cataract surgery can help cognitive decline by 50%.
Keep reading Show less

Does winning the lottery ruin your life? Not usually, study shows

A study from May 2018 found that most lottery winners report greater life satisfaction over a long-term period.

Balbir Atwal, owner of the California 7-Eleven that sold one of the 3 Powerball winning tickets, holds up a $1 million check. (Photo by Ringo Chiu/Getty Images)
Culture & Religion
  • The study asked more than 3,000 lottery winners about their mental health, happiness and life satisfaction years after winning big cash prizes.
  • Most winners reported greater life satisfaction, but less significant changes in mental health and happiness.
  • The recent Mega Millions and Powerball jackpots could be different, however, given the sheer size of the prizes.
Keep reading Show less

Authai is an Asian elephant. She can count like us.

She's not held back by other animals' numeracy limitations.

(Japan Ethological Society and Springer Japan KK, part of Springer Nature 2018
Surprising Science
  • Asian elephants and African elephants diverged, evolutionarily, more than 7.6 million years ago.
  • In a recent study, an Asian elephants named Authia, was found to count numbers.
  • Authia seems to not be held back by other animals' numeracy limitations.
Keep reading Show less

Bombs sent to Joe Biden and Robert De Niro, latest in string of attempted attacks

Explosives sent to addresses linked to former Vice President Joe Biden and actor Robert De Niro were similar to bombs delivered to other political figures this week, officials said.

Politics & Current Affairs
  • Two bombs were sent to Biden, one to De Niro. Nobody was injured.
  • So far, 10 people, all Democrats or critics of President Donald Trump, have been targeted in this week's string of attempted bombings.
  • Trump denounced the attempted bombings but also suggested the media is partly to blame.
Keep reading Show less

The unusual way magic mushrooms evolved

It's got more to do with sending insects on terrifying trips than it does making Phish sound good.

Surprising Science
  • Fungi species that produce psilocybin—the main hallucinogenic ingredient in "magic" mushrooms—aren't closely related to one another.
  • Researchers have discovered that the way these fungi independently gained the ability to produce psilocybin is because of horizontal gene transfer.
  • Based on how uncommon horizontal gene transfer is in mushroom-producing fungi and the types of fungi that produce psilocybin, it seems likely that the hallucinogenic chemical is meant to scramble the brains of insects competing with fungi for food.
Keep reading Show less