Found: second draft of Galileo's argument for a heliocentric model

At least he wasn't burned at the stake, right?

  • The letter suggests Galileo censored himself a bit in order to fly more under the radar. It didn't work, though.
  • The Royal Society Journal will publish the variants of the letters shortly, and scholars will begin to analyze the results.
  • The letter was in obscurity for hundreds of years in Royal Society Library in London.

The idea that the planets, including Earth, revolved around the Sun was first proposed by Copernicus in 1543. It was a radical departure from the religionist worldview of the time, and when Galileo confirmed this via his own observations, it caused quite a bit of consternation from the folks who led the Catholic Inquisition, as well as the Catholic Church itself. The church, you see, held strongly to the Earth-centered universe at the time, and to contradict their beliefs was straight-up heresy.

When a letter, dated December 21, 1616, was first sent to mathematician Benedetto Castelli with Galileo's proofs of the Copernicus heliocentric (sun-centered) model, along with the assertion that scientific research should be free from theological doctrine, it was forwarded to the Catholic Church, which labeled the letter "heresy," declared it an attack on the church, and blasted what it perceived as incendiary language. The Italian astronomer was found guilty of heresy in 1633.

Science v. Religion


Galileo demonstrating new theories

As it turns out, Galileo pulled some punches after he wrote the first draft that was sent to Castelli — a copy of which was sent to the Inquisition in Rome. In a recently rediscovered second draft, Galileo's hand can seen blotting out some of the harsher phrases of the original letter, substituting them with open-ended ones. For example, in reference to certain biblical claims, he crossed out the word "false" and substituted "look different from the truth."

There was good reason for caution. A few short years earlier, in 1600, scientist Giordano Bruno was found guilty of several heresies, including supporting the Copernicus heliocentric model of our solar system. He was burned at the stake by the church.

In fact, when the Vatican received the first, uncensored version, Galileo pushed out the revised version in an attempt to throw them off his trail. The final edited version did make its way to the Vatican, but it still set church officials off.

Galileo's books were banned, and he was sentenced to prison. That was commuted to house arrest, where he served the last nine years of his life.


Beyond suggesting that Galileo moderated his own text, another particularly fascinating thing about the recently discovered second draft is that it lived incognito in the London Royal Society Library for, at least, 250 years. It has been misfiled.

"I thought, 'I can't believe that I have discovered the letter that virtually all Galileo scholars thought to be hopelessly lost," Ricciardo told Nature. "It seemed even more incredible because the letter was not in an obscure library, but in the Royal Society library."

Opioids not much better than placebos at treating pain, study says

Alternative treatments are often better for noncancer pain, the study found.

Surprising Science
  • The study examined more than 26,000 people experiencing chronic pain.
  • Opioids were only marginally better than placebos at treating pain and improving physical functioning.
  • It's estimated that at least 2 million Americans have opioid use problems.
Keep reading Show less

Iceland is officially worshiping Norse Gods again

For the first time since the Vikings sailed, the Icelandic public will soon be able to worship classical Norse gods like Odin, Thor, and Frigg at a public temple built in their honor.


For the first time since the Vikings sailed, the Icelandic public are worshiping classical Norse gods like Odin, Thor, and Frigg at a public temple built in their honor. "The worship of Odin, Thor, Freya and the other gods of the old Norse pantheon became an officially recognized religion exactly 973 years after Iceland’s official conversion to Christianity."

Keep reading Show less

Sound could replace lasers in surgery

Moving from HOT to HAT, a dazzling new acoustic technology.

(Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences)
Technology & Innovation
  • Scientists announce the ability to simultaneously manipulate individual levitated objects.
  • Using high-frequency sound waves may provide a safer alternative to laser microsurgery.
  • Video of the research looks like a cartoon, but it's all real.
Keep reading Show less