Recording teachers

Andy Carvin notes on the Learning Now blog that a New Jersey school district has banned students from recording their teachers in class after a student recorded a teacher's classroom proselytization and then posted the audio on the Internet. As a school law guy, I've been following this incident with great interest. Here are some thoughts that have been running through my head...


  1. The United States Supreme Court famously said in Tinker v. Des Moines (1969) that "state-operated schools may not be enclaves of totalitarianism. School officials do not possess absolute authority over their students. Students in school as well as out of school are 'persons' under our Constitution. They are possessed of fundamental rights which the State must respect, just as they themselves must respect their obligations to the State."
  2. The default rule generally is that students can wear or bring to school what they want. Typically schools only can regulate what students wear or bring to school if it's unsafe (e.g., weapons), illegal (e.g., drugs), vulgar (e.g., t-shirt with profanity), or causes a 'material and substantial disruption' to the school environment (this is the Tinker test). There are a few other reasons that courts have upheld now and then (e.g., public school uniforms can trump student clothing preferences) but these four are arguably the main ones. It's not clear to me that a student surreptitiously recording his teacher in class meets any of these criteria.
  3. I don't know what the law is in New Jersey, but most states allow recording of conversations if one party (e.g., the student) is aware that the recording is occurring. Also, I believe that all states allow the recording of speech occurring in public (e.g., in the park, on the street (in the classroom?)). In other words you can't assert a privacy right regarding behavior that can be publicly seen or heard. I'm not a legal expert in this area, but I question whether the teacher or the students have a legally effective objection to being taped without their permission.
  4. I'm a little concerned from a supervision/evaluation standpoint that proselytizing behavior was occurring in a teacher's classroom without the administration being aware of it. It sounded like this was ongoing, recurring behavior on part of the teacher. Where were the administrators?
  5. Obviously I've got lots of concerns about the district's new policy. Maybe someone more legally savvy than me can explain why the policy might be upheld, but my initial opinion is that it's on awfully shaky legal ground.

    There are other issues here too, such as the student's belief that the administration wouldn't take the complaint seriously, the desire of the administrators for the student to come to them first, and the student's posting of the recording on the Internet. Check out the post and comments at Learning Now. There's some good conversation occurring over there. Chime in!

    'Upstreamism': Your zip code affects your health as much as genetics

    Upstreamism advocate Rishi Manchanda calls us to understand health not as a "personal responsibility" but a "common good."

    Sponsored by Northwell Health
    • Upstreamism tasks health care professionals to combat unhealthy social and cultural influences that exist outside — or upstream — of medical facilities.
    • Patients from low-income neighborhoods are most at risk of negative health impacts.
    • Thankfully, health care professionals are not alone. Upstreamism is increasingly part of our cultural consciousness.
    Keep reading Show less

    Afghanistan is the most depressed country on earth

    No, depression is not just a type of 'affluenza' – poor people in conflict zones are more likely candidates

    Image: Our World in Data / CC BY
    Strange Maps
    • Often seen as typical of rich societies, depression is actually more prevalent in poor, conflict-ridden countries
    • More than one in five Afghans is clinically depressed – a sad world record
    • But are North Koreans really the world's 'fourth least depressed' people?
    Keep reading Show less

    Banned books: 10 of the most-challenged books in America

    America isn't immune to attempts to remove books from libraries and schools, here are ten frequent targets and why you ought to go check them out.

    Nazis burn books on a huge bonfire of 'anti-German' literature in the Opernplatz, Berlin. (Photo by Keystone/Getty Images)
    Culture & Religion
    • Even in America, books are frequently challenged and removed from schools and public libraries.
    • Every year, the American Library Association puts on Banned Books Week to draw attention to this fact.
    • Some of the books they include on their list of most frequently challenged are some of the greatest, most beloved, and entertaining books there are.
    Keep reading Show less

    Is there an optimal time of day to exercise?

    Two new studies say yes. Unfortunately, each claims a different time.

    Bronx, N.Y.: NYPD officer Julissa Camacho works out at the 44th precinct gym in the Bronx, New York on April 3, 2019. (Photo by Alejandra Villa Loarca/Newsday via Getty Images)
    Surprising Science
    • Research at the Weizmann Institute of Sciences declares evening to be the best time for an exercise session.
    • Not so fast, says a new study at UC Irvine, which replies that late morning is the optimal workout time.
    • Both studies involved mice on treadmills and measured different markers to produce their results.
    Keep reading Show less