Liability for linking?

Chris Craft has posted an

interesting scenario

about the potential legal liability of using Slideshare

, or any

non-district-sponsored web service, that has advertisements that may be

inappropriate for school-age children.

I will first offer my typical caveats that

  1. I am not in an attorney-client relationship with anyone reading this;
  • Although I'm pretty sure that I'm correct, you rely on my opinions at your
  • legal risk; and

  • I always encourage educators to consult with their local school
  • organization's attorney about any legal questions that they may have.

    That said, here are my thoughts...

    It seems to me that Chris' practice of embedding his Slideshare presentations within his

    district-sponsored Moodle system, combined with his district's blocking of

    Slideshare, should be enough to protect him from claims that he negligently

    exposed children to inappropriate Web content. He's not sending students to the

    Slideshare site directly. In fact, his district is blocking students' ability to

    do so. I think it's a bit of a stretch to say that Chris could be liable for

    students accessing the site from home. That would sort of be like trying to hold

    Chris accountable when a student used Google at home to look up inappropriate images

    just because the student also used Google at school (where access to such images

    was blocked).

    If he wanted, Chris might be able to strengthen his case by including an

    explicit notice that he and the school have provided safeguards against access

    to inappropriate content, that students should access school-related content

    only within those safeguards, and that he and the school are not liable for

    students' deliberately bypassing those safeguards at home. Such a notice could

    be on his Moodle site, in a note sent home to parents, part of the

    student-signed acceptable use policy (see, e.g., a model AUP from the Indiana

    Department of Education

    ), or all three. Another potential safeguard might be

    a popup window that appeared whenever a student clicked on a link to an external

    site. The text in the window could note that the student was leaving the

    district web environment and disclaim liability for any further actions by the

    student on other web sites.

    The essence of negligence

    is whether educators acted reasonably under the circumstances. Given the

    safeguards already in place and maybe the additional ones that I've briefly described,

    I think Chris is probably okay when the situation is viewed in its totality.

    It's one thing to hold him and his school liable for a direct link to

    inappropriate content. The further away from direct linking a student gets (2

    links? 5 links? 10 links?), the less likely a court would be to hold Chris and

    the school responsible. There's no bright line here, but 'reasonable


    ' should win the day...

    NYTimes exposé reveals how Facebook handled scandals

    Delay, deny and deflect were the strategies Facebook has used to navigate scandals it's faced in recent years, according to the New York Times.

    (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
    Politics & Current Affairs
    • The exhaustive report is based on interviews with more than 50 people with ties to the company.
    • It outlines how senior executives misled the public and lawmakers in regards to what it had discovered about privacy breaches and Russian interference in U.S. politics.
    • On Thursday, Facebook cut ties with one of the companies, Definers Public Relations, listed in the report.
    Keep reading Show less

    Russian reporters discover 101 'tortured' whales jammed in offshore pens

    Protected animals are feared to be headed for the black market.

    Politics & Current Affairs
    • Russian news network discovers 101 black-market whales.
    • Orcas and belugas are seen crammed into tiny pens.
    • Marine parks continue to create a high-price demand for illegal captures.
    Keep reading Show less

    What would happen if America defaulted on its debt?

    Sure we know it would be bad, but what do all of these scary numbers really mean?

    Politics & Current Affairs
    • At the press time, the value was $21.7 trillion dollars.
    • Lots of people know that a default would be bad, but not everybody seems to get how horrible it would be.
    • While the risk is low, knowing what would happen if a default did occur is important information for all voters.
    Keep reading Show less