What If The Price Was Never Right?

What If The Price Was Never Right?


Prices are the magic in free-market stories. But what if prices were never right? Then free markets wouldn’t work as their fans claim. The ‘markets in everything’ crowd don’t tackle the following three issues well. First, the “invisible hand” can’t benignly solve every problem, rather it creates ills that need nonmarket cures. Second, self-interest often obstructs voluntary solutions. Third, self-interested winners often distort free markets.

Free-market stories rely on price signals to coordinate “spontaneous order” from innumerable voluntary (so presumed beneficial) choices. “Spontaneous” here means undesigned. No individual needs, or can have, all the information that shapes prices. Demand changes are reflected in price changes and markets adjust automatically using the “dispersed knowledge” of many. No dreaded “central planning” is needed.

But this dispersed knowledge story concentrates attention on only one type of  spontaneous order: wherein individual incentives align with collective goals. But nothing guarantees that. In “Darwin’s Wedge” situations individual and group incentives diverge.

Darwin's Wedges abound in free markets, creating openings for profitable “price errors.” For example, polluting manufacturers have incentives to not pay for cleanup. The excluded costs create errors in price signals. And dispersed self-interest complicates voluntary fixes. Both sellers and buyers “benefit” when externalized costs yield lower prices. The seeming self-interest of market participants differs from society’s. Such divergences aren’t minor imperfections that we can safely ignore.

Generally Darwin’s wedges don’t fix themselves. Collective interests require the protection of universal rules enforced by independent referees. They’re like pro-sports salary caps: rich teams buying all the best players hurts the sport overall. Some centralized restrictions on freedom in sports, and in markets, can be beneficial.

Free markets tend to undermine themselves, but not only as Marx warned from the bottom. Self-interested winners, while seeming to be market promoters, often become market distorters, as soon as they can benefit. Many corporations decry government involvement while happily pocketing public subsidies.

Better use of market magic requires attention to the underlying motives of market-fans. Market-lovers can be easily bewitched, like those that Paul Krugman says mistook “beauty, clad in impressive mathematics” for truth. They can be too rosy-eyed about business leaders: Robert Nozick implausibly believed “the future orientation of the market entrepreneur” would conserve natural resources. Some like Milton Friedman hate or distrust government, assuming they’re blundering or corrupt bureaucracies. Among business leaders many, who honestly serve their customers, pay taxes and play fair, are vital (though flatteringly casting them as heroic savior-entrepreneurs encourages arrogance). But others are lazy, favoring deregulation to make their lives easier. And some are just scoundrels seeking easier exploitation.

The price of leaving the massive power of markets to the wrong kind of market-fan is too high. Market realists should recall Upton Sinclair’s warning: we’re all motivated to discount logic that endangers our livelihoods (or pet-theories). The “free markets” vs government frame isn’t helping. Both are needed, and neither can be safely trusted, so a balance of these powers, fitted for each empirical context, is required. Or dispersed self-interest and mindless spontaneous order won’t have benign results.

 

Illustration by Julia Suits, The New Yorker Cartoonist & author of The Extraordinary Catalog of Peculiar Inventions.

Malcolm Gladwell live | How to re-examine everything you know

Join Radiolab's Latif Nasser at 1pm ET on Monday as he chats with Malcolm Gladwell live on Big Think.

Big Think LIVE

Add event to your calendar

AppleGoogleOffice 365OutlookOutlook.comYahoo


Keep reading Show less

Is this the world map of the future?

A vertical map might better represent a world dominated by China and determined by shipping routes across the iceless Arctic.

Chinese world map focusing on the Arctic Passage

Strange Maps
  • Europe has dominated cartography for so long that its central place on the world map seems normal.
  • However, as the economic centre of gravity shifts east and the climate warms up, tomorrow's map may be very different.
  • Focusing on both China and Arctic shipping lanes, this vertical representation could be the world map of the future.
Keep reading Show less

Study: Private prisons result in more inmates, longer sentences

The Labour Economics study suggests two potential reasons for the increase: corruption and increased capacity.

Politics & Current Affairs
  • After adopting strict sentencing laws in the '80s and '90s, many states have turned to for-profit prisons to handle growing prison populations.
  • A new study in Labour Economics found that privately-run prisons correlate with a rise in incarceration rates and sentence lengths.
  • While evidence is mixed, private prisons do not appear to improve recidivism or cost less than state-run facilities.
  • Keep reading Show less

    The art of asking the right questions

    What exactly does "questions are the new answers" mean?

    Videos
    • Traditionally, intelligence has been viewed as having all the answers. When it comes to being innovative and forward-thinking, it turns out that being able to ask the right questions is an equally valuable skill.
    • The difference between the right and wrong questions is not simply in the level of difficulty. In this video, geobiologist Hope Jahren, journalist Warren Berger, experimental philosopher Jonathon Keats, and investor Tim Ferriss discuss the power of creativity and the merit in asking naive and even "dumb" questions.
    • "Very often the dumb question that is sitting right there that no one seems to be asking is the smartest question you can ask," Ferriss says, adding that "not only is it the smartest, most incisive, but if you want to ask it and you're reasonably smart, I guarantee you there are other people who want to ask it but are just embarrassed to do so."
    Mind & Brain

    Study links 'sun-seeking behavior' to genes involved in addiction

    A large-scale study from King's College London explores the link between genetics and sun-seeking behaviors.

    Scroll down to load more…
    Quantcast