The Monty Hall Problem: Deal or Switch

# The Monty Hall Problem: Deal or Switch

If you’ve ever been unfortunate enough to sit through the Gameshow “Deal or No Deal”, you might have concluded as Charlie Brooker put it, that the entire show is  “actually a massively pointless exercise in utter bloody guesswork“. If you did, you’d be right. There is however an utterly counterintuitive rule of probability that appears if we have a little play around with the rules of the game.

Imagine you are in a game show and you are presented with three boxes. In one of the boxes is a sports car, in each of the other boxes is a goat. Imagine now that you can select any one of the boxes. After you have made your pick, the presenter (Monty Hall) opens one of the other boxes to reveal a goat. The question now posed to you is do you stick to your guns or choose the remaining box? Stop and think.

If you answered, that you’d stick with the same box you’d end up with only a 33% chance of winning the car, whilst if you switched your box, your odds double. If that made your brain explode, check out this quick explanation from ASAPScience:

If you still don’t believe me, watch this demonstration of the game from the BBC and if you’d like a fuller explanation head over to the Khan Academy. It just goes to show that we can’t always trust our gut feelings.

Subscribe for counterintuitive, surprising, and impactful stories delivered to your inbox every Thursday

To keep up to date with this blog you can follow Neurobonkers on TwitterFacebookRSS or join the mailing list.

Image Credit: Shutterstock/Mirexon;Dvarg

Related

# The learning ecosystem: What it is, how to build one, and why

Much like energy and nutrients flow in a continuous cycle between the elements of a natural ecosystem, a free flow of knowledge fuels the growth of a learning ecosystem.

# Is freedom what the mind wants?

Blissful ignorance can be a rational choice.

# War crimes are obvious, but proving them isn’t easy

A forensics expert explains what’s involved with documenting human rights violations during conflicts, from Afghanistan to Ukraine.

# Men and women both lie in dating profiles, but not about the same things

One study estimated that 80% of people include “deviations” from the truth in their online profiles.

# Cave paintings reveal what extinct animals may have looked like

Rock art in northern Australia depicts marsupial lions, giant kangaroos, and other megafauna that populated the Land Down Under long ago.

Up Next

# Christ…the Yogi?

Positing Jesus Christ as a yogi has become popular over the last two decades. For some, the symbolism is irresistible: loving your neighbors, turning a cheek and other maxims line […]