Are principals "public figures?"

[cross-posted at The Gate]

Defamation can be either

written (libel) or spoken (slander) and is generally defined as false statements

of fact that harm another's reputation. The United States Supreme Court ruled in

1964 that public officials must prove "actual malice" in order to win a

defamation lawsuit(New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254).

Actual malice is defined as publication despite knowledge that the

statement was false or with reckless disregard for whether it was false. Truth

always is a defense against a defamation lawsuit unless there is malicious

intent. Also, written or spoken communication that is readily understood to be a

satire, parody, or humorously intended situation generally is not found to be

defamatory because the audience understands that the writing/speech is not

intended to be a statement of fact.

The New York Times principle was later extended to "public figures"

(see Curtis Pub. Co. v. Butts, 388 U.S. 130 (1967). A public


is someone who commands "a substantial amount of public

interest by his position alone or has thrust himself by purposeful activity into

the vortex of an important public controversy" (19 A.L.R.5th 1).

So are

school administrators considered to be public figures for purposes of a

defamation lawsuit

? Well, as is usually the case with the law, it


Courts have ruled that principals ARE public figures in

  • New York (Jee v. New York Post Co., Inc., 671 N.Y.S.2d 920 (1998));
  • Maryland (Kapiloff v. Dunn, 343 A.2d 251 (1975)); and
  • Minnesota (Johnson v. Robbinsdale Indep. Sch. Dist. No. 281, 827
  • F.Supp. 1439 (1993)).

    Courts have ruled that principals ARE NOT public figures


    • Georgia (Ellerbee v. Mills, 262 Ga. 516 (1992));
  • Illinois (Stevens v. Tillman, 568 F.Supp. 289 (1983); );
  • Indiana (Beeching v. Levee, 764 N.E.2d 669 (2002));
  • Ohio (E. Canton Edn. Assn. v. McIntosh, 709 N.E.2d 468 (1999));
  • and

  • South Carolina (assistant principal; Goodwin v. Kennedy, 347 S.C.
  • 30 (2001));

    Superintendents and assistant superintendents generally have been found by

    courts to be public figures (see, e.g., Di Bernardo v. Tonawanda Pub.


    , 499 N.Y.S.2d 553 (1986)); Kefgen v. Davidson, 617 N.W.2d

    351 (2000); and Beck v. Lone Star Broadcasting, Co., 970 S.W.2d 610


    So will the

    former principal of Hickory High School in Hermitage, Pennsylvania

    win his

    lawsuit against the four students who created parody

    MySpace profiles

    of him? Only if the court determines that
    1. the principal is not a public figure, and
  • the MySpace profiles could be reasonably interpreted by visitors as
  • statements of fact rather than parodies, satire, or humor.

    Given past case law, #1 could go either way but I'm guessing that #2 will

    be pretty hard to prove

    . It will be interesting to see what happens.

    [Thanks, Wesley


    , for bringing this case to my attention!]


    19 American Law Reports (5th) 1. Who is "public figure" for purposes of

    defamation action.

    China’s artificial sun reaches fusion temperature: 100 million degrees

    In a breakthrough for nuclear fusion research, scientists at China's Experimental Advanced Superconducting Tokamak (EAST) reactor have produced temperatures necessary for nuclear fusion on Earth.

    Credit: EAST Team
    Surprising Science
    • The EAST reactor was able to heat hydrogen to temperatures exceeding 100 million degrees Celsius.
    • Nuclear fusion could someday provide the planet with a virtually limitless supply of clean energy.
    • Still, scientists have many other obstacles to pass before fusion technology becomes a viable energy source.
    Keep reading Show less

    A dark matter hurricane is crashing into Earth

    Giving our solar system a "slap in the face."

    Surprising Science
    • A stream of galactic debris is hurtling at us, pulling dark matter along with it
    • It's traveling so quickly it's been described as a hurricane of dark matter
    • Scientists are excited to set their particle detectors at the onslffaught
    Keep reading Show less

    Here's how diverse the 116th Congress is set to become

    The 116th Congress is set to break records in term of diversity among its lawmakers, though those changes are coming almost entirely from Democrats.

    (Photo: MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images)
    Politics & Current Affairs
    • Women and nonwhite candidates made record gains in the 2018 midterms.
    • In total, almost half of the newly elected Congressional representatives are not white men.
    • Those changes come almost entirely from Democrats; Republican members-elect are all white men except for one woman.
    Keep reading Show less