Preventing Another Abu Ghraib

Question: Whom do you\r\nblame for the ethical breakdown at Abu Ghraib?


Nancy Sherman: I\r\nthink it was a breakdown from high up, breakdown from the top down.  There were attempts, we know, from the\r\ntorture memos that came from the Office of Legal Council, Jay Bybee and \r\nJohn\r\nYoo, to figure out ways that we could permissibly, legally, torture by \r\nsome\r\nother name.  And it was through\r\nCheney and through President Bush that there really was an attempt to do\r\n this. And it trickled down.  So, there\r\nwere commanders who gave permission, or turned their head. \r\n And we also used forces in interrogation\r\nthat weren’t fully trained.  Some\r\nof them had been in other environments and they were told to kind of get\r\ncreative.  And also there is a\r\nfeeling of lack of respect for the enemy. \r\nOnce you degrade the enemy to just being a thing, all bets are \r\noff as to\r\nwhat you can do to them.  And as my\r\nyoung interrogators told me, the temptation to get information out of \r\nsomeone\r\nwho you’re—when you get so frustrated and it’s been days and days and \r\ndays and\r\nyou’re not making any breakthroughs and you know that there may be some \r\nhigh\r\nintelligence that may be gathered. \r\nYou run the risk of harming this person, of doing something you \r\nought\r\nnot to do.  


And in his case, he said there was a moment where \r\nhe saw a\r\nfellow U.S. officer, who was a woman, a woman pilot who had been mangled\r\n by the\r\nenemy, and that really got his ire up, and he really wanted to do \r\nsomething to\r\nbe able to prevent that kind of incident in the future.  And\r\n that’s when he knew that his\r\nconscience really in high gear, hold back.  That’s\r\n the temptation you have to be prepared to fight\r\nagainst. 


And I don’t think—that’s a very reflective, \r\nconscientious,\r\nvery humanistic interrogator.  Not\r\nall are like that.  I went to\r\nGuantanamo as part of the medical observer team, not a physician, but we\r\n were\r\nlooking at psychiatric and psychological conditions of the detainees \r\nfrom the\r\nside of care and also from the side of interrogation and also for hunger\r\nstrikers.  And there was an attempt\r\nto even then when they wanted to bring an observer team out to ask us to\r\n try to\r\nfind a legal loophole for separating the kinds of professionals, the\r\npsychologists who were involved in the interrogation from the kind of\r\npsychiatrists clinicians involved in treatment.  And\r\n if the one is involved in an interrogation never do the treatment,\r\nthen maybe they could be a little bit more aggressive or don’t have to \r\nworry\r\nabout the same restrictions as the ones on the treating side.  And that, you could already see, that’s\r\na way of eroding the responsibilities we have to the care of the \r\ndetainees who\r\nwere supposed to be treated as if they were American forces when they \r\nare in\r\nPOW situations.


Question: What ethical\r\nloopholes still need to be closed in the war on terror? 


Nancy Sherman: Oh\r\nwell, the legal situation is very complicated.  As\r\n you know, Eric Holder is really, the Attorney General, is fraught and \r\nthere’s lots of internal debates in the Obama Administration\r\nthat I can’t begin to chronicle about whether there are military \r\ntribunals or\r\ncivilian sorts of tribunals and where to have the trials, as you know, \r\nNew York\r\nor other places, and who should be released and who not. \r\n But there is certainly a commitment, I\r\nbelieve, to efficiently closing Guantanamo, and also a sense that \r\ntorture is a)\r\nwe know it’s not effective, it’s not instrumental.  It\r\n does not get you the information you want.  And \r\nb) it’s just flat out wrong.  And so there is that\r\n recognition I\r\nthink.  How it gets played out,\r\nespecially when you have TV programs like “24” making it very real, or \r\nmaking\r\nthe notion of “no holds barred” in interrogation, that’s really rough. 


And I know cadets at West Point and my young \r\ninterrogator\r\nwatch these in amusement and voyeurism and whatnot, but I also know that\r\n the\r\nSuperintendent, or the Commandant of West Point have gone out to speak \r\nto the\r\nproducer of this program and say, this isn’t how it works, we don’t want\r\n this\r\npropaganda, you’re really making it harder for us because these aren’t \r\nthe\r\nrules that we are telling to abide by. \r\nAnd so that’s really tricky. \r\nSo, it certainly an awful education that we’ve had to go through,\r\n but I\r\nthink we’re coming out of it.

The military ethicist believes Abu Ghraib represented an ethical breakdown "from the top down." But have things changed under Obama?

Thousands of Nazis held big rallies in America less than 100 years ago

Nazi supporters held huge rallies and summer camps for kids throughout the United States in the 1930s.

Credit: Bettman / Getty Images
Politics & Current Affairs
  • During the 1930s, thousands of Americans sympathized with the Nazis, holding huge rallies.
  • The rallies were organized by the American German Bund, which wanted to spread Nazi ideology.
  • Nazi supporters also organized summer camps for kids to teach them their values.
Keep reading Show less

Coffee and green tea may lower death risk for some adults

Tea and coffee have known health benefits, but now we know they can work together.

Credit: NIKOLAY OSMACHKO from Pexels
Surprising Science
  • A new study finds drinking large amounts of coffee and tea lowers the risk of death in some adults by nearly two thirds.
  • This is the first study to suggest the known benefits of these drinks are additive.
  • The findings are great, but only directly apply to certain people.
Keep reading Show less

Can you solve what an MIT professor once called 'the hardest logic puzzle ever'?

Logic puzzles can teach reasoning in a fun way that doesn't feel like work.

Credit: Shutterstock
Mind & Brain
  • Logician Raymond Smullyan devised tons of logic puzzles, but one was declared by another philosopher to be the hardest of all time.
  • The problem, also known as the Three Gods Problem, is solvable, even if it doesn't seem to be.
  • It depends on using complex questions to assure that any answer given is useful.
Keep reading Show less

Why San Francisco felt like the set of a sci-fi flick

But most city dwellers weren't seeing the science — they were seeing something out of Blade Runner.

Brittany Hosea-Small / AFP / Getty Images
Surprising Science

On Sept. 9, many West Coast residents looked out their windows and witnessed a post-apocalyptic landscape: silhouetted cars, buildings and people bathed in an overpowering orange light that looked like a jacked-up sunset.

Keep reading Show less