Croppedmd

Strange Maps

574 - Lines in the Darkness: An Atlas for the Blind

A failed experiment in speed: while I was rushing down into the basement without flicking on the light, the door closed before I had reached the downstairs switch. Frantically searching and failing to find it, I was rendered helpless by the dread of pitch darkness enveloping me. That part of my brain in charge of worst-case scenarios kicked into gear. Clawing my way back up, towards the light, the worst-case lobe was imagining what a lifetime without sight might be like. Only after regaining the safe, seeing side of the basement door was I struck by the paradox of trying to envision visionlessness. 

Perhaps extrapolated from that childhood trauma, my idea of blindness is one of extreme claustrophobia and disorientation. That idea of blindness merely as a defect is probably the result of - excusez le mot - a lack of vision. It’s often said that whoever misses one of the five senses [1], is compensated by a sharpening of the other four. It’s probably closer to the truth that it’s the blind person, not the blindness, that is doing the sharpening, finding new ways around the obstacle between themselves and observable reality. 

One such innovative detour has been the invention of Braille [2], a raised type enabling those without sight to identify letters on the page, and enjoy reading just like everyone else. Somehow, it never struck me that this translation of the inked word to a tactile script would also be possible for that other information medium of the printed page - maps. In fact, as these images prove, maps composed of raised lines and dots were in use almost as early as the invention of Braille itself. 

MD DE

A map of Maryland and Delaware, showing Virginia pre West Virginia's secession. The map does not show Delaware's Twelve-Mile Circle.

 

The link between blindness and cartography makes more sense than one might think: spatial awareness - knowing where things are without necessarily seeing them - is a trait overdeveloped in blind people, making them especially sensitive to the geo-distributive [3] aspect of maps. As was apparent when blind children were taught to read these raised-relief maps in 1830s Boston: 

“They soon understood that sheets of stiff pasteboard, marked by certain crooked lines, represented the boundaries of countries; rough raised dots represented mountains; pin heads sticking out here and there, showed the locations of towns; or, on a smaller scale, the boundaries of their own town, the location of the meeting-house, of their own and of the neighboring houses, and the like; and they were delighted and eager to go on with tireless curiosity. And they did go on until they matured in years, and became themselves teachers, first in our school, afterwards in a private school opened by themselves in their own town.”

The tactile maps shown here are taken from the Atlas of the United States Printed for the Use of the Blind, published in 1837. This precious, curious edition had a minuscule print run: no more than 50 copies were produced, for the New England Institute for the Education of the Blind [4]. Only five copies now survive. The Atlas consists of 24 state maps, each accompanied by a text describing the state and explaining the symbols used.

That text is not in Braille, but in a raised version of the Latin alphabet, which makes it easily decipherable for non-blind readers. In the introduction, Mr Howe writes:

“It is known that the contrivances hitherto used in Europe for the instruction of the blind in geography are very expensive, rude & imperfect, hardly deserving the name of maps. They were made by hand, either by puncturing through a common map the boundaries &c. or by first posting a map upon a board & then glueing upon it, strings or bits of pasteboard, to represent boundaries, rivers, &c.”

“There was no lettering, & no printed explanations, so that the blind could not tell by themselves, whether the portion they placed the finger upon was to represent one part of the globe or another; they required to be taught upon each map, by a seeing person.”

“This first attempt at embossing maps, was made at this institution [i.e. the aforementioned Institute]. After many expensive experiments a method of printing them was devised; & an atlas, the first of the kind, was published. It has been found a source of great pleasure & useful knowledge to the blind, who can study it unassisted by a seeing person.”

“[It] will give the blind the means of knowing the general outline, shape, & boundaries of each state; the rivers, principal towns, population & general statistics of the whole.”

MaineBlind

Maine, shown bordering Lower Canada, New Brunswick and New Hampshire.

 

The entire atlas has been digitised and published by the fantastic David Rumsey Map Collection [5], with sideways illumination to highlight the embossed lines, dots, letters and symbols on the maps. This map shows the state of Maine, the accompanying text reads:

“You feel the eastern boundary line running north & south: it is not yet terminated on the north because its extent is yet in dispute with Great Britain [6]; on the north, the line of dots terminates at Grand Lake, marked GL. The boundary continues through the centre of the lakes & down the river St Croix until it reaches the ocean.” 

“St J.R. is St. John's River. Next south is St. Croix River; the lakes are called Schoodie; M. is Machias. No 3 is Penobscot R[iver]. B. is for Brunswick; the dot below is Belfast; [?] below is Thomastown: next west on the coast is Wiscassett; K.R. is Kennebec River: M.L. Moose Head Lake; dot next the mouth Gardiner; A. Agusta cap. 4th N. Norridgewock. 5 A.R. Androscoggin River. The dot Bethel. Dot south of it is Paris: on the coast Portland [?]. The island in the N.E. corner is Grand Menan: middle one is Mt. Desert Island: S.W. Fox Island. The River in Canada is St. Lawrence; 2. Quebec."

"This state is as extensive as all the rest of New England: it has many lakes abounding in fish; & rivers with fine falls: first settlement in 1628: in 1651 it was attached to Massachusetts; in 1820 it became an independent state, & member of the Union. Sq. m. 32,000. Pop. near half a million. Cap. 4th Bangor 10th." 

"M[aine] has 145th tons shipping principally in the lumber & fishing trade." 

LA

Louisiana, bordering 'Part of Mexico' (later Texas) and 'Arkansaw'.

 

Many thanks to Kevin Axe and the Big Map Blog (which mentions the Atlas here) for pointing out this great book, scans of which can be found here at the DRMC.

_______

[1] In Aristotle’s classic definition: sight, hearing, touch, smell and taste. Nowadays, at least five additional external ones are recognised: senses of pain, balance, time, temperature differences and acceleration.

[2] Developed in 1825 by the blind Frenchman Louis Braille from a flawed system of night writing commissioned for Napoleon’s army, it consists of letters composed of six dots, which can be raised or not to denote the different letters of the alphabet.

[3] Okay, you got me. I just invented that word. 

[4] Founded in Boston in 1829 by Samuel G. Howe (1801-1876), the husband of Julia Ward Howe, the abolitionist who wrote the ‘Battle Hymn of the Republic’. The school, later renamed the Perkins School for the Blind and moved to Watertown (north of Boston), was mentioned in Charles Dickens’ American Notes, and schooled Helen Keller, the deafblind activist.

[5] The DRMC website contains over 17,000 digitised maps; the DMRC itself contains over 150,000 maps, and is one of the world’s largest map collections.

[6] See Strange Maps #106.

 

comments powered by Disqus
×