Interview Transcript
Paul Hoffman: So, Boonsri, tell me about the three tests that you took. I understand you came back and you started worrying about Crohn’s disease and mascular degeneration.
Boonsri Dickinson: Two of the companies, 23andMe and deCODEme, gave me some information that I could check, like, when I drink wine, my face gets flushed, I have dry earwax, I’ve brown eyes, I’m not a sprinter. And although it said that I’m likely tolerant to lactose, if I had a sip of milk, you guys would all want to hold your nose.
When I read my report on common diseases, I realized the information is useless. There’s no way to tell how accurate the so-called risks are until you actually have a disease.
Esther Dyson: Even then you don’t know what the risk was.
Boonsri Dickinson: Right. Crohn’s disease and macular degeneration are two diseases that I pay attention to, because I have poor eyesight. So loss of vision is something that meant something to me. And then Crohn’s disease is another one. I have a sensitive stomach. So I’ve learned what foods to avoid.
But the limitations, for me, were far greater. I’m half Asian and half European. So when I looked at the profiles, I got conflicting results just because they ask if you’re European or if you’re Asian. They haven’t worked out a way. Although one of the board members said that he was going to work on that.
Esther Dyson: Is that Patrick Chung?
Boonsri Dickinson: George.
Esther Dyson: Oh, he’s, sorry, scientific board.
Boonsri Dickinson: And so they haven’t found a way to calculate risk for people of mixed ethnicities. And since I wrote this story [“How Much Can You Learn From a Home DNA Test?”; from the September 2008 issue of “Discover” magazine] a year ago, the companies continue to update their Web sites with more diseases, more risks. But just because they’re adding more data doesn’t mean that they know more about the role that genes play in the onset of disease.
And only, Navigenics, the third company that I tested with, they offered in-house counseling. And even then their genetic counselor wouldn’t really tell me what my genetic profile meant. She just said I have to interpret it.
Recorded on: July 14, 2009.
Is a Healthy 25-Year-Old Really at Risk for Macular Degeneration?
Assistant Editor, Discover Magazine
Genetic testing made Discover editor Boonsri Dickinson fear for the future of her eyes, and her gut.
July 20, 2009 | In Health & Medicine, Science & Tech
Discuss
Maria Gomez on August 29, 2009, 8:35 PM
I would never take any of these tests. It would just cause me to worry too much. I watch my health closely and get regular checkups. I am aware of my family history and what to worry about. This woman’s experience with genetic testing really solidified my opposition to testing. These companies are only out to make money and play on people’s fears. If i really want to, I can have my doctor order some tests and he and I can discuss the results.
Apoorva Baluapuri on November 21, 2009, 2:48 PM
I am afraid the opinion about such tests is based on rather ill-informed presumptions rather than precise facts.
Understanding the results of such test requires considerable knowledge in Molecular Genetics and molecular biology of gene. Most of the public, including the physicians, is not very well acquainted with the intricacies of the topic. Hence, such tests, whether they should be taken or not, the decision is similar to going to the docto in case of a fever. If you feel the fever is indicative of something worse, you must make an appointment. But most us are dismissive. Similarly, if you have a history of Alzheimer’s or Breast Cancer in your family, I think you are missing out on an early possile detection.
Add a Comment
You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register