How to study better and avoid a test-day disaster

Want to learn better? Here's a lesson from cognitive psychology.

DAVID EPSTEIN: When we teach someone something, we want them to feel good about their learning. And one way to help a learner speed up their apparent progress is to sometimes give them little hints. The problem is, sometimes hint-giving can actually undermine the long-term development of knowledge. There's a really interesting study that demonstrates how this works. It was done on two individuals named Oberon and MacDuff, who happened to be rhesus macaques, monkeys, who were trained to memorize lists in order -- lists of images that they had to pick in order off of a screen. The images could be tulips, a school of fish, Halle Berry, et cetera. And they had trials where they were training to see the order of these pictures.

But the trials came in different varieties. In certain cases, Oberon and MacDuff automatically got hints on the order of the images so they knew what to pick next. In other cases, hints were always available but they didn't have to take them. But they could when they wanted to. And in another case, hints were available about half the time. And in a final instance, for a final set of lists, there were no hints whatsoever. And so over several days of training and hundreds of trials on each of these different sets of lists, Oberon and MacDuff started performing well on the lists where they got hints. On the ones where they didn't get hints, not as well. Then they took a break and came back for test day. No more hits on test day whatsoever, and it was a performance disaster. Oberon and MacDuff got almost nothing right from the lists where they were given hints. The more hints they were given in training, the worse they did on test day. And for the lists where they got no hints, all of a sudden Oberon got about 3/4 of them right and MacDuff, who was generally not as good, got about half of them right. And this demonstrates something well known about human learning, actually, called the generation effect. The generation effect means sort of what it sounds like; the effort of generating an answer actually primes your brain for learning.

So the kind of testing that Oberon and MacDuff were doing, when they had lists with no hints even though they were struggling, it was forcing them to attempt to generate an answer. And even when they were wrong, that primes your brain to then retain the knowledge. Where in the cases where they were given hints, they didn't have that same kind of priming, that same kind of work, to generate a correct answer.

So the lesson that comes from this area of cognitive psychology is that really you should be testing yourself before you're ready, because that's how you prime your brain for better learning. Or to quote the cognitive psychologist Nate Cornell, who was involved in the monkey study but usually studies cognition in humans: Frustration and difficulty is not a sign that you aren't learning, but ease is.

  • Getting hints makes students feel like they're learning, but a cognitive psychology study on monkeys, specifically on two rhesus macaques called Oberon and MacDuff, has proven that getting hints backfires when it comes to test day.
  • If you're relying on outside help, you're not employing what's called the 'generation effect'. The generation effect refers to the mental effort of generating an answer, which actually primes your brain for learning.
  • How can you study better? Test yourself before you're ready, and know that learning is supposed to be frustrating and difficult. If if feels too easy, it might be a sign you're not generating independent answers.


Should you grow a beard? Here's how women perceive bearded men

Whether or not women think beards are sexy has to do with "moral disgust"

Photo Credit: Frank Marino / Unsplash
Sex & Relationships
  • A new study found that women perceive men with facial hair to be more attractive as well as physically and socially dominant.
  • Women tend to associate more masculine faces with physical strength, social assertiveness, and formidability.
  • Women who display higher levels of "moral disgust," or feelings of repugnance toward taboo behaviors, are more likely to prefer hairy faces.
Keep reading

There is no dark matter. Instead, information has mass, physicist says

Is information the fifth form of matter?

Photo: Shutterstock
Surprising Science
  • Researchers have been trying for over 60 years to detect dark matter.
  • There are many theories about it, but none are supported by evidence.
  • The mass-energy-information equivalence principle combines several theories to offer an alternative to dark matter.
Keep reading

6 reasons dogs truly are man’s best friend

Research suggests dog ownership may improve heart health, decrease depression, and even help you live longer.

Surprising Science
  • Dogs have been man's best friend for at least the past 15,000 years.
  • Science now shows that this symbiotic relationship has been as beneficial for humans as their canine companions.
  • Benefits of dog ownership include familial ties, a reduce risk of schizophrenia, and improved cardiovascular health.
Keep reading