The Recycling Industry Is Corrupt And Destroys The Environment

The Recycling Industry Is Corrupt And Destroys The Environment

Like the zero population growth camp, the zero waste movement argues for a radical rethinking of humanity's relationship toward its refuse. It, ahem, throws out all notions of waste management in favor of a culture that continually re-uses. The movement's archenemy is the recycling industry. Big Think emailed the champion of zero waste principles and Founder of the Zero Waste Institute, Paul Palmer, to get the details on how to get to zero.

How have we developed a material culture that sees recycling as the cure-all disposal method?


Recycling serves the purposes of the gigantic and powerful garbage industry and so it has a huge promotion and press. The environmentalists have been asleep. They take greenwashing as a stand-in for green. They require no theory or analysis of recycling and just accept it as the end-all because it seems so intuitively simple.

How does recycling benefit the garbage industry?

1. It blunts popular the opposition to the egregious waste--whether by dumping or incinerating or producing biodegradable materials or recycling or any other method.

2. It enshrines discard as the proper fate for once-used goods.

3. It provides a greenwashing that looks like recovery and yet produces huge quantities of heavy goods to move around the country using garbage company fleets. Keep in mind that a garbage company has no physical inventory other than a fleet of trucks. Think about glass cullet, bales of cans or bales of newspaper or cardboard.

4. It successfully gulls the environmental movement, preventing any real analysis of resources.

What do you see as the proper role for recycling?

It has no role anywhere in a sane world, since discard has no role in a sane world. If you mean merely the recapture of materials, then it is a normal part of zero waste ideation but not as a discard method. Materials recapture must be planned for in advance as part of the design of products and processes. This implies many changes in the ways that materials are managed, virtually none of which play any role in today's recycling methods but all of which require advance planning for recovery such as extensive labeling. Compare, for example, the 50,000 kinds of polymeric alloys and compositions with the childish attempt to sum up plastic varieties in nine or so codes.


How can we get toward a zero waste culture in the United States?

First, challenge the notion that recycling is a progressive approach to resource conservation. Instead of recycling as an end goal, substitute planetary protection and then insist on a wide-ranging analysis of resource usage which totally eschews all garbage-based thinking.

For example, let's completely forget all of the management of garbage. It is all irrelevant to any serious discussion. All of the moaning in the world about the size of garbage cans, the colors, the number of streams, the rate structure, the politics of waste management--all of it is completely beside the point and leads nowhere except into endless contemplation of our environmental navels. Instead, study methods which lead to the elimination of all discard everywhere.

Redesign for perpetual reuse is barely in its infancy today and 99.9 percent of the choices that need to be made are not available to anyone. We need an entire enterprise including political incentivizing, university research, industrial designing and scientific funding to come up with new designs that do not rely on discard. This approach will be bitterly resisted by every marketer who sees the dump as his high throughput assistant (throw it away and buy another one). Opposition should not hold back any political movement including this one.

A historian identifies the worst year in human history

A Harvard professor's study discovers the worst year to be alive.

The Triumph of Death. 1562.

Credit: Pieter Bruegel the Elder. (Museo del Prado).
Politics & Current Affairs
  • Harvard professor Michael McCormick argues the worst year to be alive was 536 AD.
  • The year was terrible due to cataclysmic eruptions that blocked out the sun and the spread of the plague.
  • 536 ushered in the coldest decade in thousands of years and started a century of economic devastation.
Keep reading Show less

Humanity's most distant space probe captures a strange sound

A new paper reveals that the Voyager 1 spacecraft detected a constant hum coming from outside our Solar System.

Voyager 1 in interstellar space.

Credit: NASA / JPL - Caltech.
Surprising Science
  • Voyager 1, humankind's most distant space probe, detected an unusual "hum" in the data from interstellar space.
  • The noise is likely produced by interstellar gas.
  • Further investigation may reveal the hum's exact origins.
  • Keep reading Show less

    For $50, convert your phone into a powerful chemical, pathogen detector

    A team of scientists managed to install onto a smartphone a spectrometer that's capable of identifying specific molecules — with cheap parts you can buy online.

    Photo of the constructed system: top view (a) and side view (b).

    Technology & Innovation
    • Spectroscopy provides a non-invasive way to study the chemical composition of matter.
    • These techniques analyze the unique ways light interacts with certain materials.
    • If spectrometers become a common feature of smartphones, it could someday potentially allow anyone to identify pathogens, detect impurities in food, and verify the authenticity of valuable minerals.
    Keep reading Show less
    Quantcast