Mapping Xenophobia

A noble attempt at fighting viral racism. But is it telling only half the story?

Mapping Xenophobia

As the tide of refugees rises in Europe, so does the frequency and amplitude of some very nasty rumours about these "others." 


These rumours echo historical slander against Jews, Gypsies, and other groups of outsiders previously seen as threatening. You’ve probably heard variations of some of these:

Their customs are barbaric and they hold ours in contempt; they don’t feel bound by our rules and laws; they get preferential treatment from the government; they harass, rape, and kill; they have too many children, and they’re here to "take over."  

Many of these stories are very specific and detailed, and thus sound convincing. Yet they usually have no clear source, and often they grow taller in the telling. It’s the classic urban legend syndrome, seasoned with a dose of racism — and enhanced by Twitter, Facebook, and other modern means of communication.

One concerned German netizen has decided to fight back against this rising tide of viral xenophobia.

“Since the middle of last year, we’re witnessing an increasing trend of rumours about asylum seekers going viral — ranging from them poaching swans to desecrating graves. Those stories are collected here,” writes Karolin Schwarz on Hoaxmap, which has gone live on 8 February.

Hoaxmap uses a map of Germany and Austria as the geographic backdrop for a growing collection of rumours reported and invalidated. Each rumour is described, dated, localized, categorized — and refuted, with a link to the evidence.  Some examples:

  • Rumour: The town of Kropp has hired sex workers for refugees.
  • Date: 29 January 2016
  • Location: Kropp
  • Category: money or other benefits
  • Disproved here by the Schleswiger Nachrichten.
  • Rumour: Refugees slaughter and eat a horse from the paddock beside their refugee centre in Stern Buchholz.
  • Date: 17 September 2015
  • Location: Schwerin
  • Category: poaching
  • Disproved here by Die Schweriner.
  • Rumour: no more social housing available in Cottbus because a refugee has three wives and 15 children, thus requiring four apartments
  • Date: 4 December 2015
  • Location: Cottbus
  • Category: preferential treatment
  • Disproved here by Rundfunk Berlin-Brandenburg Online.
  • Rumour: City of Erfurt offers refugees €2,000 as a "welcome gift."
  • Date: 17 September 2015
  • Location: Erfurt
  • Category: money or other benefits
  • Disproved here by the Thüringer Allgemeine.
  • Rumour: Asylum seekers urinate on gravestones.
  • Date: 4 August 2015
  • Location: Heidelberg
  • Category: grave desecration
  • Disproved here by Rheinneckarblog.
  • By far the most widespread rumour involves sex crimes committed by refugees.

  • Rumour: schoolgirl raped in broad daylight by asylum seekers
  • Date: 28 January 2016
  • Location: Krumbach
  • Category: rape
  • Disproved here by the Augsburger Allgemeine.
  • Rumour: three girls raped in Neuwied
  • Date: 8 January 2016
  • Location: Neuwied
  • Category: rape
  • Disproved here by the Westerwald Kurier.
  • Rumour: cleaning lady raped in Alfred-Fischer-Halle
  • Date: 14 January 2016
  • Location: Hamm
  • Category: rape
  • Disproved here by the Westfälischer Anzeiger.
  • And on and on it goes. The rumours, 200 and counting, are depressingly repetitive. They paint a picture of a world in which all of Germany's and Austria’s horses and swans are rapidly disappearing into refugees’ cooking pots; towns and cities are handing out money, mobile phones, and other favours to ungrateful, thieving newcomers; and girls and women are no longer safe to walk the streets, for fear of being raped and killed.

    But most of all: They reflect a world in which these rumours are fabricated, out of fear or malice, and are spread faster than ever before, via social media. Even if lies like these are refuted by the traditional press, most people remember the screaming front-page headline, not the grudging correction buried on page 54. Intentionally or not, these rumours create a climate in which extremist attitudes and politics can thrive.

    So at the very least, Hoaxmap is a noble attempt to fight back against the rising tide of hate for "others." But perhaps its good intentions are also a fatal flaw. Case in point: Zoom in on Cologne. Nothing. As some will recall, the city on the Rhine was the scene of mass assaults last New Year’s Eve, reportedly perpetrated by as many as 1,000 men of foreign extraction, with numerous thefts and some rapes reported to the police.

    Quite probably, these incidents fueled some of the hoaxes reported after 1 January — exposing the complex relationship between actual news and malicious rumour. By only reporting refuted incidents, Hoaxmap is vulnerable to the criticism that it obscures the magnitude of a very real problem. Would it not be more useful to produce a map that tracks both real and false incidents?

    --

    Map found here (in German only). Many thanks to Peter Dupont for pointing it out.

    Strange Maps #765

    Got a strange map? Let me know at strangemaps@gmail.com.

    Malcolm Gladwell live | How to re-examine everything you know

    Join Radiolab's Latif Nasser at 1pm ET on Monday as he chats with Malcolm Gladwell live on Big Think.

    Big Think LIVE

    Add event to your calendar

    AppleGoogleOffice 365OutlookOutlook.comYahoo


    Keep reading Show less

    Humans evolved for punching, study confirms

    University of Utah research finds that men are especially well suited for fisticuffs.

    Image source: durantelallera/Shutterstock
    Surprising Science
    • With males having more upper-body mass than women, a study looks to find the reason.
    • The study is based on the assumption that men have been fighters for so long that evolution has selected those best-equipped for the task.
    • If men fought other men, winners would have survived and reproduced, losers not so much.
    Keep reading Show less

    To be a great innovator, learn to embrace and thrive in uncertainty

    Innovators don't ignore risk; they are just better able to analyze it in uncertain situations.

    David McNew/Getty Images
    Personal Growth
    Madam C.J. Walker, born Sarah Breedlove, was America's first female self-made millionaire.
    Keep reading Show less

    Study: Private prisons result in more inmates, longer sentences

    The Labour Economics study suggests two potential reasons for the increase: corruption and increased capacity.

    Politics & Current Affairs
  • After adopting strict sentencing laws in the '80s and '90s, many states have turned to for-profit prisons to handle growing prison populations.
  • A new study in Labour Economics found that privately-run prisons correlate with a rise in incarceration rates and sentence lengths.
  • While evidence is mixed, private prisons do not appear to improve recidivism or cost less than state-run facilities.
  • Keep reading Show less
    Videos

    The art of asking the right questions

    What exactly does "questions are the new answers" mean?

    Scroll down to load more…
    Quantcast