The Unusual Moral Reason McCain Is Voting "No" on the GOP Health Care Bill

Sen. John McCain announced he'll be voting against GOP legislation that would repeal the Affordable Care Act.


Sen. John McCain announced in a statement that he’ll be voting against the Graham-Cassidy Republican health care bill, a decision that puts the GOP legislation in serious jeopardy.

The announcement is surprising not only because Graham and Cassidy are personal friends of McCain, but also because he's objecting to the process behind the legislation, not its policy.

McCain wrote that he “cannot in good conscience” vote for the bill because it hasn’t gone through Congress with “regular order,” and that he would have considered voting for it if it had been the product of extensive hearings, debate and amendment.” He added that the “specter” of the GOP’s budget reconciliation deadline of Sept. 30 has hung over the entire process.

I cannot in good conscience vote for Graham-Cassidy. A bill impacting so many lives deserves a bipartisan approach. https://t.co/2sDjhw6Era pic.twitter.com/30OWezQpLg

— John McCain (@SenJohnMcCain) September 22, 2017

McCain is essentially calling for Congress to play by the rules and precedents that have guided U.S. lawmaking for generations. It’s an argument against special task forces and closed-door meetings, and a call for a more bipartisan and (consequently) slower approach to government. This would theoretically imbue laws with broader appeal and a longer lifespan, as McCain wrote:

“We should not be content to pass health care legislation on a party-line basis, as Democrats did when they rammed Obamacare through Congress in 2009. If we do so, our success could be as short-lived as theirs when the political winds shift, as they regularly do. The issue is too important, and too many lives are at risk, for us to leave the American people guessing from one election to the next whether and how they will acquire health insurance. A bill of this impact requires a bipartisan approach.”

Still, “regular order remains open to interpretation.

In my view, there's no such thing as 'regular order, said Sarah Binder, a procedural expert at George Washington University and the Brookings Institution, to the Washington Post.

According to Binders, calling for “regular order” could mean a number of things: less filibustering, more bipartisanship, the idea that committees should craft policy rather than leadership. It's open to interpretation. And, as Amber Phillips writes for the Washington Post, there are a few practical roadblocks to returning to McCain's idea of "regular order":

  • The Republic Party is divided ideologically
  • The digital era has increased the power of outside interests on politics
  • President Trump is publicly attempting to influence GOP lawmakers 
  • Centuries-old protections for the minority party have been thrown out by both Democrats and Republicans in recent years
  • Party leadership, i.e. the President, is publicly pushing against regular order:
  • The U.S. Senate should switch to 51 votes, immediately, and get Healthcare and TAX CUTS approved, fast and easy. Dems would do it, no doubt!

    — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) May 30, 2017

    Big Think Edge
    • The meaning of the word 'confidence' seems obvious. But it's not the same as self-esteem.
    • Confidence isn't just a feeling on your inside. It comes from taking action in the world.
    • Join Big Think Edge today and learn how to achieve more confidence when and where it really matters.

    To boost your self-esteem, write about chapters of your life

    If you're lacking confidence and feel like you could benefit from an ego boost, try writing your life story.

    Personal Growth

    In truth, so much of what happens to us in life is random – we are pawns at the mercy of Lady Luck. To take ownership of our experiences and exert a feeling of control over our future, we tell stories about ourselves that weave meaning and continuity into our personal identity.

    Keep reading Show less

    Active ingredient in Roundup found in 95% of studied beers and wines

    The controversial herbicide is everywhere, apparently.

    (MsMaria/Shutterstock)
    Surprising Science
    • U.S. PIRG tested 20 beers and wines, including organics, and found Roundup's active ingredient in almost all of them.
    • A jury on August 2018 awarded a non-Hodgkin's lymphoma victim $289 million in Roundup damages.
    • Bayer/Monsanto says Roundup is totally safe. Others disagree.
    Keep reading Show less

    Ashes of cat named Pikachu to be launched into space

    A space memorial company plans to launch the ashes of "Pikachu," a well-loved Tabby, into space.

    GoFundMe/Steve Munt
    Culture & Religion
    • Steve Munt, Pikachu's owner, created a GoFundMe page to raise money for the mission.
    • If all goes according to plan, Pikachu will be the second cat to enter space, the first being a French feline named Felicette.
    • It might seem frivolous, but the cat-lovers commenting on Munt's GoFundMe page would likely disagree.
    Keep reading Show less