Skip to content
Starts With A Bang

Is it possible to pull something out of a black hole?

Falling into a black hole is forever… but could a tether to the outside pull you back out?

“Nobody ever did, or ever will, escape the consequences of his choices.” 
Alfred A. Montapert

Once something falls into a black hole, it can never get out. No matter how much energy you have, you can never move faster than the speed of light, and yet you’d need to in order to exit of the event horizon once you’ve crossed inside. But what if you tried to cheat that little rule by tethering a tiny object that just dipped inside the event horizon to a much larger, more massive one that was destined to escape? Could you pull something out of a black hole that way, or any other way? The laws of physics are restrictive, but they should tell us whether it’s possible or not. Let’s find out!

Flamm’s paraboloid, shown here, represents the spacetime curvature outside the event horizon of a Schwarzschild black hole. Image credit: AllenMcC. of Wikimedia Commons.

A black hole isn’t merely an ultra-dense, ultra-massive singularity, where space is curved so tremendously that anything that falls in can’t escape. Although that’s what we conventionally think of, a black hole is more accurately the region of space around this objects from which no form of matter or energy — not even light itself — can escape. This isn’t as foreign or exotic as you might think: if you took the Sun, exactly as-is, and compressed it down to a region of space just a few kilometers in radius, a black hole is exactly what you’d wind up with. Although our Sun is in no danger of undergoing such a transition, there are stars in the Universe that will wind up producing a black hole in this very fashion.

The star forming region 30 Doradus, in the Tarantula Nebula in one of the Milky Way’s satellite galaxies, contains the largest, highest-mass stars known to humanity. The largest, R136a1, is approximately 260 times the Sun’s mass. Image credit: NASA, ESA, and E. Sabbi (ESA/STScI); Acknowledgment: R. O’Connell (University of Virginia) and the Wide Field Camera 3 Science Oversight Committee.

The most massive stars in the Universe — stars with twenty, forty, a hundred, or even, at the core of the super star cluster shown above, up to 260 times the mass of our Sun — are the bluest, hottest, and most luminous objects out there. They also burn through the nuclear fuel in their cores the most quickly of all stars: just one or two million years instead of many billions like the Sun. When these inner cores run out of nuclear fuel, the nuclei at the core are subject to tremendous gravitational forces: forces so strong that, without the incredible pressure from the radiation of nuclear fusion to hold them up, they implode. In less extreme cases, the nuclei and electrons have so much energy that they fuse into a mass of neutrons, all bound together. If the core is more massive than a few times the mass of the Sun, those neutrons will be so dense and so massive that they themselves will collapse, leading to a black hole.

An illustration of an active black hole, one that accretes matter and accelerates a portion of it outwards in two perpendicular jets, may describe the black hole at the center of our galaxy in many regards. But nothing from within the event horizon could ever get out. Image credit: Mark A. Garlick.

That’s the minimum mass of a black hole, mind you: a few times the mass of the Sun. Black holes can grow much larger than that, though, by merging together, by devouring matter-and-energy, and by sinking to the centers of galaxies. At the center of the Milky Way, we’ve identified an object that’s some four million times the mass of the Sun, where individual stars are seen orbiting it, but where no light of any wavelength is emitted.

Other galaxies can have even more massive black holes that are thousands of times the mass of our own, with no theoretical upper limit to how large they can grow. But there are two interesting properties about black holes that are going to lead us to the answer of whether anything tethered can escape. The first is what happens to space the more massive a black hole gets. The definition of a black hole is that no object can escape from its gravitational pull in a region of space, no matter how quickly that object accelerates, no matter even if it moves at the speed of light. That border between where an object could and an object couldn’t escape is what’s known as an event horizon, and every black hole has one.

The black hole at the center of the Milky Way, along with the actual, physical size of the Event Horizon pictured in white. The visual extent of darkness will appear to be 5/2 as large as the event horizon itself. Image credit: Ute Kraus, Physics education group Kraus, Universität Hildesheim; background: Axel Mellinger.

What might surprise you is that the curvature of space is much smaller at the event horizon around the most massive black holes, and is most severe (and largest) around the least massive ones! Think about it this way: if you “stood” on the event horizon of a black hole, with your feet right at the edge and your head some 1.6 meters farther away from the singularity, there would be a force stretching — spaghettifying — your body. If that black hole were the one at the center of our galaxy, the force that stretches you would be only 0.1% the force of gravity here on Earth, while if Earth itself were turned into a black hole and you stood on that, that stretching force would be some 1020 times as strong as Earth’s gravity!

Even something as massive as a star, if brought too close to a black hole, will find itself stretched-and-compressed into a long, thin filament: spaghettified. The effects on a human being are equally severe if the black hole is low enough in mass. Image credit: ESO, ESA/Hubble, M. Kornmesser.

If these stretching forces are small at the edge of the event horizon, they’re not going to be much larger inside the event horizon, and so — given the strength of the electromagnetic forces that hold solid objects together — perhaps we’ll be able to do exactly what was suggested: dangle an object outside the event horizon, cross it momentarily, and then pull it safely back. But would that be possible? To understand this, let’s go back to what happens at the very border between a neutron star and a black hole: just at that mass threshold.

A neutron star is one of the densest collections of matter in the Universe, but there is an upper limit to their mass. Exceed it, and the neutron star will further collapse to form a black hole. Image credit: ESO/Luís Calçada.

Imagine you’ve got a ball of neutrons that’s spectacularly dense, but where a photon on the surface can still escape off into space and not necessarily spiral in to the neutron star itself. Now, let’s place one more neutron on that surface, and suddenly the core itself can’t hold up against gravitational collapse. But rather than thinking about what’s happening at the surface, let’s think about what’s happening inside the region where the black hole is forming. Imagine an individual neutron, made up of quarks and gluons, and imagine how the gluons need to travel from one quark to another within a neutron in order to exchange forces.

The force exchanges inside a proton, mediated by colored quarks, can only move at the speed of light; no faster. Inside a black hole’s event horizon, these light-like geodesics are inevitably drawn to the central singularity. Image credit: Wikimedia Commons user Qashqaiilove.

Now, one of these quarks is going to be closer to the singularity at the center of the black hole than another, and another will be farther away. For an exchange of forces to happen — and for a neutron to be stable — a gluon will have to travel, at some point, from the closer quark to the farther quark. But even at the speed of light (and gluons are massless), that’s not possible! All null geodesics, or the path an object moving at the speed of light will travel along, will lead to the singularity at the center of the black hole. Moreover, they will never get farther away from the black hole’s singularity than they are at the moment of emission. That is why a neutron inside of a black hole’s event horizon must collapse to become part of the singularity at the center.

Once you cross the threshold to form a black hole, everything inside the event horizon crunches down to a singularity that is, at most, one-dimensional. No 3D structures can survive intact. Image credit: Ask The Van / UIUC Physics Department.

So now, let’s come back to the tether example: you’ve got a small mass tethered to a large ship; the ship is outside the event horizon but the mass dips inside. Whenever any particle crosses the event horizon, it’s impossible for any particle — even light — to escape from it again. But photons and gluons are the very particles we need to exchange forces with the particles that are still outside the event horizon, and they can’t go there!

This doesn’t necessarily mean that your tether will snap; it more likely means that the rushing ride towards the singularity will pull your entire ship in. Sure, the tidal forces, under the right conditions, won’t tear you apart, but that’s not what makes reaching the singularity inevitable. Rather, it’s the incredible attractive force of gravitation and the fact that all particles of all masses, energies and velocities have no choice but to head towards the singularity once they cross the event horizon.

Anything that find itself inside the event horizon that surrounds a black hole, no matter what else is going on in the Universe, will find itself sucked into the central singularity. Image credit: Bob Gardner / ETSU.

And for that reason, I’m sorry to say, there is still no way out of a black hole once you cross the event horizon. You can cut your losses and cut off what’s already inside, or you can stay connected and let everything get sucked inside. The choice is up to you, but let this be a lesson to everyone who has dreams of someday flying by a black hole: keep your hands and feet inside!

Ethan Siegel is the author of Beyond the Galaxy and Treknology. You can pre-order his third book, currently in development: the Encyclopaedia Cosmologica.


Up Next