Some thoughts on U.S. News World Report's 100 best public high schools

My father-in-law gave me the January 2010 issue of U.S. News & World Report. It features a number of articles on P-12 education and includes detailed tables of its '100 best public high schools' in the United States. I've been playing around with the data a bit...

1. Nationally, it helps to be rich and/or flexible

The tables show that 72 of the top 100 schools are magnet schools, charter schools, or have an application process for students. Only 33 of the top 100 high schools are classified as open enrollment schools. What's not apparent from the online tables (but is in the printed version), however, is that 5 of those 33 also are labeled as magnet or charter schools and that 26 of the remaining 28 have fewer than 10% of their students classified as economically disadvantaged. In other word, only 2 of the 100 'best' public high schools are traditional open enrollment schools serving a socioeconomically-diverse student population:

  • High School for Dual Language and Asian Studies (#52; New York, New York)
  • Hidalog Early College High School (#97; Hidalgo, Texas)
  • 2. In Iowa, small homogenous schools reign

    No high schools in Iowa were given a gold medal by U.S. News. Only 1 of the 47 Iowa high schools given a bronze or silver medal has a sizable number of students in it:

    • Washington High School (1,463 students; Linn County, Iowa)
    • The remaining 46 high schools have fewer than 600 students. Over 3/4 have fewer than 300 students, often spread out over grades 7 through 12, not just grades 9 through 12. Only 4 of the 47 high schools (including Washington High School above) have racial/ethnic minority student percentages greater than 6%.

      3. Are these schools good models for others?

      No doubt these are good schools. Some of them appear on the U.S. News list every year. But many will question whether they are good models or exemplars for traditional schools. Are they doing things differently in terms of curriculum, instruction, expectations for student work, teacher training, etc.? And to the extent that they are, how much is due to their greater flexibility compared to more traditional schools?

      I'm not disparaging these schools. I'm just thinking out loud here...

      Car culture and suburban sprawl create rifts in society, claims study

      New research links urban planning and political polarization.

      Politics & Current Affairs
      • Canadian researchers find that excessive reliance on cars changes political views.
      • Decades of car-centric urban planning normalized unsustainable lifestyles.
      • People who prefer personal comfort elect politicians who represent such views.
      Keep reading Show less

      How to split the USA into two countries: Red and Blue

      Progressive America would be half as big, but twice as populated as its conservative twin.

      Image: Dicken Schrader
      Strange Maps
      • America's two political tribes have consolidated into 'red' and 'blue' nations, with seemingly irreconcilable differences.
      • Perhaps the best way to stop the infighting is to go for a divorce and give the two nations a country each
      • Based on the UN's partition plan for Israel/Palestine, this proposal provides territorial contiguity and sea access to both 'red' and 'blue' America
      Keep reading Show less

      NASA astronomer Michelle Thaller on ​the multiple dimensions of space and human sexuality

      Science and the squishiness of the human mind. The joys of wearing whatever the hell you want, and so much more.

      Flickr / 13winds
      Think Again Podcasts
      • Why can't we have a human-sized cat tree?
      • What would happen if you got a spoonful of a neutron star?
      • Why do we insist on dividing our wonderfully complex selves into boring little boxes
      Keep reading Show less