Has Neuroscience Been Looking In the Wrong Place All Along?

Philosopher Alva Noë says there’s a big problem with neuroscience: It assumes brains produce consciousness.


Philosopher Alva Noë has a major concern about the most fundamental assumption neurosciencists make: That the brain is where our consciousness lives. He says that’s like looking for dance inside a dancer’s muscles.

According to Noë, the assumption is just an old idea with a new twist, with the long-held belief in an immaterial spirit being replaced by one in which it’s the lit-up neurons in fMRI scans that make us, well, us. The bottom line, he says, is that we’re still looking in the wrong place.

Near the heart of neuroscience’s belief in the brain as the source of consciousness is the fMRI imagery showing various areas of the brain working as test subjects think and do. It’s worth remembering, though, that we have no way thus far of knowing whether what we’re seeing is correlation or causation.

Compelling speakers do these 4 things every single time

The ability to speak clearly, succinctly, and powerfully is easier than you think

Former U.S. President Barack Obama speaks during a Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee rally at the Anaheim Convention Center on September 8, 2018 in Anaheim, California. (Photo by Barbara Davidson/Getty Images)
Personal Growth

The ability to communicate effectively can make or break a person's assessment of your intelligence, competence, and authenticity.

Keep reading Show less

Scientists invent method to extract gold from liquid waste

The next gold rush might take place in our sewers.

Shutterstock
Surprising Science
  • Even though we think of it as exceedingly rare, gold can be found all around us.
  • The trouble is, most of the gold is hard to get at; its too diluted in our waste or ocean waters to effectively extract.
  • This new technique quickly, easily, and reliably extracts gold from most liquids.
Keep reading Show less

How 'dark horses' flip the script of success and happiness

What defines a dark horse? The all-important decision to pursue fulfillment and excellence.

Big Think Books

When we first set the Dark Horse Project in motion, fulfillment was the last thing on our minds. We were hoping to uncover specific and possibly idiosyncratic study methods, learning techniques, and rehearsal regimes that dark horses used to attain excellence. Our training made us resistant to ambiguous variables that were difficult to quantify, and personal fulfillment seemed downright foggy. But our training also taught us never to ignore the evidence, no matter how much it violated our expectations.

Keep reading Show less