Re: Re: Are faith and reason incompatible?

Perhaps I'm in the minority, but I tend to view "faith" and "reason" as incompatible; in fact, I see them as diametrically opposed to one another.

From a semantics standpoint, there is a world of difference between the two terms.  Reason, on the one hand, is a verified (and verifiable) fact that logically justifies either a premise or conclusion.  From its definition, one gets the sense that reason involves an evidentiary inquest.  Faith, on the other hand, is something entirely different.  By its definition, faith implies a trust, belief, or acceptance without evidence or investigation.  From this perspective, faith and reason appear to be strict antonyms, rather than compatible terms.

I am troubled when I hear people try to force together the terms, as if they were jamming a square peg into a round hole.  To argue, as some have, that faith is what happens when you exhaust reason is insulting to the very foundations of academia.  In academic inquiries, the conclusions we draw must always be based upon the credible evidence that we have at our disposal.  Any academic worth his or her salt would find it reprehensible to say, when the evidence and logic does not support the hypothesis, that you can simply continue believe something to be true.  As far as I'm concerned, this sort of faith is not a virtue.

I have heard others remark that faith and reason are compatible because they can be interchanged to answer life's questions.  The specific quote, I believe, was that faith is important because  "reason and science can't explain everything."  There are too many things wrong with this statement to catalogue in this post; suffice it to say that such utterances make the hair on my neck stand on end.  It is a non sequitur (that is: it does not follow) that if science or reason doesn't yet have the answer to a question that faith should automatically become the default alternative.  Why would faith be an appropriate substitute for reason?  Faith has a terrible track record when it comes to getting things right (see: the shape of the Earth, the nature of the solar system, the cause of disease and natural disasters etc, etc., etc!)  I would have thought that faith lost its right to sit beside reason, as a method of observation, a long time ago.

I cannot be sure of the motivation behind such attempts to force together faith and reason.  I would suspect that it is done in an effort to bolster the credibility of faith, specifically religious faith, so that faith can give the appearance of having a logical or evidentiary basis.  In reality, by arguing for interconnectivity between faith and reason, one establishes a false compatibility that subverts the natural tension between the terms.  Reason relies solely on logic and the evidence to form a conclusion; faith implies the willingness to maintain a belief, in the face of contrary (or lacking) evidence and logic.

Some might find it sophomoric to harp incessantly on the definition of the terms -- everyone cringes at the freshman paper that begins: "The Oxford English Dictionary defines the term _____ as ____."  However, I would argue that it is important, in this case, to understand what these terms mean.  Failing to do so enhances the possibility that one will misunderstand the nature of the question and wrongly (in my opinion) argue for compatibility between faith and reason.  In the end, faith and reason are very different things.  They are not, in my estimation, the least bit compatible.

Ethnic chauvinism: Why the whole world shouldn’t look like America

We are constantly trying to force the world to look like us — we need to move on.

  • When the Berlin Wall fell in 1989, many Americans jumped for joy. At the time, some believed there weren't going to be any more political disagreements anywhere in the world. They thought American democracy had won the "war of ideas."
  • American exceptionalism has sought to create a world order that's really a mirror image of ourselves — a liberal world order founded on the DNA of American thinking. To many abroad this looks like ethnic chauvinism.
  • We need to move on from this way of thinking, and consider that sometimes "problem-solving," in global affairs, means the world makes us look like how it wants to be.
Keep reading Show less

Physicists find new state of matter that can supercharge technology

Scientists make an important discovery for the future of computing.

Surprising Science
  • Researchers find a new state of matter called "topological superconductivity".
  • The state can lead to important advancements in quantum computing.
  • Utilizing special particles that emerge during this state can lead to error-free data storage and blazing calculation speed.
Keep reading Show less

First solar roadway in France turned out to be a 'total disaster'

French newspapers report that the trial hasn't lived up to expectations.

Image source: Charly Triballeau / AFP / Getty Images
Technology & Innovation
  • The French government initially invested in a rural solar roadway in 2016.
  • French newspapers report that the trial hasn't lived up to expectations.
  • Solar panel "paved" roadways are proving to be inefficient and too expensive.
Keep reading Show less