Re: Gilbert and Aristotle

How do you see this fitting with Aristotle's discussion of virtue ethics and eudamonia? In particular, I'm thinking about his ideas expressed in the Nicomachean Ethics, where the goal is to train yourself over time to live in such a way as to do what is right, which also turns out to be what is good for us. According to Aristotle then, acting virtuously is a source of pleasure- natural happiness as Gilbert refers to it elsewhere, while also ensuring synthetic happiness.


Since acting virtuously requires certain behaviors and bars others, synthetic happiness would be the result of our being glad about the things we chose NOT to do. Even, or especially, when those choices were particularly tempting. If the difficulties we have in being happy are linked to our poor affective forecasting skills, then a training in those actions that would help us more reliably forecast can only be beneficial. Virtue ethics would then be a way to: 1. more accurately forecast those actions that would make us happy 2. help us feel good about those tempting possibilities that we rejected 3. give us a sense of immediate gratification from our being virtuous.

My question here is whether this seems like a fair way to tie Aristotelian ethics to what gilbert is talking about-- am I trying too hard to make things fit which actually do not? What other ways might we be able to tie this research gilbert is doing now to our great thinkers of the past?

Live on Thursday: Learn innovation with 3-star Michelin chef Dominique Crenn

Dominique Crenn, the only female chef in America with three Michelin stars, joins Big Think Live this Thursday at 1pm ET.

Big Think LIVE

Add event to your calendar

AppleGoogleOffice 365OutlookOutlook.comYahoo


Keep reading Show less

Physicists solve a 140-year-old mystery

Scientists discover the inner workings of an effect that will lead to a new generation of devices.

Carrier-resolved photo-Hall effect.

Credit: IBM
Surprising Science
  • Researchers discover a method of extracting previously unavailable information from superconductors.
  • The study builds on a 19th-century discovery by physicist Edward Hall.
  • The research promises to lead to a new generation of semiconductor materials and devices.
Keep reading Show less

Does forgetting a name or word mean that I have dementia?

The number of people with dementia is expected to triple by 2060.

Photo by Connor Wang on Unsplash
Mind & Brain
The number of cases of dementia in the U.S. is rising as baby boomers age, raising questions for boomers themselves and also for their families, caregivers and society.
Keep reading Show less

New Hubble images add to the dark matter puzzle

The images and our best computer models don't agree.

Surprising Science
  • Scientists can detect the gravitational effects of invisible dark matter.
  • Dark matter causes visual distortions of what's behind it.
  • The greater the distortion, the greater the amount of dark matter. Maybe.
  • Keep reading Show less
    Culture & Religion

    Did our early ancestors boil their food in hot springs?

    Scientists have found evidence of hot springs near sites where ancient hominids settled, long before the control of fire.

    Scroll down to load more…
    Quantcast