Would the Republican Economic Plan Work?

Today’s economic news was not good. The Commerce Department lowered its estimate of second quarter growth from an annual rate of 2.4% to an annual rate of 1.6%. That’s down from 3.7% in the first quarter of 2010 and 5.0% in the last quarter of 2009. Although the revision was smaller than many economists had feared, it’s nevertheless a sign that the recovery—if that’s what this is—is stalling.


The poor economy threatens to turn the November midterm elections into a complete rout for Democrats. With the official unemployment rate at 9.6%—and the actual percent of people who want more work than they can find maybe twice as high—Americans are suffering. More people now disapprove of President Obama’s performance than approve, and Republicans lead Democrats by 5 points on a generic Congressional ballot. The political futures market Intrade gives the Republicans a 76% chance of retaking the House. FiveThirtyEight’s Nate Silver projects they will also pick up 6-7 seats in the Senate, and even have a shot to win a majority in the Senate as well. President Obama and the Democrats may not have created the financial crisis, but they are going to held responsible for not having done more to manufacture a recovery.

With the Republicans likely to make major gains in Congress on the strength of frustration with the Democrats' inability to fix the economy, it’s fair to ask just what Republicans would do differently. In a speech to the City Club of Cleveland on Tuesday, House Minority Leader—and prospective Speaker of the House—John Boehner (R-OH) laid out his alternative to the Democratic plan. First, he wants to keep the Bush-era tax cuts—including the unpopular tax cuts for families making more than $250,000/year—from expiring at the end of the year. Second, he opposes both a cap-and-trade scheme to limit the emission of greenhouse gases and card-check legislation that would make it easier for labor unions to form. Third, he called for repeal of the health care reform bill’s so-called “1099 mandate,” which starting in 2012 will require businesses to report more of their income to the government. Fourth, he wants “aggressive” cuts in government spending. And, fifth, he wants Obama’s economic team—and in particular Secretary of the Treasury Timothy Geithner and National Economic Council Director Larry Summers—to step down.

What’s striking about Boehner’s plan is how little it actually would do. Extending the tax cuts and rolling back the stimulus would simply be a return to the economic policies of the Bush administration. Cap-and-trade schemes, card-check rules, and the 1099 provision of the health care bill clearly aren’t to blame for the weak economy, since none of those laws have gone into effect or are likely to any time soon. Boehner doesn’t seem to have any positive ideas for how to address the our economic crisis. His whole argument seems to be that we would be better off we had simply continued doing we what we were doing under Bush.

That’s hard to believe. While the stimulus package failed to get the economy really going again, the consensus among economists is that we would be in even worse shape without it. The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office estimates that the Recovery Act has saved between 1.4 and 3.3 million jobs that would otherwise have been lost. And, as Gary Burtless argues, the stimulus package is what kept disposable income from falling dramatically as wages were cut and people lost their jobs.

Meanwhile, as Andrew Romano explains, although getting rid of the stimulus by itself would save money, the savings would be more than offset by repealing health care bill—which the Congressional Budget Office says will actually save money—and extending the Bush tax cuts. The net effect of Boehner's plan would be to increase the deficit by more than $300 billion. Nor would his plan be likely to create jobs. As William Gale points out, most of the benefits of the keeping the tax cuts will go to the rich, which is typically the least effective way to stimulate the economy. Any jobs that keeping the tax cuts would create would be more than offset by the jobs lost without the stimulus. So if Boehner had his way the deficit would be larger and the unemployment rate would be higher.

“Bush economics on steroids,” is what Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee chair Chris Van Hollen calls Boehner’s proposals. That’s the case the Democrats have to make. They have to convince the public that if Boehner had his way things would be even worse. Fortunately, for Boehner and the Republicans, as long as people are struggling to make ends meet, it’s going to be a hard sell.

How to vaccinate the world’s most vulnerable? Build global partnerships.

Pfizer's partnerships strengthen their ability to deliver vaccines in developing countries.

Susan Silbermann, Global President of Pfizer Vaccines, looks on as a health care worker administers a vaccine in Rwanda. Photo: Courtesy of Pfizer.
Sponsored
  • Community healthcare workers face many challenges in their work, including often traveling far distances to see their clients
  • Pfizer is helping to drive the UN's sustainable development goals through partnerships.
  • Pfizer partnered with AMP and the World Health Organization to develop a training program for healthcare workers.
Keep reading Show less

James Patterson on writing: Plotting, research, and first drafts

The best-selling author tells us his methods.

Videos
  • James Patterson has sold 300 million copies of his 130 books, making him one of the most successful authors alive today.
  • He talks about how some writers can overdo it by adding too much research, or worse, straying from their outline for too long.
  • James' latest book, The President is Missing, co-written with former President Bill Clinton, is out now.
Keep reading Show less

How to split the USA into two countries: Red and Blue

Progressive America would be half as big, but twice as populated as its conservative twin.

Image: Dicken Schrader
Strange Maps
  • America's two political tribes have consolidated into 'red' and 'blue' nations, with seemingly irreconcilable differences.
  • Perhaps the best way to stop the infighting is to go for a divorce and give the two nations a country each
  • Based on the UN's partition plan for Israel/Palestine, this proposal provides territorial contiguity and sea access to both 'red' and 'blue' America
Keep reading Show less

Why the White House Correspondents’ Association dinner won’t feature a comedian in 2019

It's the first time the association hasn't hired a comedian in 16 years.

(Photo by Anna Webber/Getty Images for Vulture Festival)
Culture & Religion
  • The 2018 WHCA ended in controversy after comedian Michelle Wolf made jokes some considered to be offensive.
  • The WHCA apologized for Wolf's jokes, though some journalists and many comedians backed the comedian and decried arguments in favor of limiting the types of speech permitted at the event.
  • Ron Chernow, who penned a bestselling biography of Alexander Hamilton, will speak at next year's dinner.
Keep reading Show less