Is Medicare About to Run Out?

Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI) claims his recent budget proposal will “save Medicare.” Medicare, he says, will run out of money in the next ten years and is “headed for a painful collapse.” Ryan’s plan, as I have explained, doesn’t actually keep Medicare funded at the same level. Instead he proposes to cut Medicare benefits now—returning that money to the wealthy in the form of new tax breaks—so that they won’t be cut later. Ryan claims that by privatizing elements of Medicare, he will increase competition and keep health care costs down. But according to the analysis of the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office, under Ryan’s plan “most elderly people would pay more for their health care than they would under the current health care system.”

Democrats, of course, have been accusing anyone who voted for Ryan’s plan of wanting to end Medicare.  That’s overstating the case, although it is probably fair to point out that the radical changes to the program Ryan proposes would end up costing seniors more money. And, of course, Republicans used the same “MediScare” strategy—claiming that Obama’s health care reform bill would destroy Medicare—against the Democrats in 2010.

Lost in all this political posturing is that Medicare is not in any grave danger. The latest Medicare trustees report says that as currently constituted the program will begin to spend more than it takes in by 2024, largely because the economic recovery has been so much slower than expected. As Maggie Mahar says, that doesn’t mean that the program will collapse in 2024, but only that it some time in the next 13 years, Medicare will either have to cut costs or increase revenues.

As Eric Zorn documents, politicians have been regularly claiming that Medicare was on the verge of bankruptcy almost since the program was created in 1965. That’s not to say that rising health care costs aren’t a serious issue in the U.S., or that the Medicare program doesn’t need to be reformed in some ways. But the constant assertions that unless Medicare benefits are slashed immediately the program will collapse are completely unwarranted. Those are the real MediScare tactics.

Big Think Edge
  • The meaning of the word 'confidence' seems obvious. But it's not the same as self-esteem.
  • Confidence isn't just a feeling on your inside. It comes from taking action in the world.
  • Join Big Think Edge today and learn how to achieve more confidence when and where it really matters.
Sponsored by the Institute for Humane Studies
  • There are 2 different approaches to governing free speech on college campuses.
  • One is a morality/order approach. The other is a bottom-up approach.
  • Emily Chamlee-Wright says there are many benefits to having no one central authority on what is appropriate speech.

Is there an optimal time of day to exercise?

Two new studies say yes. Unfortunately, each claims a different time.

Bronx, N.Y.: NYPD officer Julissa Camacho works out at the 44th precinct gym in the Bronx, New York on April 3, 2019. (Photo by Alejandra Villa Loarca/Newsday via Getty Images)
Surprising Science
  • Research at the Weizmann Institute of Sciences declares evening to be the best time for an exercise session.
  • Not so fast, says a new study at UC Irvine, which replies that late morning is the optimal workout time.
  • Both studies involved mice on treadmills and measured different markers to produce their results.
Keep reading Show less
Big Think Edge
  • Economist Sylvia Ann Hewlett breaks down what qualities will inspire others to believe in you.
  • Here's how 300 leaders and 4,000 mid-level managers described someone with executive presence.
  • Get more deep insights like these to power your career forward. Join Big Think Edge.