Is Prenatal Testing for Disease and Birth Defects a Good Idea?

There is a debate among would-be parents and experts alike, as to whether it’s better to undergo prenatal genetic testing and know if there is a problem – or not. Here are the pros and cons.

Expecting a baby can be one of the most joyous times in a couple’s life together. It can also instill a lot of worry. One of the biggest concerns is over the baby’s health. They may worry about birth defects or even genetic diseases. Luckily, most babies are born perfectly healthy. That doesn’t mean such complications are rare, but uncommon. Around one in 33 births result in a birth defect each year, according to the CDC.


Prenatal testing is by and large up to the woman or the couple. There are generally two types: screening and diagnostic tests. First trimester screening usually occurs around 10 to 13 weeks. This includes a blood test and an ultrasound, which can detect whether or not the baby might develop Down syndrome.

During the second trimester a quad screen can be performed. This can test for certain chromosomal indicators which may signal the presence of Down syndrome, along with neural tube defects, or issues with the brain or spinal cord. Keep in mind that even if such testing does come back positive, it doesn’t necessarily mean the child is doomed to a certain condition.

A diagnostic test is usually delivered if there is some sort of family history of a disease, if the mother is of a certain age, if a parent’s medical history puts the baby at risk, or another test unearths a potential problem. This is the only way to know what’s going on for sure. Usually, these are invasive, which is one of the reasons why it has to be considered carefully. In these instances, a sample of the amniotic fluid—known as amniocentesis, or of the placenta—called chorionic villus sampling (CVS), can be performed.

Advancements in medicine have given prospective parents a lot of complex decisions to make, such as what type of prenatal testing should be employed.

Lastly, there is a newcomer to the group: cell-free DNA screening. This is a blood test which examines the DNA of the fetus found in the mother’s bloodstream. It can check for specific chromosomal issues, such as Down syndrome, Tay-Sachs disease, cystic fibrosis, or sickle cell anemia. Though birth defects may occur at any point in the pregnancy, according to the CDC, they are most likely to occur in the first trimester. Currently, there is a debate among would-be parents and experts alike, as to whether it’s better to undergo prenatal genetic testing and know if there is a problem or not. Here are the pros and cons.

PRO:

  • A negative test can allay parents' fears and ease tension.
  • A positive one can help prepare the parents and let them know what to expect.
  • Parents can start saving for the care their child if disability is detected.
  • Testing can allow them to decide whether or not to keep the pregnancy.
  • CON:

  • A positive result can cause the parents anxiety and inner conflict.
  • The stress of knowing can affect their relationship.
  • Those with disabilities today can lead useful, fulfilling, vibrant lives.
  • Genetic screening can give a false positive, causing anxiety for no reason.
  • There may be a chromosomal issue the test misses.
  • Prenatal testing is optional. Some physicians suggest thinking about why a potential parent wants to know before deciding. This could help develop an understanding of whether or not it’s right for them. Dr. Andrea Greiner is a maternal and fetal medicine specialist at the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics. She told Live Science that most women don’t undergo such testing to know whether or not to have an abortion, but merely to prepare themselves.

    Some women should evaluate whether or not a positive answer would lead to undue stress, the specialist said. Dr. Greiner also notes that this science is new, and patients should keep that in mind. If you are considering prenatal testing, be sure to ask your doctor a lot of questions before deciding.

    To learn how aging affects pregnancy and prenatal testing, click here: 

    Antimicrobial resistance is a growing threat to good health and well-being

    Antimicrobial resistance is growing worldwide, rendering many "work horse" medicines ineffective. Without intervention, drug-resistant pathogens could lead to millions of deaths by 2050. Thankfully, companies like Pfizer are taking action.

    Image courtesy of Pfizer.
    • Antimicrobial-resistant pathogens are one of the largest threats to global health today.
    • As we get older, our immune systems age, increasing our risk of life threatening infections. Without reliable antibiotics, life expectancy could decline for the first time in modern history.
    • If antibiotics become ineffective, common infections could result in hospitalization or even death. Life-saving interventions like cancer treatments and organ transplantation would become more difficult, more often resulting in death. Routine procedures would become hard to perform.
    • Without intervention, resistant pathogens could result in 10 million annual deaths by 2050.
    • By taking a multi-faceted approach—inclusive of adherence to good stewardship, surveillance and responsible manufacturing practices, as well as an emphasis on prevention and treatment—companies like Pfizer are fighting to help curb the spread.
    Keep reading Show less
    Sponsored

    An ancient structure visible from space isn’t man-made

    Long hidden under trees, it's utterly massive

    (Roy Funch)
    Surprising Science
    • This 4,000-year-old structure can be seen from space and wasn't built by humans
    • It's made up of 200 million mounds of earth
    • It's still under construction today
    Keep reading Show less

    How to split the USA into two countries: Red and Blue

    Progressive America would be half as big, but twice as populated as its conservative twin.

    Image: Dicken Schrader
    Strange Maps
    • America's two political tribes have consolidated into 'red' and 'blue' nations, with seemingly irreconcilable differences.
    • Perhaps the best way to stop the infighting is to go for a divorce and give the two nations a country each
    • Based on the UN's partition plan for Israel/Palestine, this proposal provides territorial contiguity and sea access to both 'red' and 'blue' America
    Keep reading Show less

    How Christians co-opted the winter solstice

    Christmas has many pagan and secular traditions that early Christians incorporated into this new holiday.

    Saturnalia by Antoine Callet
    Culture & Religion
    • Christmas was heavily influenced by the Roman festival of Saturnalia.
    • The historical Jesus was not born on December 25th as many contemporary Christians believe.
    • Many staple Christmas traditions predated the festival and were tied into ancient pagan worship of the sun and related directly to the winter solstice.
    Keep reading Show less