Could an updated Feynman experiment finally lead to a Theory of Everything?

Measuring quantum gravity has proven extremely challenging, stymying some of the greatest minds in physics for generations.

For over a century, the two leading theories in physics have had irreconcilable differences, and scientists have scrambled to find ways to square them, to no avail. An experiment proposed in 1957 by American luminary Richard Feynman, is now getting a makeover, and the results could be significant.


Scientists at Oxford University and University College London (UCL), are attempting to overhaul one of the late Nobel Laureate's experiments and in doing so, hope to heal the rift in a dramatic fashion. Could a Theory of Everything be near? This would be incorporating all four physical forces: gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak nuclear forces, into one solid working theory.

Thus far, theoretical physicist Steven Weinberg, himself a Nobel Laureate, has only been able to combine electromagnetism and the weak nuclear force. A final theory—as Weinberg calls it, would mark the end of physics as we know it. Although the laws of general relativity and quantum mechanics work exceptionally well in their own spheres, some of the rules that govern one area don’t work in the other, and vice-versa. For instance, Relativity explains the gravitational force as it relates to bodies on Earth or in space. But it falls apart on the quantum level.

The merging of two neutron stars. Einstein’s general relativity helps us understand the gravitational forces involved well. Where it gets lost is on the quantum level. Credit: European Space Agency (ESA).

The current upgrade to Feynman’s proposal focuses on quantum gravity. Two papers on the upcoming experiment were published in the journal Physical Review Letters. In the first researchers write, “Understanding gravity in the framework of quantum mechanics is one of the great challenges in modern physics.” A lot of experiments have been proposed, but it’s proven extremely difficult to test quantum gravity in the lab.

One of the reasons, researchers write in the second paper, “Quantum effects in the gravitational field are exceptionally small, unlike those in the electromagnetic field.” Sougato Bose leads the UCL team. He told Physics World, “For example, even the electrostatic force between two electrons overtakes the gravitational force between two kilogram masses by several orders of magnitude.”

These physicists believe if they can detect gravity on the quantum level, it would help us better understand why it operates so differently there, and perhaps reveal the secret to navigating between our two prevailing theories. Feynman’s idea to test for quantum gravity surrounds something known as superposition. A particle is thought to exist in all possible states or positions at once, until measured. Then you can nail down its exact location (or velocity, but not both).

Feynman speculated that using quantum entanglement, one could take a small mass and place it inside a gravitational field, causing it to become entangled with the field on the quantum level. Then, the physicist would be able to detect the field’s interference, before indicating the mass’s position. The interference itself would cause the mass to take a single, specific location or form, which would occur before the mass separated itself from the field. And so in this way, quantum gravity could be detected.

Illustration of a quantum gravity photon race. The purple or high energy photon carries a million times the energy of the yellow one. Yet, it’s thought to move slower as it interacts more with the frothy material of space. In 2009, satellites measured a gamma ray burst from a neutron star collision. Curiously, after traveling approximately 7 billion light years, a pair of such photons arrived just nine-tenths of a second apart. Credit: NASA Goddard Space Flight Center

Oxford researchers Chiara Marletto and Vlatko Vedral worry that since entanglement isn’t measured directly in Feynman’s proposed experiment, it wouldn’t provide direct evidence of quantum gravity. By quantizing not one but two masses and entangling them, the Oxford physicists say, quantum gravity can be detected directly. Each mass would be in superposition and entangled in a quantum gravity field. UCL physicists added their own element, a “quantum gravity mediator,” to entangle the masses.

To conduct the experiment, two identical interferometers will be placed adjacent to one another. These usually split light up into its constituent parts. But down on the quantum level, these devices interfere with a mass’s quantum wave function, in order to superimpose its quantum state. If gravity is operating on the quantum level, the two masses will become entangled before each leaves its own interferometer.

An artist’s depiction of quantum entanglement. Credit: The National Science Foundation.

Dr. Marletto explained in Physics World,

Our two teams took slightly different approaches to the proposal. Vedral and I provided a general proof of the fact that any system that can mediate entanglement between two quantum systems must itself be quantum. On the other hand, Bose and his team discussed the details of a specific experiment, using two spin states to create the spatial superposition of the masses.

This isn’t a done deal by any means. Electromagnetic forces might interfere with the entanglement before researchers are able to measure the effects of quantum gravity. Even if the gravitational field is quantized, quantum gravity may be harder to detect than scientists predict. But if it does work, it could lead to quite a breakthrough.

There are a lot of theories on how gravity operates on the quantum level. It may originate from particles called gravitons, which would be carriers of gravity much like how photons carry electromagnetism. Quantum gravity and string theory have their own bends. The results of this experiment could help us sort quantum gravity out, and perhaps lead to a final theory, at which time, it’d be the dawning of a whole new understanding of the universe and how all its forces fit together.

To learn more about where we’re at with the Theory of Everything, click here:

Should you defend the free speech rights of neo-Nazis?

Former president of the ACLU Nadine Strossen discusses whether our society should always defend free speech rights, even for groups who would oppose such rights.

Sponsored by Charles Koch Foundation
  • Former ACLU president Nadine Strossen understands that protecting free speech rights isn't always a straightforward proposition.
  • In this video, Strossen describes the reasoning behind why the ACLU defended the free speech rights of neo-Nazis in Skokie, Illinois, 1977.
  • The opinions expressed in this video do not necessarily reflect the views of the Charles Koch Foundation, which encourages the expression of diverse viewpoints within a culture of civil discourse and mutual respect.
Keep reading Show less

Moon mission 2.0: What humanity will learn by going back to the Moon

Going back to the moon will give us fresh insights about the creation of our solar system.

Videos
  • July 2019 marks the 50th anniversary of the moon landing — Apollo 11.
  • Today, we have a strong scientific case for returning to the moon: the original rock samples that we took from the moon revolutionized our view of how Earth and the solar system formed. We could now glean even more insights with fresh, nonchemically-altered samples.
  • NASA plans to send humans to a crater in the South Pole of the moon because it's safer there, and would allow for better communications with people back on Earth.

NASA releases stunning image of ISS crossing in front of the sun

Strangely, the sun showed no sunspots at the time the photo was taken.

Image source: Rainee Colacurcio
Surprising Science
  • The photo shows the International Space Station as it orbits the Earth, as it does every 90 minutes.
  • The photo is remarkable because it offers a glimpse of the star at a time when there were no sunspots.
  • In November, astronauts aboard the ISS plan to grow Española chili pepper plants.
Keep reading Show less

U.S. Air Force warns UFO enthusiasts against storming Area 51

Jokesters and serious Area 51 raiders would be met with military force.

Politics & Current Affairs
  • Facebook joke event to "raid Area 51" has already gained 1,000,000 "going" attendees.
  • The U.S. Air Force has issued an official warning to potential "raiders."
  • If anyone actually tries to storm an American military base, the use of deadly force is authorized.
Keep reading Show less