New Gene Editing Technology Can Eliminate Whole Species — Should We Use It?

A report by a team of scientists highlights the dangers of "gene drive" technology that can eliminate unwanted species.

worker fighting pika virus

While ethical considerations have always troubled thoughtful scientists, the fact of the matter is that if something can be done, somebody usually does it. While a few had clear concerns about creating an Atomic bomb in the first place, there were more than enough scientists who put their minds to work on creating one. A similar conundrum is taking place now with the technological breakthroughs that allow us to manipulate genetic code.


A technique known as “gene drive” enables scientists to insert genetic code into a species that would be passed onto to its offspring. One potential outcome of this ability is to be able to eliminate unwanted species that carry disease. You could possibly eliminate malaria, dengue fever, Lyme disease. Or stop the much-publicized Zika Virus by getting rid of virus-carrying mosquitoes. In fact, maybe we should get rid of mosquitoes in general. Not many humans will stand up for the necessity to keep these pesky blood-suckers around. 

Potential applications of RNA-guided gene drives. Clockwise from left. Taken from a paper on gene drives by a group of Harvard scientists.

A report published this week by the U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine both validated this technology and cautioned that it's a power not to be taken lightly. Who knows what releasing genetically altered organisms into the wild would lead to? 

“There is insufficient evidence available at this time to support the release of gene-drive modified organisms into the environment,” states the paper.

On the other hand, the report did not call for a ban on this technology and, ultimately, underscored the fact that sooner or later these organisms will find their way out into ecological systems, whether by plan, subterfuge or simple mistake. if it can, it will happen. 

“Gene drive” is spread through sexual reproduction and will spread as long as the members of the affected species keep reproducing. It’s also possible that if there’s any inter-species mating that occurs, a new species will get changed. And so on and so forth.

How gene drives spread.

Of course, while risks exist, gene manipulation is here to stay and will continue to advance. One positive application of gene editing that’s made waves was demonstrated by scientists at Temple University - they were able to delete the HIV virus from infected mice

How exactly would the gene drive get rid of a whole species? This tech is called “crash drive”. It works by getting a gene engineered into the Y chromosome that will shred the X chromes in the cells that make sperm. This will ensure that all the offspring will be male. The number of females would dwindle each generation until the population disappears. Nothing is likely to go wrong with such a plan.

Moral quandaries aside, now that we can, which species should we eliminate first?

I’d say, let’s start with cockroaches. I mean, come on. Cockroaches. No love lost there. 

Then, let’s move onto rats. Black Plague, anyone?

Others might include - venomous scorpions and snakes. Did I say spiders yet? 

Would we really miss seeing this?

U.S. Navy controls inventions that claim to change "fabric of reality"

Inventions with revolutionary potential made by a mysterious aerospace engineer for the U.S. Navy come to light.

U.S. Navy ships

Credit: Getty Images
Surprising Science
  • U.S. Navy holds patents for enigmatic inventions by aerospace engineer Dr. Salvatore Pais.
  • Pais came up with technology that can "engineer" reality, devising an ultrafast craft, a fusion reactor, and more.
  • While mostly theoretical at this point, the inventions could transform energy, space, and military sectors.
Keep reading Show less

Are we in an AI summer or AI winter?

Neither. We are entering an AI autumn.

Credit: Jesse Chan via Unsplash
13-8
  • The history of AI shows boom periods (AI summers) followed by busts (AI winters).
  • The cyclical nature of AI funding is due to hype and promises not fulfilling expectations.
  • This time, we might enter something resembling an AI autumn rather than an AI winter, but fundamental questions remain if true AI is even possible.
Keep reading Show less

How WallStreetBets “hype” spreads among investors like a virus

A new study explores how investors' behavior is affected by participating in online communities, like Reddit's WallStreetBets.

WallStreetBets reddit page

Rafael Henrique via Adobe Stock
Mind & Brain
  • The study found evidence that "hype" over assets is psychologically contagious among investors in online communities.
  • This hype is self-perpetuating: A small group of investors hypes an asset, bringing in new investors, until growth becomes unsteady and a price crash ensues.
  • The researchers suggested that these new kinds of self-organized, social media-driven investment behaviors are unlikely to disappear anytime soon.
Keep reading Show less
Strange Maps

The ‘Lost Forty’: how a mapping error preserved an old-growth forest

A 19th-century surveying mistake kept lumberjacks away from what is now Minnesota's largest patch of old-growth trees.

Quantcast