Harmful Nonprofits Thrive With "Trickle-Down Community Engagement"

The nonprofit sector is unfairly geared toward large, mainstream organizations that take in the most money but don't adequately engage with the people most affected by a problem.

Vu Le, Executive Director of Rainier Valley Corps and a self-proclaimed nonprofit humor writer, has a great piece up on his blog all about a concept he calls "Trickle-Down Community Engagement" (TDCE). What, pray tell, does he mean by that? 

"This is when we bypass the people who are most affected by issues, engage and fund larger organizations to tackle these issues, and hope that miraculously the people most affected will help out in the effort, usually for free."

As someone who has worked extensively with/for nonprofits, Le's article hits at the heartstrings. He describes symptoms of TDCE: powerful organizations not led by people they proclaim to support, muddled goals that don't get accomplished, and "outreach" being defined as getting local community leaders to contribute for free.

There are many reasons why TDCE happens. Le points to how the nonprofit sector is unfairly geared toward large, mainstream organizations -- umbrella organizations, most often. These groups take advantage of economies of scale to maintain relationships with funders. They also too often fail to make an impact on the community level or work counterproductive to their stated goals. Their leaders -- who are more often than not making an absolute killing -- tend to dedicate themselves to accomplishing "sexy short-term goals" rather than striving for lasting positive effects.

Facing a preponderance of evidence that the American nonprofit industrial complex is broken, Le remains optimistic that things can change for the better. He stresses the importance of funders and donors to vet the institutions they invest in. If your goal is to get a building wing named after you, keep giving to those top-heavy juggernauts. If you want your money to actually reach the artists, researchers, homeless people, etc., perhaps you should consider seeking out organizations who may not have the resources to seek you out. This runs contrary to the TDCE model that employs people more intent to take your money than properly redistribute it. Of course, there's also the opportunity for inefficient or unethical mainstream organizations to reform themselves. Let's just say Le is more of an optimist on that matter than I am.

Finally, Le also has advice for organizations led by marginalized communities:

"Learn when to say yes and when to say no. I’ve seen too many small nonprofits agree to do outreach, to be partners, to even run programs for tiny amounts of funding. I’ve done it myself. My last organization, when it was much smaller, partnered with a bigger org who could not reach students of color. They asked us to organize a 2-hour workshop for over 100 diverse kids each month for a year. You know how much we got to do that? $2500 total, and we had to itemize and have receipts for every pencil we bought! The big organization who 'partnered' with us got all the credit, of course... It just perpetuates a terrible and ineffective system that continues to leave our communities behind. Learn to say no, to give feedback firmly, and to build strategic relationships."

It's a terrific article filled with smart insights, big ideas for change, and even a little hope. Read it (I've linked it again below) and let us know what you think.

Read more at Nonprofit with Balls

Photo credit: Melinda Gates (via Twitter)

Compelling speakers do these 4 things every single time

The ability to speak clearly, succinctly, and powerfully is easier than you think

Former U.S. President Barack Obama speaks during a Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee rally at the Anaheim Convention Center on September 8, 2018 in Anaheim, California. (Photo by Barbara Davidson/Getty Images)
Personal Growth

The ability to communicate effectively can make or break a person's assessment of your intelligence, competence, and authenticity.

Keep reading Show less

This 5-minute neck scan can spot dementia 10 years before it emerges

The results come from a 15-year study that used ultrasound scans to track blood vessels in middle-aged adults starting in 2002.

Mikhail Kalinin via Wikipedia
Mind & Brain
  • The study measured the stiffness of blood vessels in middle-aged patients over time.
  • Stiff blood vessels can lead to the destruction of delicate blood vessels in the brain, which can contribute to cognitive decline.
  • The scans could someday become a widely used tool to identify people at high risk of developing dementia and Alzheimer's.
Keep reading Show less

How 'dark horses' flip the script of success and happiness

What defines a dark horse? The all-important decision to pursue fulfillment and excellence.

Big Think Books

When we first set the Dark Horse Project in motion, fulfillment was the last thing on our minds. We were hoping to uncover specific and possibly idiosyncratic study methods, learning techniques, and rehearsal regimes that dark horses used to attain excellence. Our training made us resistant to ambiguous variables that were difficult to quantify, and personal fulfillment seemed downright foggy. But our training also taught us never to ignore the evidence, no matter how much it violated our expectations.

Keep reading Show less