Where's Mitt Romney Going to Come Up With $7 Trillion?

Where's Mitt Romney Going to Come Up With $7 Trillion?

Dear Readers,

I made a mistake. In the article below, I said it would take some very high rates of growth to close the $7 trillion gap in Mitt Romney's budget plan. It turns out the gap is not quite so big, depending on your assumptions. 

The critical assumption I made was that the federal government would collect 22% of gross domestic product in taxes between 2013 and 2022, instead of the 19% to 21% forecast by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). At this collection rate, it turns out that the annual rate of economic growth would only have to be higher than the CBO's forecast by about 1.5 percentage points, not 9 percentage points. If the collection rates were the same as the CBO predicted, then growth would have to be about 2.7 percentage points higher.

If we put Social Security and Medicare taxes off-limits, then we'd need growth to be about 2.5 percentage points higher than the forecast in every year from 2013 to 2022, not 16 percentage points.

I found the error in my calculations after receiving a couple of requests for my spreadsheet. Before sending it out, I decided to take a second look myself. I'm grateful to those who asked to see the figures, and I regret my error. I apologize to you and to the Romney campaign. But I would note, too, that raising the nation's annual rate of GDP growth by 2.5 percentage points or even just 1.5 is no easy feat.

Best regards,

Daniel Altman

On Sunday, Pierre Omidyar, the founder of eBay, asked a simple question on Twitter: "How much faster would economy have to grow than current projections to pay for $7 trillion Mitt Romney wants to add to deficit?"

The $7 trillion figure in the question comes from the combination of $2 trillion in new spending on defense and $5 trillion in tax cuts.  The answer, like almost anything in economics, depends on your assumptions.  But let’s try to make some reasonable ones and see where they take us.

In 2013, the economy will produce about $16 trillion in goods and services; that’s our gross domestic product (GDP).  And in good years – and we’re assuming 2013 to 2022 will be better than 2008 through 2012 – the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) collects about 19% to 21% of GDP in taxes.  It’s important to say “in good years”, because tax collections – especially from corporations – fall during economic downturns.

In the current forecast from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the economy will grow by 4.4% to 6.5% annually, without adjusting for inflation, from 2013 to 2022.  The question is, how much faster would it have to grow to collect $7 trillion more in taxes?

With faster growth will probably come higher corporate profits and bigger collections, even on a proportional basis.  So abstracting from any changes to tax rates and loopholes that Romney might implement, let’s assume that the IRS would collect 22% of GDP in taxes – not 19% to 21% – during this prolonged boom.  By itself, this assumption adds about $3 trillion to revenue over the next ten years.

Where would the other $4 trillion come from?  It would have to come from growth in the economy – a lot of growth.  In fact, by my calculations the annual growth rate of the economy would have to rise by 9 percentage points above the CBO’s current projections.  In other words, the United States would have to grow almost twice as fast as China over the coming decade in order to close the $7 trillion gap.  This is practically impossible, no matter what other improvements Romney might make in the economy.

There’s one more complication.  In 2006 and 2007, our most recent “good years”, roughly a third of the collections went to the Social Security and Medicare programs.  It’s not clear that Romney would be able to use that money to pay for his extra spending.  If he couldn’t, then economic growth would have to pick up even more to close the budget gap.  Tax collections would have to rise by about $10 trillion over the next ten years.  For that to happen, the growth rate of the economy would have to rise by 16 percentage points.  If it does, Romney will surely get the Nobel in economics!

Image credit: Shutterstock.com

How New York's largest hospital system is predicting COVID-19 spikes

Northwell Health is using insights from website traffic to forecast COVID-19 hospitalizations two weeks in the future.

Credit: Getty Images
Sponsored by Northwell Health
  • The machine-learning algorithm works by analyzing the online behavior of visitors to the Northwell Health website and comparing that data to future COVID-19 hospitalizations.
  • The tool, which uses anonymized data, has so far predicted hospitalizations with an accuracy rate of 80 percent.
  • Machine-learning tools are helping health-care professionals worldwide better constrain and treat COVID-19.
Keep reading Show less

Designer uses AI to bring 54 Roman emperors to life

It's hard to stop looking back and forth between these faces and the busts they came from.

Meet Emperors Augustus, left, and Maximinus Thrax, right

Credit: Daniel Voshart
Technology & Innovation
  • A quarantine project gone wild produces the possibly realistic faces of ancient Roman rulers.
  • A designer worked with a machine learning app to produce the images.
  • It's impossible to know if they're accurate, but they sure look plausible.
Keep reading Show less

Dark matter axions possibly found near Magnificent 7 neutron stars

A new study proposes mysterious axions may be found in X-rays coming from a cluster of neutron stars.

A rendering of the XMM-Newton (X-ray multi-mirror mission) space telescope.

Credit: D. Ducros; ESA/XMM-Newton, CC BY-SA 3.0 IGO
Surprising Science
  • A study led by Berkeley Lab suggests axions may be present near neutron stars known as the Magnificent Seven.
  • The axions, theorized fundamental particles, could be found in the high-energy X-rays emitted from the stars.
  • Axions have yet to be observed directly and may be responsible for the elusive dark matter.
  • Keep reading Show less

    Put on a happy face? “Deep acting” associated with improved work life

    New research suggests you can't fake your emotional state to improve your work life — you have to feel it.

    Credit: Columbia Pictures
    Personal Growth
  • Deep acting is the work strategy of regulating your emotions to match a desired state.
  • New research suggests that deep acting reduces fatigue, improves trust, and advances goal progress over other regulation strategies.
  • Further research suggests learning to attune our emotions for deep acting is a beneficial work-life strategy.
  • Keep reading Show less
    Surprising Science

    World's oldest work of art found in a hidden Indonesian valley

    Archaeologists discover a cave painting of a wild pig that is now the world's oldest dated work of representational art.

    Scroll down to load more…