Atheist Churches? Come now, Mr. Dennett!
A reaction to Daniel Dennett's suggestion
In a recent video posted on Big Think, Daniel Dennett suggested that secularists should band together and form organizations along the lines of churches to provide a supportive "community" for non-believers. He noted that the "community, loving, and care" provided by religion are a "good thing." He said, with a somewhat wistful twinge in his voice: "Sometimes when there is nobody around to love you and take care of you, it's great to have a group that you can be welcomed into." He went on to speak of "churches without dogmas" that provide a "community of care, helping the world" and of "credalists organization that do a lot of good work," and suggested that these can serve as a model for secularist churches.
I find this rather difficult to swallow.
First, can a church "without dogmas" properly be called a "church"? What would distinguish such an institution from other charitable and social-uplift organizations such as Oxfam, UNICEF, CARE, the Salvation Army, and so on? If all it does is "good works," then it is no different from secular organizations that do "good works." And if it is no different from secular organizations, then why call it a church? The very essence of "church-hood" is the adherence to a unique set of beliefs about God, man, and the world. What holds the church community together is the common set of beliefs shared by its members, beliefs that are held as a condition of membership. One cannot get baptized into a church without affirming the dogmas of that church. A church without dogmas is as unthinkable as a brothel without prostitutes. I wonder what Dennett would say to a brothel whose inmates did not engage in sex in exchange for money, but went around feeding the poor instead, or provided in-home care for bed-ridden old men. I wonder if he would still call it a brothel.
Second, the moment atheists (or agnostics, or secularists) form a church-like community, atheism (or agnosticism, or secularism) will devolve into a religion. This is precisely what atheism (or secularism) is against. Atheists are atheists because their atheism gives them the freedom to think what they like; it does not bind them to any particular set of beliefs. A "church" of atheists would immediately turn atheism into a system of beliefs and would require adherence to those beliefs as a condition of membership. This is the very antithesis of atheism.
Third, I find it rather mercenary to want to be a memeber of a church or similar "community" merely for the sake of having someone to love you and take care of you when all else fails. Christians are required to love one another by the tenets of their faith (and, of course, by the express injunction of Christ to do so). But Christians are not members of a church simply in order to have someone to love and take care of them in time of need—or at least they should not be. That would be a prostitution of Christianity. Christians are (or should be) members of whatever church they attend because they are followers of Christ, regardless of whether they will have someone to fall back on when they are destitute. The love and caring of the Christian community (such as it is) is merely a side benefit—the icing on the cake, if you will.
Loving and caring can and does occur across religious and sectarian lines. In countless communities around the world, Muslims show caring for their Christian and Jewish neighbours, and Hindus help Sikhs, and Catholics and Protestants come to the aid of each other in time of need, and non-believers take care of their religiously inclined fellow community members when it is called for. Churches don't have a monoploy on loving and caring.
The last thing the world needs now is yet another church. And the last thing that non-believers need is to mimic the behaviour of their believing counterparts. Anyone who does not have the courage (or strength) to be an atheist entirely on his or her own, even in the face of opposition from the entire rest of the human race, is not worthy of being an atheist. If you want community support, go become a Christian! After all, there already are, according to Dennett, "churches without dogmas," so a non-believer or secularist, according to him, should fit right in at some such institution. Where, then, is the need for secularist churches?
Atheist churches? Come now, Mr. Dennett!
Malcolm Gladwell teaches "Get over yourself and get to work" for Big Think Edge.
- Learn to recognize failure and know the big difference between panicking and choking.
- At Big Think Edge, Malcolm Gladwell teaches how to check your inner critic and get clear on what failure is.
- Subscribe to Big Think Edge before we launch on March 30 to get 20% off monthly and annual memberships.
Neuroscience research suggests it might be time to rethink our ideas about when exactly a child becomes an adult.
- Research suggests that most human brains take about 25 years to develop, though these rates can vary among men and women, and among individuals.
- Although the human brain matures in size during adolescence, important developments within the prefrontal cortex and other regions still take pace well into one's 20s.
- The findings raise complex ethical questions about the way our criminal justice systems punishes criminals in their late teens and early 20s.
Three scientists publish a paper proving that Mercury, not Venus, is the closest planet to Earth.
- Earth is the third planet from the Sun, so our closest neighbor must be planet two or four, right?
- Wrong! Neither Venus nor Mars is the right answer.
- Three scientists ran the numbers. In this YouTube video, one of them explains why our nearest neighbor is... Mercury!
A new method of growing mini-brains produces some startling results.
- Researchers find a new and inexpensive way to keep organoids growing for a year.
- Axons from the study's organoids attached themselves to embryonic mouse spinal cord cells.
- The mini-brains took control of muscles connected to the spinal cords.
SMARTER FASTER trademarks owned by The Big Think, Inc. All rights reserved.