How Battlestar Galactica Lost Sight of Its Realism and Disappointed Fans

When I was in graduate school at Cornell, David Kirby was a course mate while he was working on a post-doc in science studies. Kirby was re-training from his former field as a geneticist, researching the influence of science consultants on major motion pictures.

One of his conclusions--published in a paper at the Social Studies of Science--was that science consultants are important to filmmakers because they can help lend a sense of realism and perceived legitimacy to a film, especially among the opinion-setting audience base who shape the success of a film via word-of-mouth and online buzz.

On the other hand, scientists benefit as consultants because the film offers a major vehicle for promoting to other scientists (and funders) their expertise and views on an area of emerging science, enable a consultant to argue for their own interpretations in an ongoing scientific debate (think dinosaurs-as-birds in Jurassic Park), and/or provide a consultant the opportunity to visualize ideas about future developments and technologies. In other words, scientists watch movies and read news coverage, so consulting on films can be an important way to influence colleagues.

I was thinking of David Kirby's line of research when my brother Erik sent me this excellent essay on the hit TV series Battlestar Galactica. The central premise of the essay is that the series-- which so delighted viewers and TV critics in its first few years--ended up disappointing its fan base precisely because it broke with its deep anchor in realism. As "Brad" the essayist explains, the series departed from realism on several key dimensions:

The confirmation/revelation of an intervening god as the driving force behind events

The use of that god to resolve large numbers of major plot points

A number of significant scientific mistakes on major plot points, including:

Twisting the whole story to fit a completely wrong idea of what Mitochondrial Eve is

To support that concept, an impossible-to-credit political shift among the characters

The use of concepts from Intelligent Design to resolve plot issues.

The introduction of the nonsense idea of "collective unconscious" to explain cultural similarities.

The use of "big secrets" to dominate what was supposed to be a character-driven story

Removing all connection to our reality by trying to build a poorly constructed one

Mistakes, one of them major and never corrected, which misled the audience


Check out the essay. It's worth considering. Kirby's work makes for even better reading.

'Upstreamism': Your zip code affects your health as much as genetics

Upstreamism advocate Rishi Manchanda calls us to understand health not as a "personal responsibility" but a "common good."

Sponsored by Northwell Health
  • Upstreamism tasks health care professionals to combat unhealthy social and cultural influences that exist outside — or upstream — of medical facilities.
  • Patients from low-income neighborhoods are most at risk of negative health impacts.
  • Thankfully, health care professionals are not alone. Upstreamism is increasingly part of our cultural consciousness.
Keep reading Show less

Elizabeth Warren's plan to forgive student loan debt could lead to an economic boom

A plan to forgive almost a trillion dollars in debt would solve the student loan debt crisis, but can it work?

Photo credit: Drew Angerer / Getty Images
Politics & Current Affairs
  • Sen. Elizabeth Warren has just proposed a bold education reform plan that would forgive billions in student debt.
  • The plan would forgive the debt held by more than 30 million Americans.
  • The debt forgiveness program is one part of a larger program to make higher education more accessible.
Keep reading Show less

Banned books: 10 of the most-challenged books in America

America isn't immune to attempts to remove books from libraries and schools, here are ten frequent targets and why you ought to go check them out.

Nazis burn books on a huge bonfire of 'anti-German' literature in the Opernplatz, Berlin. (Photo by Keystone/Getty Images)
Culture & Religion
  • Even in America, books are frequently challenged and removed from schools and public libraries.
  • Every year, the American Library Association puts on Banned Books Week to draw attention to this fact.
  • Some of the books they include on their list of most frequently challenged are some of the greatest, most beloved, and entertaining books there are.
Keep reading Show less

Supreme Court to hear 3 cases on LGBT workplace discrimination

In most states, LGBTQ Americans have no legal protections against discrimination in the workplace.

(Photo by Andres Pantoja/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)
Politics & Current Affairs
  • The Supreme Court will decide whether the Civil Rights Act of 1964 also applies to gay and transgender people.
  • The court, which currently has a probable conservative majority, will likely decide on the cases in 2020.
  • Only 21 states and the District of Columbia have passed laws effectively extending the Civil Rights of 1964 to gay and transgender people.
Keep reading Show less