David Goggins
Former Navy Seal
Career Development
Bryan Cranston
Critical Thinking
Liv Boeree
International Poker Champion
Emotional Intelligence
Amaryllis Fox
Former CIA Clandestine Operative
Chris Hadfield
Retired Canadian Astronaut & Author
from the world's big
Start Learning

A Dangerous Method: Jung, Freud, and the Pursuit of Scientific Legitimacy

--Guest post by Declan Fahy, AoE’s Science and Culture correspondent.

Writer David Milch, a creator of NYPD Blue and Deadwood, was quoted in a talk by author Michael Crichton as saying that the scientific method was antithetical to storytelling. The point was that that the painstaking process of data-collection, theorizing and analysis was just too slow to make for a compelling narrative, especially on screen.

But A Dangerous Method, a film about the beginnings of a radical new way of addressing emotional crises that went on to be known as psychoanalysis, makes the scientific method a central part of its compelling narrative.

The movie, directed by David Cronenberg, focuses on the complex relationship between Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung as they developed their path-breaking original theories in Europe in the early decades of the twentieth century.

And some of the most interesting parts of the film were its depictions of the application of Freud’s new “talking cure” and the ways in which psychoanalysis sought scientific legitimacy.

The film’s opening sequence shows how this novel treatment was applied, as Jung sits behind and listens to the verbalized, anguished feelings of 18 year-old woman Sabina Spielrein, who was admitted in 1904 to Jung’s Burgholzli clinic in Zurich suffering from hysteria.

The new method is shown to gradually liberate her mind and awaken her interest in psychiatry. (Though Terrence Rafferty in The New York Times argued that the film was another problematic example of movies that examined the psychology of women, rather than men).

In another scene, as part of her therapy, Jung recruits Spielrein to assist him in evaluating the free associations of his wife, as he reads her a series of words.  See clip below.

As well as showing Jung attempt to apply the scientific method to his work, the film’s smart dialogue shows how the theoretical basis of the new field developed. One of the best scenes is the initial intense meeting between Freud and Jung that began with a frank discussion of psychoanalytic terminology at the dinner table and continued for 13 hours, as their views were refined, questioned, and sharpened.

The two men are now iconic figures in the intellectual history of psychiatry, but the film excellently presents the early stages of their work, when neither is sure what would happen to their work next. As Freud told Jung, comparing himself to Christopher Columbus: “I've set my feet on the shore and the country exists.”

Portrayed as a carefully-analytical logician, Freud initially saw Jung as his intellectual heir. But, concerned with keeping the field’s development within the boundaries of what his contemporary critics would deem scientific, he despaired at Jung’s interest in the mystical and metaphysical. As their intellectual paths diverged, their relationship soured, as each attempted to claim authority within the field for their viewpoints.

Psychoanalysis has a contentious status as a contemporary science, but it is nevertheless embedded in the intellectual history of the west, and one of this movie’s strengths is its vivid dramatization of the critical years in which the field originated. Psychoanalysis did not just emerge fully-formed. It was developed in distinct historical situations by flesh-and-blood humans, battling for status, wealth and influence.

A Dangerous Method is an example of how the scientific method is not antithetical to storytelling. Similarly, in 2002 PBS made a film version of Michael Frayn’s play Copenhagen, which presented a dramatization of the development of quantum theory. But apart from these, what other movies successfully depicted the origins of a field of science, as well as explaining its methods and impacts? Is it that difficult to do?

--Declan Fahy is Assistant Professor at the School of Communication, American University, Washington, DC. Read other posts by Fahy and find out more about the MA program in Journalism and Public Affairs and the doctoral program in Communication at American.

LIVE EVENT | Radical innovation: Unlocking the future of human invention

Innovation in manufacturing has crawled since the 1950s. That's about to speed up.

Big Think LIVE

Add event to calendar

AppleGoogleOffice 365OutlookOutlook.comYahoo

Keep reading Show less

Two MIT students just solved Richard Feynman’s famed physics puzzle

Richard Feynman once asked a silly question. Two MIT students just answered it.

Surprising Science

Here's a fun experiment to try. Go to your pantry and see if you have a box of spaghetti. If you do, take out a noodle. Grab both ends of it and bend it until it breaks in half. How many pieces did it break into? If you got two large pieces and at least one small piece you're not alone.

Keep reading Show less

Unfiltered lessons of a female entrepreneur

Join Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter and best-selling author Charles Duhigg as he interviews Victoria Montgomery Brown, co-founder and CEO of Big Think.

Big Think LIVE

Women today are founding more businesses than ever. In 2018, they made up 40% of new entrepreneurs, yet in that same year, they received just 2.2% of all venture capital investment. The playing field is off-balance. So what can women do?

Keep reading Show less

Why ‘Christian nationalists’ are less likely to wear masks and social distance

In a recent study, researchers examined how Christian nationalism is affecting the U.S. response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

A Catholic priest wearing a facemask and face shield blesses a hospital on August 6, 2020 in Manila, Philippines

Ezra Acayan/Getty Images
  • A new study used survey data to examine the interplay between Christian nationalism and incautious behaviors during the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • The researchers defined Christian nationalism as "an ideology that idealizes and advocates a fusion of American civic life with a particular type of Christian identity and culture."
  • The results showed that Christian nationalism was the leading predictor that Americans engaged in incautious behavior.
Keep reading Show less
Sex & Relationships

Two-thirds of parents say technology makes parenting harder

Parental anxieties stem from the complex relationship between technology, child development, and the internet's trove of unseemly content.

Scroll down to load more…