What Secrets Did Shakespeare Take to the Grave?

What secrets did Shakespeare take to his grave 400 years ago?  Are the plays the thing to unlock the mysteries of literature’s king?

“Alas, poor Yorick!” Hamlet says in the famous graveyard scene from William Shakespeare’s play. “I knew him, Horatio.”  Most people misquote the line as “I knew him well,” but Hamlet didn’t say that.  Neither do we know Hamlet’s creator “well,” now 400 years after he shook off that mortal coil to venture off to that undiscovered country from which no traveler returns.  Shakespeare, whose works live on in nearly every human language (and even in the “original” Klingon), remains an impenetrable mystery in death.  What secrets did Shakespeare take to his grave four centuries ago on April 23, 1616?  Are the plays the thing to unlock the mysteries of literature’s king?


 

  • Image: The Ashbourne Portrait of Shakespeare, 16th century. Originally thought to have been of William Shakespeare, the painting is now thought to be a lost Cornelius Ketel portrait of Edward de Vere, 17th earl of Oxford. Illustration from Hutchinson’s Story of the British Nation. (Photo by The Print Collector/Print Collector/Getty Images)
  • Of all the things that we think we know about Shakespeare but really don’t, what stands out to me is the question of what he looked like.  If you thought the portrait above shows Shakespeare, you’re not alone.  Many believed it the Bard until the 1930s, when scholars suggested it showed instead Edward de Vere, 17th earl of Oxford, whom many know as one of the suspects in the great “Shakespeare authorship question,” along with Christopher Marlowe, Sir Francis Bacon, and William Stanley, 6th Earl of Derby (among others).  In fact, it’s this fact-free Shakespeare biography that still inspires screen atrocities such as 2011’s Anonymous, whose poster asked “Was Shakespeare a fraud?” while suggesting de Vere was really “Shakespeare.”  Such lingering doubts and half-baked theorizing compel scholars to keep digging and looking for Shakespeare’s secrets.

  • Image: A painting of William Shakespeare which is believed to be the only authentic image of Shakespeare made during his life is unveiled by The Shakespeare Birthplace Trust on March 9, 2009 in London, England. The recently discovered painting, which is believed to date from around 1610, depicts Shakespeare in his mid-forties. The portrait is due to go on display at The Shakespeare Birthplace Trust in Stratford-upon-Avon on April 23, 2009. (Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images)
  • Sometimes that digging hits hidden pay dirt.  As recently as 2009, experts determined that a new portrait, called the Cobbe Portrait (shown above), was the first discovered from Shakespeare’s lifetime and possibly painted from life (unlike other posthumous portraits reputably of him).  New documents related to Shakespeare’s life, however, remain elusive, a strange problem for a man who made his money as a writer.  In fact, the lone manuscript page we have believed to be in Shakespeare’s own hand belongs to a play never produced during his lifetime, the collaborative work Sir Thomas More.  Too politically hot for Jacobean England, Sir Thomas More may not have hit the stage until 1922.

     

  • Image: Stephen Greenblatt, a Shakespeare biographer at the Folger Shakespeare Library in Washington DC. (Photo by Juana Arias/The Washington Post/Getty Images)
  • Lacking evidence, how can we “know” Shakespeare?  We can make educated guesses.  Some highly educated guesses came from Shakespearean scholar Stephen Greenblatt (shown above) in his 2005 best-selling “biography” Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare. Both informative and entertaining, Greenblatt navigates you through the tangled mess of centuries of Shakespearean legend and scholarship with highly probable ideas about the Bard that, absent absolute certainty, are better than nothing at all.  Other scholars criticized Greenblatt for stretching the thin documentation we have too far, but, again, for those with a hunger for knowing what Shakespeare’s world may have been like, Greenblatt serves up a tasty meal.

     

  • Image: A Sotheby’s employee handles a copy of William Shakespeare, The First Folio 1623 on July 7, 2006 in London, England. The most important book in English Literature, the First Folio edition of Shakespeare’s plays (1623), will be offered in Sotheby’s sale of English Literature & History on July 13th, and is estimated to fetch GBP 2.5-3.5 million. (Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)
  • Greenblatt, of course, like every other scholar, makes extensive use of Shakespeare’s writings, the history of which begins with the “holy grail” of English Literature, The First Folio of 1623 (shown above).  Error ridden and revised later on, the texts of the plays in The First Folio remain the starting point for any digging into the mystery of Shakespeare.  As Ron Rosenbaum pointed out, references to skin, gloves, and glove-making abound in the plays, unsurprising for the son of a tanner and glove maker.  Such nuggets mined from the texts help scholars fight back the authorship question “truthers” while allowing us to think we know how Shakespeare thought.  Books such as Jonathan Bate’s Soul of the Age: The Life, Mind and World of William Shakespeare offer fascinating suppositions, but, in the end, remain purely guesswork, no matter how erudite.

  • Image: Circa 1900: A death mask thought to be that of English dramatist William Shakespeare (1566 - 1616). Found by Dr Ludwig Becker in Mainz in 1849, the mask was linked to Shakespeare because of its 1616 date and its supposed facial resemblance to the writer. A rival theory, however, maintains that the mask is more likely to be that of English poet Ben Jonson. (Photo by Hulton Archive/Getty Images)
  • Alas, every time we think we have Shakespeare in our hands, he slips through our fingers.  Imagine finding the Bard’s death mask (shown above), only to have it disproven by scholars.  For years, “truthers” believed the secrets were actually buried with the body and begged for an exhumation.  When filmmakers recently scanned the grave with radar they actually found a surprising secret—the playwright’s head is missing (probably taken by graverobbers long ago).

    Personally, the one theorized Shakespeare “secret” I find the most fascinating is the possibility that Shakespeare was secretly Catholic (or held Catholic sympathies)—a dangerous thing during the religious tumult of England during his lifetime. If he were Catholic, Shakespeare would have avoided committing that belief to paper, which perhaps explains the lack of a diary or other personal writings.  But it would add an interesting dimension to his involvement in the controversial Sir Thomas More, the story of the Catholic saint.  And what is the nature of that monologue we have in Shakespeare’s handwriting?  Shakespeare has More talk of the plight of outsiders, specifically Huguenot refugees of religious intolerance:

    Imagine that you see the wretched strangers,

    Their babies at their backs and their poor luggage,

    Plodding tooth ports and costs for transportation,

    And that you sit as kings in your desires,

    Authority quite silent by your brawl,

    And you in ruff of your opinions clothed

     

    When Shakespeare paints in words a picture of Catholic Huguenot refugees with “babies at their backs” and lugging “poor luggage” before the uncaring glare of the Protestant English, it’s not hard to see today’s Syrian refugees and others displaced by religious strife.  Perhaps the real “secret” Shakespeare took to his grave was an essential humanity founded in the recognition of others’ humanity.  For Shakespeare, the greatest test of our humanity is acknowledging the humanity of the lowest outsider—the Catholic in Anglican England, the persecuted Jew, the refugee far from home.  That’s a secret we should all share today.

  • [Image at top of post: A scene from a film version of Hamlet directed by Grigori Kozintsev and starring Innokenti Smoktunovsky as Hamlet (shown above with Yorick’s skull), the score was composed by Dimitry Shostakovich.  (Photo by: Sovfoto/UIG via Getty Images)]
  • [Please follow me on Twitter (@BobDPictureThis) and Facebook (Art Blog By Bob) for more art news and views.]
  • Trying to spot China’s green energy tipping point

    Pay attention to the decisions made by the provinces.

    Surprising Science
    • China leads the world in numerous green energy categories.
    • CO2 emissions in the country totaling more than all coal emissions in the U.S. have recently emerged.
    • This seems to be an administrative-induced blip on the way towards a green energy tipping point.
    Keep reading Show less

    Got a question for a real NASA astronomer? Ask it here!

    NASA astronomer Michelle Thaller is coming back to Big Think to answer YOUR questions! Here's all you need to know to submit your science-related inquiries.

    Surprising Science

    Big Think's amazing audience has responded so well to our videos from NASA astronomer and Assistant Director for Science Communication Michelle Thaller that we couldn't wait to bring her back for more!

    And this time, she's ready to tackle any questions you're willing to throw at her, like, "How big is the Universe?", "Am I really made of stars?" or, "How long until Elon Musk starts a colony on Mars?"

    All you have to do is submit your questions to the form below, and we'll use them for an upcoming Q+A session with Michelle. You know what to do, Big Thinkers!

    Keep reading Show less

    Cancer researcher says keto is not a fad diet

    Anatomy and physiology professor David Harper claims a recent study in The Lancet is flawed.

    Photo: Shutterstock
    Surprising Science
    • The low-carbohydrate group in a recent Lancet study were typically middle-aged, obese, sedentary, diabetic smokers.
    • The study was not a randomized, controlled, double-blind experiment.
    • Harper has been in ketosis for six years, and says it has profound effects on cancer patients, among other chronic ailments.
    Keep reading Show less

    Take the Big Think survey for a chance to win :)

    Calling all big thinkers!

    • Tell us a little bit about where you find Big Think's videos, articles, and podcasts.
    • Be entered for a chance to win 1 of 3 Amazon gift cards each worth $100.
    • All survey information is anonymous and will be used only for this survey.
    Keep reading Show less

    Elon Musk says Boring Company tunnel opens Dec. 10

    The Boring Company plans to offer free rides in its prototype tunnel in Hawthorne, California in December.

    Image: Claudia Soraya
    Technology & Innovation
    • The prototype tunnel is about 2 miles long and contains electric skates that travel at top speeds of around 150 mph.
    • This is the first tunnel from the company that will be open to the public.
    • If successful, the prototype could help the company receive regulatory approval for much bigger projects in L.A. and beyond.
    Keep reading Show less

    Are you a Boltzmann Brain? Why nothing in the Universe may be real

    A mind-bending paradox questions the nature of reality.

    Pixabay
    Surprising Science
    • Boltzmann Brains are hypothetical disembodied entities with self-awareness.
    • It may be more likely for a Boltzmann Brain to come into existence than the whole Universe.
    • The idea highlights a paradox in thermodynamics.
    Keep reading Show less
    Mind & Brain
    • When it comes to educating, says Dr. Elizabeth Alexander, a brave failure is preferable to timid success.
    • Fostering an environment where one isn't afraid to fail is tantamount to learning.
    • Human beings are complicated and flawed. Working with those complications and flaws leads to true knowledge.
    Keep reading Show less

    What is kalsarikänni? The Finnish art of being "pantsdrunk"

    Drinking home alone in your underwear just might be what you need to be as relaxed as the Finnish.

    Big Think art department / Finnish tourism department
    Personal Growth
    • Päntsdrunk is the latest trend to come out of Northern Europe and it involves drinking alone at home.
    • Finnish writer Miska Rantanen outlines the philosophy in his newest book titled: Pantsdrunk: Kalsarikanni: The Finnish Path to Relaxation.
    • Kalsarikänni is a word in Finnish that literally means "drinking at home and alone in your underwear."
    Keep reading Show less