Cory Booker, Kim Jong Il, and Stalin

Cory Booker, Kim Jong Il, and Stalin

If I were trapped in a burning building, here's who I would want to see coming up the smoke-filled stairwell: A trained professional firefighter in full gear. Not Mayor Bloomberg. Nothing against the mayor, but a healthy democratic society protects its people with institutions, not the magic powers of a superhero leader. As Corey Robin points out in this very smart post, there are societies that celebrate their leaders for doing everyone's job: Stalin's Russia was one. North Korea is another. And so he sees the sadness at the heart of what is supposed to be the feel-good story of the weekend: Newark Mayor Cory Booker rushes into his neighbor's burning house to save her, suffering burns and smoke inhalation for his trouble. Vigilantism in a democracy is a sign that public institutions aren't trusted. Are we really supposed to feel all warm inside about that?


Granted, vigilantes sometimes luck out, which is what happened after Booker didn't wait for firefighters. Sometimes, though, things turn out badly (as when George Zimmerman didn't wait for the cops). The outcome of each particular anecdote doesn't affect the larger point, which, as Robin writes, is this: "Booker is a stand-in, a compensation in this case for a public sector that doesn’t work. And the reason it doesn’t work—the reason we put more stock in the antics of a Batman Mayor than a well paid and well trained city employee—is that we’ve made it not work: through tax cuts, privatization, and outsourcing, policies that Booker himself often supports."

Robin is especially alarmed about the lionization of Booker because he is the mayor. The leader who can magically reach down into the common people and do everyone's job is the leader of a cult of personality. (Think of all those photos of Kim Jong Il giving "field guidance" to farmers, chemical engineers and fighter pilots.) And such a cult thrives because society is hollowed out, its people and its normal institutions reduced to helplessness. Robin quotes Slavoj Žižek on Stalin: "What this Leader’s intervention in everyday life means is that things do not function on the most everyday level—what kind of country is this, in which the supreme Leader himself has to dispense advice about how to repair tractors?"

Cory Booker is a brave man who probably moved on instinct and didn't think that he might be setting a bad example ("while the heroics of the mayor are unparalleled, we don’t encourage people to run into burning buildings," said the head of Newark's Fire Department). But Robin is right: getting all giddy about this is a sad sign of decline.

Photo: A costume on sale at the Superhero Supply Store in Brooklyn (which does heroic real-world work as a tutoring center)

New study says cosmic acceleration and dark energy don't exist

An Oxford scientist claims a Nobel-Prize-winning conclusion is wrong.

Type la supernova remnant

NASA
Surprising Science
  • Paper by Oxford University physicist Subir Sarkar and his colleagues challenges how conclusions about cosmic acceleration and dark energy were reached.
  • Physicists who proved cosmic acceleration shared a Nobel Prize.
  • Sarkar used statistical analysis to question key data, but his methodology also has detractors.
Keep reading Show less

Why the US must break the grip of huge monopolies

Monopolies wield an immense amount of economic and political power and influence. So what can we do to make the economy more equitable?

Videos
  • According to Vanderbilt law professor and author Ganesh Sitaraman, America has a monopoly problem—a problem that is almost universally acknowledged as such, yet little is done about it.
  • Sitaraman explains how monopolies of today share DNA with trusts of the 19th century, and how the increased concentration and consolidation of these corporations translates to increased power both economically and politically.
  • "We need to think about reinvigorating our anti-trust laws and the principles of anti-monopoly that gave spirit to those laws and to lots of other regulations," he argues. Restoring faith in government and the economy starts with dismantling the things that make people question its allegiances and priorities.
Keep reading Show less

Average human body temperature mysteriously declined, finds study

A new study seeks to understand why the average body temperature is no longer 98.6 degrees Fahrenheit.

Man swims in icy water in the Moskva river in Moscow.

Credit: MAXIM MARMUR/AFP via Getty Images
Surprising Science
  • Average human body temperatures have declined, show several studies.
  • A new paper looked at an indigenous population in the Amazon over 16 years.
  • They found the new body temperature of the observed people to be 97.7°F, not the standard 98.6°F.
Keep reading Show less
Mind & Brain

One is the loneliest number: the history of a Western problem

The negative associations of introversion help to explain why loneliness now carries such social stigma.

Scroll down to load more…
Quantcast